Marketing

Measuring marketing return per channel

Work out cost per valuation, cost per instruction and fee return for each marketing channel, with formulas, a monthly report and rules for cutting spend.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Measure money in, not leads in
  2. The four numbers you need per channel
  3. The formulas
  4. Portal spend needs the closest look
  5. Costs people forget
  6. Lettings channels are measured differently
  7. Attribution rules
  8. Allow for the lag and the losses
  9. Building the monthly report
  10. When to cut, keep or test
  11. Presenting the numbers
  12. Example: two channels compared
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Judge channels on cost per instruction and fee earned, not on lead counts.
  • Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in H1 2026[1], usually the largest single line in the budget, so measure it hardest.
  • Buyers are plentiful and instructions scarce: Propertymark branches registered 69 new buyers but placed only 10.8 homes on the market each in August 2026[2].
  • Allow for the lag and the losses: around 1 in 3 transactions fail[3], so count completed fees, not agreed sales.
  • Review every channel quarterly against the same formulas and cut the weakest before adding anything new.

Measure money in, not leads in

Most agency marketing reports count enquiries: calls, emails, web forms, portal leads. Those numbers are easy to collect and tell you almost nothing about return. A channel that produces fifty buyer enquiries and no instructions is a cost, while one that produces three valuation requests a month might be your most profitable spend. The useful questions are how much each channel costs to win one instruction, and how much fee each pound of spend eventually brings back.

That shift matters because instructions are the scarce resource. In August 2026, each Propertymark member branch registered an average of 69 new prospective buyers but placed only around 10.8 homes on the market[2]. RICS contributors reported that the number of market appraisals remained below the level of twelve months earlier[4]. Spending that wins vendors and landlords deserves the closest scrutiny.

Average per Propertymark member branch, August 2026
Average per Propertymark member branch, August 2026Comparison. New prospective buyers registered: 69; Homes placed on the market: 10.8.69New prospective buyers registeredNew prospective buyers registered: 6910.8Homes placed on the marketHomes placed on the market: 10.8Average per Propertymark member branch, August 2026Comparison. New prospective buyers registered: 69; Homes placed on the market: 10.8.69New prospective buyers registeredNew prospective buyers registered: 6910.8Homes placed on the marketHomes placed on the market: 10.8

Source: Propertymark, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
New prospective buyers registered69
Homes placed on the market10.8

The four numbers you need per channel

  • Spend: everything the channel costs in the period, including design, printing, delivery, subscriptions and staff time where it is significant.
  • Valuations: market appraisals booked and attended where the source was this channel.
  • Instructions: signed sales or lettings instructions from those valuations.
  • Fee earned: commission or lettings fees actually invoiced from those instructions, recorded when the sale completes or the tenancy starts.

Everything else is a ratio of these four. If you cannot fill all four for a channel, the first job is fixing the source data, not judging the channel. Our guide to lead source tracking in the CRM covers how to get reliable sources on every record.

The formulas

Channel return formulas, with an Example channel spending £1,200 in a quarter
MetricFormulaExample
Cost per valuationSpend ÷ valuations attended£1,200 ÷ 8 = £150
Valuation to instruction rateInstructions ÷ valuations3 ÷ 8 = 37.5%
Cost per instructionSpend ÷ instructions£1,200 ÷ 3 = £400
Completion rateCompleted ÷ instructions, measured later2 ÷ 3 = 67%
Fee returnFee earned ÷ spend£7,000 ÷ £1,200 = 5.8 times

Example figures in the table are fictional. Use your own fee levels and your branch's real conversion rates; the point is the method, applied the same way to every channel.

Portal spend needs the closest look

Portals are usually the largest single line in an agency's marketing budget. Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in the first half of 2026, up 8% on a year earlier, across 16,591 advertising branches[1]. The portal also reported that its AI-enabled valuation tool supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to agents[1]. Those leads are only worth what they convert to, so give portal valuation leads their own source code and track them all the way to instruction.

Split portal value into two parts. The buyer and tenant enquiries are partly a service to vendors and landlords you already have; the vendor and landlord leads are new business. Judge the second part on cost per instruction like any other channel, and treat the first as part of the cost of delivering your service.

Costs people forget

Spend figures are usually understated, which flatters some channels more than others. Before you calculate anything, make sure each channel carries its full cost.

  • Design and copywriting time, whether done in-house or by an agency.
  • Printing, envelopes, postage and distribution for every leaflet and letter drop.
  • Board erection, removal and replacement, and the cost of boards lost or damaged.
  • Staff time spent on canvassing calls, events and social media, valued at a simple hourly rate.
  • Software and subscriptions used only for one channel, such as a social scheduling tool or a mailing platform.
  • Portal upgrades and featured listings on top of the base subscription.

Lettings channels are measured differently

A lettings instruction is not a single fee. A fully managed landlord may stay with the agency for years, paying management fees every month and new let fees each time the property changes hands, while a let-only instruction may pay once. Measure landlord channels on the estimated value of the instructions they win over a sensible period, such as three years, using your own retention data.

Do the same for portfolio landlords. A channel that brings in a landlord with several properties should be credited with all of them, including those that move across later. Without this, landlord marketing almost always looks worse than sales marketing on a single-quarter view, and the agency underinvests in the part of the business that produces its most reliable income.

Attribution rules

Most vendors meet an agent several times before they call: a board in the street, a leaflet, a portal listing, a friend's recommendation. Pick one attribution rule and use it consistently, or your numbers will drift every time someone reinterprets a source.

  • Primary source: ask 'what made you call us today?' and record that answer as the source.
  • Secondary source: record any other touchpoints the client mentions in a separate field.
  • Never change a source after the instruction is won, even if a negotiator believes their own canvassing deserves credit.
  • Report channels on primary source, and look at secondary sources when deciding whether to cut a brand channel such as boards or sponsorship.

Allow for the lag and the losses

Sales fees arrive months after the marketing that won them. HMRC says completions happen on average two to four months after an offer is made[5], and that is after the time on the market. Around 1 in 3 transactions fail, costing buyers and sellers around £400m a year[3]. If you judge a channel on agreed sales, you will overstate its return; if you wait for completions, you will judge last year's marketing.

The practical answer is to report both. Show a leading view based on instructions, using your branch's average fee and completion rate to estimate value, and a lagging view based on fees actually invoiced. Make decisions on the leading view and check them against the lagging view every quarter.

Building the monthly report

  1. Export from the CRM

    Valuations, instructions and completions for the month, each with its primary source.

  2. Add the spend

    From the accounts, allocate each invoice to a channel. Spread annual costs such as portal contracts evenly across months.

  3. Calculate the ratios

    Cost per valuation, conversion rate, cost per instruction and estimated fee return for each channel.

  4. Rank the channels

    Sort by cost per instruction. Highlight any channel with fewer than three instructions in the quarter as 'not enough data'.

  5. Write three lines of commentary

    What improved, what worsened and what you will change next month.

When to cut, keep or test

  • Cut: a channel with a cost per instruction well above your branch average for two quarters running, and no strong secondary-source role.
  • Keep: a channel with a cost per instruction at or below average, or a brand channel that shows up often as a secondary source.
  • Test: a new channel gets a fixed budget, a dedicated source code and one quarter. Decide at the end, not halfway.
  • Renegotiate: a channel that converts well but costs too much may be cheaper on a different package or frequency.

Presenting the numbers

Keep the report to one page. Put the ranked table of channels at the top, the three-line commentary underneath and any decisions needed at the bottom. Owners and branch managers will read a single page every month; they will not read a spreadsheet with forty columns.

Share a simpler version with negotiators. Show them which channels produced their instructions and how much those channels cost. People who see the numbers ask better questions about where effort should go, and they are more careful about recording sources accurately.

Example: two channels compared

Example (fictional). A branch spends £900 a quarter on leaflets and £1,500 on paid social adverts. Leaflets bring 6 valuations and 3 instructions; social brings 15 valuations and 2 instructions. Cost per valuation favours social at £100 against £150. Cost per instruction favours leaflets at £300 against £750.

Example decision: the branch keeps leaflets, cuts the social budget by half and targets it at landlords instead of homeowners, and runs the test for another quarter with a separate source code. The lesson is the one most agencies learn when they first run the numbers: the channel with the most leads is rarely the one with the best return.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cost per instruction for an estate agency?

There is no reliable national benchmark. Compare channels against your own branch average and against your average fee, and aim to cut the channels that sit far above both.

Should I measure marketing on agreed sales or completions?

Both. Use instructions and agreed sales for quick decisions, and check against completed fees each quarter, because a share of agreed sales will fall through.

How do I value boards and sponsorship that rarely get credited?

Record secondary sources on every valuation. Brand channels often appear as a second or third touchpoint even when they are rarely the reason someone called.

References

  1. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). UK monthly property transactions commentary (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo