Customer experience

Disputes between landlords and tenants

How letting agents can handle disputes between landlords and tenants: staying neutral, building the evidence file and escalating through the right route.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The agent in the middle
  2. Disputes are rising
  3. Common disputes and the evidence they need
  4. Staying neutral in practice
  5. What a good dispute file looks like
  6. The escalation ladder
  7. When mediation helps
  8. When the landlord asks you to cross a line
  9. Example: a disputed repair
  10. Language that lowers the temperature
  11. After the dispute
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • You act for the landlord, but you still owe the tenant fair dealing and must follow the law; neutrality on facts protects everyone.
  • Lettings disputes taken to The Property Ombudsman rose 65% in 2025, and most decided cases went the consumer's way[1][2].
  • Write everything down as it happens: dated notes, photos and copies of messages are what settle disputes.
  • Use the right escalation route for the issue: deposit schemes for deposits, your complaints process and redress scheme for service, the council for disrepair.

The agent in the middle

A letting agent who manages a property sits between two people who often see the same event very differently. The landlord sees a tenant who caused damage and is now refusing to pay. The tenant sees a landlord who ignored a leak for weeks. Both call you, both expect you to take their side, and both will judge you on how the dispute ends.

Your client is the landlord, and you act on their instructions. But you also have legal duties that do not depend on whose side you are on: protecting deposits, following the rules on fees and notices, carrying out safety duties and dealing fairly with tenants. Being neutral about the facts, even while you represent the landlord, is what keeps you on the right side of those duties and gives your account credibility if the dispute goes further.

Disputes are rising

Property Ombudsman cases decided in the consumer's favour, 2025All cases decided by The Property Ombudsman in 2025.
Property Ombudsman cases decided in the consumer's favour, 2025Donut chart. Decided for the consumer: 61%.Decided for the consumer: 61%61%
  • Decided for the consumer 61%

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Decided for the consumer61%

The Property Ombudsman resolved 3,119 lettings disputes in 2025, up 65% on 2024[2], and 61% of the cases it decided were decided in the consumer's favour[1]. Poor, unclear or delayed communication was listed first among the top issues in lettings disputes[3]. Many of those cases began as landlord and tenant disagreements that the agent did not manage clearly, and ended as complaints against the agent.

Common disputes and the evidence they need

Most disputes fall into a handful of types. For each, decide in advance what evidence your team must collect, so it is there when you need it.

Common landlord and tenant disputes and the evidence a managing agent should hold.
DisputeTypical positionsEvidence you needRoute if unresolved
Deposit deductionsLandlord: damage. Tenant: fair wear and tearCheck-in and check-out reports, dated photos, invoicesDeposit scheme dispute service
Repairs and disrepairTenant: reported and ignored. Landlord: not told, or caused by tenantRepair log with dates, contractor reports, messagesComplaints process, then the council if hazards remain
Rent arrearsLandlord: unpaid rent. Tenant: withheld because of repairsRent ledger, repair log, written communicationsPossession process or court, with advice
AccessLandlord: needs entry. Tenant: no notice givenCopies of notices and the times givenDiscussion, then legal advice
Noise or neighboursEach blames the otherDates, reports, any council or police contactCouncil, mediation

Staying neutral in practice

  • Separate facts from opinions. Record what happened, when and who said it, without adjectives.
  • Do not promise either side an outcome before you have checked the evidence.
  • Tell both sides the same facts. If you tell the landlord the contractor found tenant damage, tell the tenant the same thing.
  • Avoid taking calls when you are angry or rushed. Ring back at an agreed time.
  • Never pass on personal remarks from one side to the other.
  • Keep your own view of who is right out of messages. Your job is to resolve, not to judge.

Neutral does not mean passive. If the landlord is clearly responsible for a repair, tell them so, with the reason. If the tenant has caused damage, say that too. Being straight with both parties is what makes each of them believe you.

What a good dispute file looks like

  1. A timeline: every contact, visit and decision, with dates and names.
  2. Copies of all written messages, including texts and WhatsApp, saved to the property file rather than left on personal phones.
  3. Photos and videos with dates, ideally taken at inspections as well as when problems arise.
  4. Contractor reports, quotes and invoices.
  5. The tenancy agreement, inventory, check-in report and any later variations.
  6. A note of the outcome and what each side agreed.

If the dispute is about the deposit, check that it was protected within 30 days of receipt[4]. A protection failure changes the position completely and is better discovered by you than by the tenant's adviser.

The escalation ladder

  1. Talk early

    Call each party, listen, and agree what you will check and by when. Most disputes end here if the agent acts quickly.

  2. Summarise in writing

    Send both parties the same short summary of the facts, what each has said and the next step.

  3. Manager review

    If either party is unhappy, a manager reviews the file with fresh eyes and calls them.

  4. Formal complaint

    If the complaint is about your service, follow your written complaints procedure and timescales.

  5. Deposit dispute service

    For deposit disagreements, use the free dispute resolution service of the scheme holding it. There are three schemes in England and Wales[5], and once the parties agree the amount, the deposit must be returned within 10 days[6].

  6. Redress scheme

    Letting and property management agents in England must belong to a redress scheme[7]. Tell complainants how to use it once your procedure is exhausted.

  7. Council or court

    Serious disrepair can be referred to the council. Possession, money claims and other legal disputes need legal advice.

When mediation helps

Some disputes are less about facts than about a relationship that has broken down: a landlord who feels disrespected, a tenant who feels ignored. In those cases a short, structured conversation can achieve more than another round of emails. The agent can run a simple version, but only if both parties agree and the agent is clear about acting for the landlord.

  • Agree the purpose in advance: to find a practical way forward, not to decide who was right.
  • Hold it by phone or video, or at a neutral place, with a fixed time limit.
  • Let each side explain the problem without interruption, then summarise what you heard.
  • Focus on what each party needs now: a repair date, a payment plan, an access arrangement.
  • Confirm any agreement in writing to both parties the same day.

If the dispute involves allegations of harassment, a risk to safety or a legal claim, do not attempt informal mediation. Refer the parties to independent advice instead.

When the landlord asks you to cross a line

Disputes sometimes lead a landlord to ask for something you cannot do: change the locks, cut off a service, remarket a property they have no right to remarket, or send a tenant an informal message telling them to leave. Letting agents acting for landlords can be liable for breaches of the Renters' Rights Act enforcement measures[8], so 'the landlord told me to' is not a defence.

Messages matter too. Government guidance notes that a notice to quit can include texts or WhatsApp messages[9]. A frustrated line such as 'the landlord wants you out by the end of the month' could be treated as more than a remark. Use templates for anything about the tenancy itself, and route formal notices through your proper process.

Script for the landlord: 'I understand why you are frustrated, and I want this resolved too. I cannot do that, because it would break the law and expose both of us to penalties. Here is what we can do this week instead.'

Example: a disputed repair

Example. A tenant reports damp in a bedroom in October. The landlord says it is condensation from drying clothes indoors; the tenant says the gutter has been leaking for months. The property manager arranges a contractor visit within a week, shares the report with both sides and finds a blocked gutter plus poor ventilation. The landlord pays to clear and repair the gutter and fit an extractor fan; the tenant agrees to ventilate the room and use the fan. The manager sends both parties a written summary and books a check-up visit six weeks later. No complaint follows, because both saw the same evidence at the same time.

Language that lowers the temperature

  • 'I can hear this has been really frustrating. Let me check the facts and call you back by 3pm.'
  • 'I am not going to take sides on what happened until I have seen the report, but I will share it with you as soon as I have it.'
  • 'Here is what we know, here is what we do not know yet, and here is what happens next.'
  • 'If you are not happy with how we have handled this, I will ask my manager to review it, and I will tell you how our complaints process works.'

After the dispute

Once a dispute is resolved, spend ten minutes on what caused it. Was the inventory weak? Did a repair report sit in an inbox? Did a property manager promise something they could not deliver? Fix the process, update templates and share the lesson with the team. Disputes that teach you something are worth more than those that are simply closed.

Frequently asked questions

Who does a letting agent represent in a landlord and tenant dispute?

The agent acts for the landlord, but must still follow the law and deal fairly with the tenant. Staying neutral on the facts protects both the agent and the landlord.

How are tenancy deposit disputes resolved?

Through the free dispute resolution service of the deposit protection scheme holding the money. Once the amount is agreed, the deposit must be returned within 10 days.

Can a tenant complain about the agent to an ombudsman?

Yes. Letting and property management agents in England must belong to a redress scheme, and tenants can use it once the agent's own complaints procedure has been completed.

What should we do if a landlord asks us to do something unlawful?

Refuse, explain why and offer lawful alternatives. Agents acting for landlords can be liable for breaches of the Renters' Rights Act enforcement measures.

References

  1. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Register your rental property service: guidance for letting agents and property managers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Enforcement measures for landlords: Renters' Rights Act 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Enforcement measures for landlords: Renters' Rights Act 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo