AML consumer data

The fake reviews ban: what agencies must change

What the fake reviews ban means for estate and letting agencies: review gating, incentives, selective display, staff reviews and a fair request process.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why reviews matter so much to agencies
  2. What is now banned
  3. Common agency practices and where they stand
  4. Incentives: the safest approach
  5. A compliant review request process
  6. Responding to negative reviews
  7. Portals, search engines and social media
  8. Your steps against fake reviews
  9. Briefing the team
  10. Penalties
  11. Example: cleaning up a review widget
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews have been banned outright since 6 April 2025[1].
  • Businesses that publish reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake and concealed incentivised reviews[2].
  • In a 2025 review of more than 100 business websites, the CMA found 54 could be failing to comply with its guidance[3].
  • Ask every client for a review the same way, disclose any incentive and show reviews as they come, good or bad.

Why reviews matter so much to agencies

Estate agency starts from a trust deficit. Only 37% of people said they trust estate agents in the Ipsos Veracity Index of November 2024, as cited by the government[4]. Reviews are one of the few ways a seller or landlord can judge an agency before meeting it, which is exactly why the temptation to manage them is strong, and why the law now treats manipulation so seriously.

People who say they trust estate agents (Ipsos Veracity Index, 2024)
People who say they trust estate agents (Ipsos Veracity Index, 2024)Donut chart. Trust estate agents: 37%.Trust estate agents: 37%37%
  • Trust estate agents 37%

Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Trust estate agents37%

The unfair commercial practices provisions of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which cover fake reviews, came into force on 6 April 2025[1]. The Competition and Markets Authority has since been active. In a review of more than 100 business websites in 2025 it found 54 could be failing to comply with its fake reviews guidance[3], and in March 2026 it opened investigations into 5 businesses, including Autotrader, over online review practices[5].

What is now banned

Two things are banned in all circumstances: fake reviews, meaning reviews that purport to be from a genuine experience but are not, and concealed incentivised reviews. Under CMA guidance, a review written in exchange for money or other benefits without making that clear is a banned concealed incentivised review[6]. Publishing or commissioning such reviews, or presenting review information in a misleading way, can breach the law.

There is also a positive duty. Businesses that publish consumer reviews or review information must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews[2]. If your website shows reviews, through a widget or your own page, that duty applies to you.

Common agency practices and where they stand

Review practices to check in an agency
PracticeRiskWhat to do instead
Staff or their families writing reviewsFake reviewStop; remove any that exist
Prize draw entry for leaving a review, not disclosedConcealed incentivised reviewDrop the incentive, or disclose it clearly with every review it produces
Asking only clients who seem happy (review gating)Misleading review informationAsk every client at the same point in the process
Sending unhappy clients to a private feedback form instead of the review siteMisleading review informationOffer both, to everyone, and handle complaints separately
Showing only five-star reviews on the websiteMisleading presentationShow all reviews, or all within a stated rule such as most recent first
Reporting genuine negative reviews as fakeSuppressionRespond publicly and politely; report only reviews you believe are fake
Copying reviews from another branch or a previous businessMisleadingShow reviews only for the business and service they relate to

If you are unsure whether a practice is allowed, ask how a reasonable seller would feel if they knew exactly how the reviews they are reading were collected.

Incentives: the safest approach

Incentives are where agencies most often slip. A small thank-you, a prize draw, a discount on a future service or a donation to charity in return for a review all count as benefits. If you offer one and the resulting reviews do not make that clear, they are concealed incentivised reviews[6].

  • The safest course is not to incentivise reviews at all.
  • If you do, offer the incentive to every client regardless of whether they leave a positive or negative review, and make sure each review shows it was incentivised.
  • Never tie the incentive to a star rating, a particular site or particular wording.
  • Record what you offered, to whom and when.

A compliant review request process

  1. Pick a fixed trigger

    Send the request at the same point for every client, such as seven days after completion or after the first month of a tenancy.

  2. Use one neutral message

    Ask for honest feedback, not a five-star review, and give the same link to every client.

  3. Do not pre-screen

    Do not send a satisfaction survey first and only invite the satisfied to review.

  4. Display without filtering

    Show all reviews on your website, or apply a neutral, stated rule such as most recent first.

  5. Moderate fairly

    Remove reviews only if they are fake, offensive or unlawful, and keep a record of why.

  6. Respond publicly

    Reply to negative reviews with facts and an offer to talk, never with personal details about the client.

A request message can be as simple as: 'Thank you for choosing us to sell your home. We'd value your honest feedback on how we did. It takes two minutes. Good or bad, it helps us improve and helps other sellers decide.'

Responding to negative reviews

A few critical reviews make a profile believable. What damages an agency is a defensive or dismissive reply, or a pattern of negative reviews disappearing. Treat every negative review as a complaint that happens to be public.

  1. Reply within two working days, from a named manager.
  2. Thank the reviewer, acknowledge the issue in general terms and avoid arguing about details in public.
  3. Never disclose personal information about the client, the property or the transaction.
  4. Offer a direct conversation and follow your complaints procedure.
  5. If the matter is resolved, ask whether they would like to update their review, but never ask them to remove it or offer anything in return.

Report a review to the platform only when you have good reason to believe it is fake, for example because no such client exists. Keep a note of your reasons. Reporting genuine criticism as fake to get it removed is a form of suppression.

Portals, search engines and social media

Agencies collect reviews on several platforms at once: a dedicated review site, search engine business profiles, portal agent pages and social media. The same rules apply to how you collect them on each. Check that every request template, every automated email and every link in your email signature follows the same neutral process, and that no branch is running its own scheme, such as a negotiator offering coffee vouchers for reviews on their personal profile.

If you show reviews from any of these sources on your own website, you are publishing review information, so the duty to take reasonable steps applies to what you display as well as how you collected it.

Your steps against fake reviews

The duty to take reasonable and proportionate steps means having a written approach, not just good intentions[2]. For most agencies it fits on one page.

  1. A short review policy: who may review, how requests are made, what incentives if any, and how reviews are displayed.
  2. A ban on staff, family and friends reviewing the agency, written into the staff handbook.
  3. A check before displaying reviews from any third-party widget: is it showing all reviews or a filtered set?
  4. A route for reporting suspected fake reviews, about you or about competitors, to the review platform.
  5. An annual audit of review practices, recorded and signed off by a director.

Briefing the team

Most review problems start with well-meaning staff. A negotiator asks a friend to leave a review for a quiet branch, or a lettings administrator only sends the link to tenants who said thank you. Brief every member of staff on the policy, explain why selective requests and undisclosed rewards are now unlawful, and include it in induction for new starters. Make it clear that review numbers will never be used as a personal target, because targets create exactly the behaviour the law prohibits.

Penalties

The CMA can enforce directly. A final infringement notice can impose a penalty of up to £300,000 or, if higher, 10% of the business's turnover[7]. The reputational cost of being named for fake reviews in a trust-based industry would be higher still.

Example: cleaning up a review widget

Example: a lettings agency in Cardiff displayed a review carousel on its home page set to show only five-star reviews, and its tenancy renewal email offered entry to a prize draw for anyone who left a review. The marketing manager switched the carousel to show all reviews in date order, which brought in some three- and four-star comments, and dropped the prize draw. Review requests moved to a fixed point one month after move-in for every tenant and every landlord. Over the following quarter the average rating fell slightly, but the number of reviews rose, and landlords at valuation appointments started mentioning that the reviews felt real.

Reviews are one part of the wider unfair practices regime. See the DMCC Act for agents and misleading property adverts.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal for estate agents to offer incentives for reviews?

Concealing the incentive is banned: a review written in exchange for money or other benefits without making that clear is a concealed incentivised review[6]. The safest course is not to incentivise.

When did the fake reviews ban start?

On 6 April 2025, when the unfair commercial practices provisions of the 2024 Act came into force[1].

Can we choose which reviews to show on our website?

Showing only positive reviews risks presenting review information in a misleading way. Show all reviews or apply a neutral, stated rule.

What must an agency do to prevent fake reviews?

Take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake and concealed incentivised reviews[2], such as a written policy, a staff ban and regular audits.

References

  1. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Reviews and social media endorsements: guidance for businesses and brands (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Online consumer reviews (CMA case page) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2026). Online consumer reviews (CMA case page) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 182: final infringement notice (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo