Marketing

Cutting portal costs without losing leads

How UK agencies can cut portal costs without losing leads: measure return per instruction, prune add-ons, prepare for renewal and fix lead leakage first.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why portal costs keep rising
  2. Put the cost in branch terms
  3. Measure return before you cut
  4. Stop the leaks first
  5. Prune the add-ons
  6. Preparing for renewal
  7. Lettings branches need a different calculation
  8. Questions to ask your portal account manager
  9. Cheaper channels that complement portals
  10. Example: a three-branch agency's review
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in H1 2026, up 8% on a year earlier[1].
  • Measured against output, an average Propertymark branch placed around 10.8 homes on the market and agreed 9.5 sales in August 2026[2][3].
  • The cheapest saving is usually not a smaller contract but fewer wasted leads: unanswered calls and slow replies waste the spend you already make.
  • Prepare for renewal months ahead with your own lead data, cost per instruction and a clear view of which add-ons earn their place.

Why portal costs keep rising

For most agencies, portal advertising is the largest marketing cost and one of the largest overall after staff and premises. Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser reached £1,636 a month in H1 2026, up 8% on a year earlier[1], while the number of agency branches advertising rose 1% to 16,591[4].

At the same time, browsing has eased. Time spent on Rightmove fell to 8.4 billion minutes in H1 2026 from 9.1 billion a year earlier[5], and Rightmove reported sales agreed in October 2026 were down 8% on a year earlier[6]. Paying more while the market is quieter makes it essential to know what the spend returns.

Put the cost in branch terms

National averages become useful when you translate them into branch output. Propertymark member branches each placed around 10.8 homes on the market in August 2026, agreed an average of 9.5 sales and had an average of 51 properties available for sale[2][3][7]. Lettings branches saw fully managed new instructions fall to 2.97 per branch[8].

Average Propertymark sales branch, August 2026
Average Propertymark sales branch, August 2026Column chart. Properties available for sale: 51 properties; Sales agreed in the month: 9.5 properties.0 properties20 properties40 properties60 propertiesProperties available for sale: 51 properties51 propertiesProperties available for saleSales agreed in the month: 9.5 properties9.5 propertiesSales agreed in the monthAverage Propertymark sales branch, August 2026Column chart. Properties available for sale: 51 properties; Sales agreed in the month: 9.5 properties.Properties available for saleProperties available for sale: 51 properties51 propertiesSales agreed in the monthSales agreed in the month: 9.5 properties9.5 properties

Source: Propertymark, 2026[7]

Show the data
ItemValue
Properties available for sale51 properties
Sales agreed in the month9.5 properties

Example calculation (illustrative, using the averages above): a branch paying £1,636 a month and listing about 10.8 new homes a month spends roughly £151 of portal money per new listing. Your own figures will differ, which is exactly the point: calculate them for each branch, every quarter.

Measure return before you cut

  1. Make lead source mandatory

    Every enquiry, valuation booking and applicant record needs a specific source: the portal name, your website, the board, a referral, a past client.

  2. Follow leads to money

    Track each source through valuation, instruction, sale agreed and completion, and for lettings through let agreed and management instruction.

  3. Total the real spend

    Include the base subscription, featured listings, premium products, branch branding and seller-lead products for each portal.

  4. Calculate cost per outcome

    Divide spend by valuations, instructions and lets agreed for each portal and each add-on.

  5. Compare with other channels

    Put the same calculation alongside canvassing, local print, social media and referral schemes.

If your CRM shows a large share of leads with no source or a vague label such as internet, fix that before negotiating anything. Without it you cannot tell which spend is working.

Stop the leaks first

The fastest way to improve portal return is to waste fewer of the leads you already pay for. Most branches lose portal enquiries in predictable places: calls at lunchtime and after hours, emails answered the next day, and valuation requests that wait over a weekend.

  • Answer every portal call, including evenings and weekends, or route it to someone who can.
  • Reply to email enquiries within the hour during opening times, with a proposed viewing slot rather than a generic acknowledgement.
  • Call valuation leads the same day; portal valuation tools generate warm but early interest.
  • Log every enquiry in the CRM with its source, even if it does not lead to a viewing.

Rightmove reported that its AI-enabled online agent valuation supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to agents in H1 2026[9]. More leads only help if someone picks them up quickly. An AI Employee such as Ava can answer portal enquiry calls when the team is busy or the office is closed, take viewing and valuation requests, and pass a summary to the right negotiator.

Prune the add-ons

Add-on products are where most savings hide. Each one should pass the same test as the base listing: does it produce valuations, instructions or lets at a cost you would accept from any other channel?

Testing portal add-ons before renewal
ProductTestKeep if
Featured or premium listingsCompare promoted and similar unpromoted listings for enquiries and time to sale agreedPromoted listings sell or let measurably faster
Seller-lead or valuation productsCount appointments and instructions from those leadsCost per instruction is competitive with canvassing
Branch branding on search resultsTrack instruction win rate in the areas coveredValuers report sellers mention it and win rates rise
Data and market insight toolsCheck log-ins and use in valuation appointmentsValuers use them every week
Second or third portalMeasure unique leads not duplicated on the main portalUnique leads produce instructions or lets

Run tests in one branch where you have several. A quarter with and without a product, in comparable branches, gives a clearer answer than any sales presentation.

Preparing for renewal

  1. Find the renewal date and notice period for every portal contract, and diarise a review six months before.
  2. Assemble twelve months of lead and outcome data by portal and by add-on.
  3. Decide in advance what you will drop if the price rises, and what you would add if it falls.
  4. Ask for the price of the core listing alone, separately from bundles.
  5. Consider the timing of any change: leaving a portal or product mid-season can hurt more than waiting for a quieter month.
  6. Record what was agreed and when the next review is due.

Be realistic about leverage. With Rightmove holding most portal time, few sales branches can credibly threaten to leave it entirely. The negotiation that works is usually about the bundle: which products you take, at what level, for which branches.

Lettings branches need a different calculation

In lettings, the portal is mostly a tool for finding tenants, while revenue comes from landlords. That changes the measure. A lettings branch with strong applicant demand may fill most properties from its own applicant list and a single portal, and gain little from extra exposure. The more useful question is how many landlord instructions the portal helps win, and how many void days it saves.

  • Track days from listing to let agreed by lead source, so you can see whether portal applicants let homes faster than your own list.
  • Count landlord valuation leads from portal tools separately from tenant enquiries.
  • Compare management instructions won against the spend, given that fully managed new instructions averaged 2.97 per Propertymark branch in August 2026[8].
  • Check whether quieter months justify a lighter package, and whether your contract allows it.

Questions to ask your portal account manager

  1. What does the core listing cost on its own, without bundled products?
  2. Which of our current products have measurable results for branches like ours, and what data supports that?
  3. Can we trial a product in one branch for a quarter before committing across the group?
  4. What notice is needed to remove a product, and can we change the package mid-contract?
  5. Can you supply lead data in a format we can match against our CRM?

Write down the answers and compare them with your own figures. Account managers are paid to sell packages, and your data is the only reliable check on what they say.

Cheaper channels that complement portals

Reducing portal spend is easier when other channels are pulling their weight. Your own applicant list, past clients, local referrals and boards all produce instructions that do not depend on portal pricing.

  • Keep applicant records clean and contact active buyers directly when new stock arrives, before it reaches the portals.
  • Ask every completed seller and landlord for a referral and a review within a week of completion.
  • Use sold boards and local mailings in streets where you are winning, with clear opt-outs for marketing.
  • Invest in your website's valuation and alert sign-up journeys so more leads arrive directly.

Example: a three-branch agency's review

Example (fictional): an agency with three branches reviews its portal spend ahead of renewal. It finds that 18% of leads have no source recorded, so it makes the field mandatory and waits a quarter. The new data shows featured listings in one branch producing no measurable difference in time to sale agreed, while seller-lead products in another branch generate valuations but few instructions because nobody calls them back the same day.

In this example, the agency drops featured listings in the first branch, keeps the seller-lead product but assigns a negotiator to call every lead within two hours, and covers evening calls so portal enquiries are no longer lost. At renewal it negotiates the core listing separately and keeps the add-ons that passed. Total spend falls, and instructions from portal leads rise because fewer are wasted.

Frequently asked questions

What is a reasonable portal cost per instruction?

There is no single benchmark. Calculate it for each branch from your own lead data and compare it with what other channels cost you per instruction.

Is Rightmove getting more expensive?

Its average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in H1 2026, up 8% on a year earlier[1].

Should we drop add-on products first?

Test them first. Keep the ones that produce instructions or lets at a competitive cost per outcome, and drop the ones you cannot measure or that show no effect.

How can we get more from the same spend?

Answer every portal enquiry fast, including out of hours, call valuation leads the same day and make lead source mandatory in the CRM.

References

  1. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Rightmove (2026). House Price Index, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo