AML consumer data

Consumer Rights Act: fair terms in agency contracts

How the Consumer Rights Act tests estate and letting agency terms: fairness, transparency and prominence, the grey list and the clauses most at risk.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Who the Act protects in agency work
  2. The fairness test
  3. Transparency and prominence: the fee exemption
  4. The grey list, applied to agency terms
  5. Clauses that deserve a hard look
  6. What happens when a term fails
  7. Transparency starts before the contract
  8. Lettings documents need the same scrutiny
  9. A quick fairness review of your terms
  10. Example: a withdrawal fee dispute
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • An unfair term in a consumer contract is not binding on the consumer, though the consumer can still rely on it if they choose[1].
  • Fees escape a fairness review only if the term is both transparent and prominent, so an average consumer would be aware of it[2].
  • The Act's grey list includes automatic extensions with unreasonably early deadlines and disproportionate charges on cancellation[3].
  • Consumers win often: The Property Ombudsman decided 61% of its 2025 cases in the consumer's favour[4].

Who the Act protects in agency work

Most agency clients are consumers. A homeowner selling their house, an accidental landlord letting a single flat and a tenant signing an application are individuals acting outside their trade, so the Consumer Rights Act 2015 applies to the terms you ask them to accept. Portfolio landlords trading through companies may not be consumers, but many smaller landlords are, and the safest approach is to draft every standard set of terms as if a consumer will sign it.

The stakes are reputational as well as legal. Only 37% of people say they trust estate agents[5], and a seller who discovers an unexpected fee on withdrawal rarely forgives the agency, whatever the small print says.

The fairness test

An unfair term of a consumer contract is not binding on the consumer[1]. A term is unfair if, contrary to the requirement of good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations to the consumer's detriment[1]. Fairness is judged by looking at the subject matter of the contract and all the circumstances when the term was agreed, including the other terms[1].

Two features of the test matter for agencies. First, it looks at the effect of the term, not your intentions or how you usually apply it. A clause you never enforce can still be unfair. Second, the consumer keeps the choice: they can rely on a term if it suits them, even if it is unfair to them[1]. So an unfair term can only hurt the business that drafted it.

Transparency and prominence: the fee exemption

There is an important exception. A term cannot be assessed for fairness to the extent that it specifies the main subject matter of the contract or the assessment is about whether the price is appropriate for the service[2]. That protects your commission rate from an argument that it is simply too high. But the exemption only applies if the term is transparent and prominent[2].

  • Transparent means expressed in plain and intelligible language and, for written terms, legible[2].
  • Prominent means brought to the consumer's attention in a way that an average consumer would be aware of the term[2].
  • The average consumer is reasonably well-informed, observant and circumspect[2], not a lawyer reading every clause.

A commission rate on the first page of a one-page summary, explained by the valuer and initialled by the seller, is likely to be transparent and prominent. A withdrawal fee on page seven in small grey text is not, and it can then be tested for fairness.

The grey list, applied to agency terms

Schedule 2 of the Act lists terms that may be regarded as unfair. They are not automatically unfair, but they attract scrutiny. Several map directly onto common agency clauses.

Schedule 2 grey list items and similar agency clauses[3] (practitioner mapping, not legal advice)
Grey list itemAgency clause it resemblesLower-risk drafting
Requiring a disproportionately high sum when the consumer decides not to go aheadLarge fixed withdrawal fees on a sole agencyCharge only documented costs actually incurred, stated upfront
Automatically extending a fixed-term contract where the deadline to stop it is unreasonably earlySole agency periods that roll over unless the seller gives notice weeks in advanceShort, clear notice periods and a reminder before any extension
Binding the consumer to terms they had no real chance to read before signingTerms sent after the valuation, or signed on a tablet at the doorSend terms in advance and allow time to read them
Letting the trader change terms without a valid reason specified in the contractClauses allowing fee changes at the agency's discretionFix fees for the agreement; state the reasons and notice for any change
Letting the trader increase the price without a right to cancelMid-contract increases to management feesGive a right to end without penalty if fees rise
Allowing the trader to cancel at will but not the consumerOne-sided termination rights in management agreementsMirror the notice rights for both parties

Clauses that deserve a hard look

Beyond the grey list, some agency clauses regularly cause disputes because their effect is not what a consumer expects.

  • Commission on introductions: wording that makes a seller pay commission if they later sell to anyone you introduced, with no time limit, can produce results a seller would never anticipate. Limit the period and define introduction clearly.
  • Ready, willing and able purchaser clauses: these can make commission payable even if no sale happens. They need especially clear explanation and, under estate agency rules, specific wording.
  • Renewal and extension fees in lettings: fees payable to an agent when a tenant stays on, long after the agent's tenant-find role ended, are a classic source of landlord complaints. Make them prominent and proportionate, or drop them.
  • Termination charges on management agreements: a fee for ending management early should reflect real costs, not penalise the landlord for leaving.
  • Fees described differently in different documents: a rate on the website, another in the proposal and a third in the terms undermines transparency at once.

Our guide to agency terms of business covers drafting the whole document; this section is about the clauses most likely to fail a fairness test.

What happens when a term fails

If a term is unfair, it simply does not bind the consumer, while the rest of the contract usually continues[1]. In practice, the test rarely reaches a court. It is applied by redress schemes, trading standards and, sometimes, small claims judges, and it shapes how complaints are settled.

Redress outcomes show how often consumers succeed. The Property Ombudsman decided 61% of its 2025 cases in the consumer's favour[4]. The average award was £616 in sales cases and £497 in lettings cases[6][7]. Those sums are small compared with a disputed commission, but they add up, and a pattern of complaints about the same clause invites wider scrutiny.

Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025
Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Bar chart. Sales cases: £616; Lettings cases: £497.Sales casesSales cases: £616£616Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£497Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Bar chart. Sales cases: £616; Lettings cases: £497.Sales casesSales cases: £616£616Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£497

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Sales cases£616
Lettings cases£497

Transparency starts before the contract

Fairness and transparency are linked to how you present fees and terms throughout the sales process, not just in the signed document. National Trading Standards has said that price on application in property listings is unlawful[8], which reflects a wider expectation that consumers get material information early and in plain language.

  1. Put the deal on one page

    A short summary of commission or fees, the agreement type, the length, the notice period and any charges on withdrawal, given before the full terms.

  2. Explain it in the appointment

    The valuer walks through the summary and notes that it was explained.

  3. Send terms in advance

    Email the full terms before signature, with time to read them; avoid signing at the door.

  4. Use the same words everywhere

    Website, proposal, summary and terms describe fees identically.

  5. Remind before extensions

    Write to the client before any automatic extension and explain how to stop it.

Lettings documents need the same scrutiny

Lettings agencies have two sets of consumer-facing terms: the landlord's management or tenant-find agreement and the documents tenants sign. Both can contain terms that fail the fairness test, and tenant-facing documents are also constrained by tenant fees and renting rules that limit what can be charged at all.

  • Landlord agreements: check fee changes, termination notice, charges for ending management early and any fees that continue after the agency stops acting.
  • Tenant application forms: avoid terms that make tenants responsible for costs they cannot control or that conflict with the rules on holding deposits.
  • Tenancy agreements prepared for landlords: an unfair term in the landlord's tenancy will rebound on the agency that drafted it.
  • Guarantor deeds: guarantors are consumers too, and broad open-ended guarantees deserve plain explanation.

A quick fairness review of your terms

  1. Read each fee and charge as a seller or landlord seeing it for the first time. Would they be surprised by it later?
  2. Check whether every fee appears in the one-page summary, in the same words as the terms.
  3. Look for any clause that lets only the agency end, extend or change the agreement.
  4. Compare each cancellation or withdrawal charge with the costs you actually incur.
  5. Check that notice periods and automatic extensions are short, clear and reminded in writing.
  6. Record the review date and who carried it out, and repeat it whenever you change the terms.

Example: a withdrawal fee dispute

Example (fictional): a seller withdraws after six weeks of a twelve-week sole agency. The agency's terms charge a fixed withdrawal fee equal to a large share of the commission. The seller says nobody mentioned it; the fee sits in clause 14 on page five, in the same font as everything else.

In this example, the agency cannot rely on the price exemption because the term was not prominent, so the fee is open to a fairness assessment, and as a disproportionate charge on cancellation it resembles a grey list item. The agency settles by charging its documented marketing costs, then redrafts: a one-page summary now shows the withdrawal charge as a list of actual costs, the valuer explains it in the appointment, and complaints about withdrawal stop.

Frequently asked questions

Can a seller challenge our commission rate as unfair?

Not on the ground that it is too high, provided the term is transparent and prominent[2]. If the rate is hidden or unclear, that protection falls away.

Are tie-in periods unfair?

Not in themselves. Automatic extensions with an unreasonably early deadline to stop them appear on the grey list[3], so keep periods clear and remind clients before any extension.

Does the Act apply to landlords?

It applies where the landlord is a consumer, typically an individual letting one or a few properties outside a trade. Draft standard terms as though consumers will sign them.

What happens if one clause is unfair?

That clause does not bind the consumer, but the rest of the contract usually continues[1].

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 62: Requirement for contract terms and notices to be fair (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 64: Exclusion from assessment of fairness (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, Schedule 2: Consumer contract terms which may be regarded as unfair (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. National Trading Standards (2022). NTS Estate Agency and NTS Letting Agency Teams (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo