Renters rights

Guarantors vs rent guarantee insurance

When a guarantor protects a landlord better than rent guarantee insurance, what to check in policies after the reforms and how to model arrears exposure.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. The gap both are meant to fill
  2. How the two compare
  3. When a guarantor is the better choice
  4. When insurance is the better choice
  5. What to check in a policy after the reforms
  6. What to check in a guarantee deed
  7. A decision checklist for each new tenancy
  8. Example: modelling a landlord's exposure
  9. Using both, and what happens at claim time
  10. Explaining the choice to landlords
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Deposits are capped at five weeks' rent for most lets[1], far less than the arrears a landlord can face before possession.
  • The mandatory arrears ground needs three months' arrears, or 13 weeks for weekly rents, plus four weeks' notice[2].
  • Landlord claims took a median 27.1 weeks from claim to repossession in April to June 2026[3].
  • A strong guarantor suits higher-risk applicants; insurance suits portfolios that want predictable cover and legal costs.
  • Re-read every policy and guarantee deed for periodic tenancies, notification deadlines and referencing conditions.

The gap both are meant to fill

Since the Tenant Fees Act, the deposit has been capped at five weeks' rent where annual rent is below 50,000 pounds and six weeks' where it is 50,000 to 100,000 pounds[1]. Rent in advance is now capped at one month and cannot be taken before the agreement is signed[1]. Those are the only funds a landlord holds at the start of a tenancy.

Meanwhile the route to possession for arrears has lengthened. The mandatory ground needs at least three months' arrears, or 13 weeks for weekly or fortnightly rent, at both notice and hearing, with four weeks' notice[2]. Court stages then add months: in April to June 2026 the median time from a landlord's claim to repossession was 27.1 weeks[3].

The deposit against arrears and court timescalesDeposit cap and arrears threshold from GOV.UK guidance; court time from Ministry of Justice statistics
The deposit against arrears and court timescalesColumn chart. Deposit cap (most lets): 5 weeks; Arrears threshold for mandatory ground (weekly rent): 13 weeks; Median landlord claim to repossession: 27.1 weeks.0 weeks10 weeks20 weeks30 weeksDeposit cap (most lets): 5 weeks5 weeksDeposit cap (most lets)Arrears threshold for mandatory ground (weekly rent): 13 weeks13 weeksArrears threshold formandatory ground (weeklyrent)Median landlord claim to repossession: 27.1 weeks27.1 weeksMedian landlord claim torepossessionThe deposit against arrears and court timescalesColumn chart. Deposit cap (most lets): 5 weeks; Arrears threshold for mandatory ground (weekly rent): 13 weeks; Median landlord claim to repossession: 27.1 weeks.Deposit cap (most lets)Deposit cap (most lets): 5 weeks5 weeksArrears threshold for mandatory ground(weekly rent)Arrears threshold for mandatory ground (weekly rent): 13 weeks13 weeksMedian landlord claim to repossessionMedian landlord claim to repossession: 27.1 weeks27.1 weeks

Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Deposit cap (most lets)5 weeks
Arrears threshold for mandatory ground (weekly rent)13 weeks
Median landlord claim to repossession27.1 weeks

The difference between the deposit and the realistic arrears in a contested case is the landlord's exposure. A guarantor and rent guarantee insurance both aim to cover it, in different ways.

How the two compare

Guarantor and rent guarantee insurance compared
FactorGuarantorRent guarantee insurance
Who paysNo premium; the guarantor bears the riskLandlord pays the premium; it cannot be charged to the tenant
What it coversWhatever the deed says: usually rent and sometimes damageRent up to a monthly limit and period; often legal expenses
How you recoverDemand on the guarantor, then court if they do not payClaim to the insurer within policy deadlines
Strength depends onThe guarantor's income, assets and willingnessPolicy terms, exclusions and your compliance with conditions
Common failure pointGuarantor cannot pay or disputes the deedLate notification or referencing not to the insurer's criteria
Periodic tenanciesDeed must clearly cover the periodic tenancy and rent changesPolicy must cover periodic tenancies and the new grounds
Legal costsLandlord funds possession and recoveryOften included, subject to limits

Neither is automatically better. A well-referenced homeowner guarantor can be stronger than an insurance policy with a low monthly cap. A policy can be stronger than a guarantor who is a student's parent with stretched finances. The decision should be per tenancy, not per landlord.

When a guarantor is the better choice

  • The applicant does not meet the income test alone but has a guarantor who comfortably does, for example a student, a first-time renter or someone new to self-employment.
  • The insurer would decline the applicant because of their income type or referencing outcome, but the landlord is willing to proceed.
  • The rent is above an insurer's monthly limit and the guarantor can cover the full amount.
  • The landlord wants cover for damage beyond the deposit, which a properly drafted deed can include.

Apply guarantor criteria the same way to every applicant who needs one. Requiring guarantors only from benefit claimants or families risks breaching the new discrimination rules.

When insurance is the better choice

  • The landlord wants predictable cover across a portfolio, with legal costs handled by the insurer's panel.
  • Tenants pass full referencing on their own income, so a guarantor would add little.
  • The landlord is overseas or does not want to pursue a guarantor personally.
  • The landlord's mortgage lender or business plan requires a defined level of income protection.

Rent guarantee insurance is not a permitted payment under the Tenant Fees Act, so the premium cannot be passed to the tenant in any form.

What to check in a policy after the reforms

Policies written before 1 May 2026 assumed fixed terms and section 21 as a possession route. Read your current wording, or ask your broker, with these questions in front of you.

  1. Does the policy cover assured periodic tenancies, and for how long after a rent increase?
  2. Which possession grounds will the insurer pursue, and does it rely on the mandatory arrears ground only?
  3. What is the notification deadline after a missed payment, and what counts as notice?
  4. What referencing standard must the tenant meet at the start, and does a later change of sharers need new referencing?
  5. Is there a monthly limit and a maximum claim period, and does it reflect current court timescales?
  6. Are legal costs included, and up to what limit?
  7. What happens if the landlord accepts a payment plan without the insurer's agreement?

Keep the answers on file for each landlord. If the landlord's policy has a short notification deadline, your arrears process must meet it; diary it at day one of every arrears case.

What to check in a guarantee deed

  1. Does the deed clearly cover the tenancy as a periodic tenancy, including future rent increases?
  2. Is the guarantor's liability limited to the named tenant's share in a joint tenancy, or the whole rent?
  3. Can the guarantor end the guarantee, and on what notice?
  4. Did the guarantor receive the tenancy terms and have the chance to take advice before signing?
  5. Is the deed signed and witnessed correctly?

Deeds drafted for fixed-term tenancies may be uncertain once the tenancy is periodic. If you hold older deeds, take legal advice on whether they still bite and consider new deeds for new tenancies.

A decision checklist for each new tenancy

Run through these questions when an applicant has been referenced and before the landlord signs. The answers point to a guarantor, insurance, both or neither.

  1. Does the applicant pass the affordability test alone? If yes, insurance is usually the simpler protection.
  2. If not, is there a guarantor who passes the guarantor test comfortably, with stable income or assets?
  3. Would the landlord's insurer accept this tenant on its referencing criteria? If not, the policy may not respond to a claim.
  4. Is the monthly rent within the policy's monthly limit, and is the claim period long enough for a contested case?
  5. How would the landlord cope with six months of no rent? A landlord with a large mortgage and one property needs stronger cover than a cash buyer with ten.
  6. Is the tenancy joint? Check whether each guarantor covers the whole rent or only one tenant's share.

Example: modelling a landlord's exposure

Example (fictional): a flat is let at 1,400 pounds a month, close to the UK average private rent of 1,406 pounds in September 2026[4]. The tenant stops paying altogether and contests possession.

  • In the example, three months' arrears accrue before the mandatory ground can be used: 4,200 pounds.
  • In the example, four weeks' notice adds about 1,290 pounds.
  • In the example, a claim taking around the April to June 2026 median of 27 weeks to repossession adds about 8,700 pounds.
  • Total unpaid rent in the example is about 14,200 pounds. The five-week deposit of about 1,615 pounds leaves roughly 12,600 pounds exposed, before legal costs.

In the example, a guarantor with good income covers most of that if they pay promptly. An insurance policy with a sufficient monthly limit and claim period covers it if notification and referencing conditions were met. Without either, the landlord carries it.

Using both, and what happens at claim time

Some landlords hold insurance and also accept a guarantor where the tenant needs one. That is allowed and can make sense for higher rents, but check the policy: some insurers expect to pursue the guarantor themselves after paying a claim, and some require the guarantor to have been referenced to their standard too.

At claim time, speed and paperwork decide the outcome. Insurers usually want the rent statement, tenancy agreement, referencing report, correspondence with the tenant and proof of when arrears were first notified. Guarantor recovery needs a formal written demand, a clear statement of what is owed and the signed deed. Keep these in the tenancy file from the start rather than reconstructing them when the money has already gone.

Agree with the landlord in writing who pursues recovery and who pays the legal costs if the insurer or the guarantor refuses. Disputes about that question are common, and they are easier to prevent than to resolve.

Explaining the choice to landlords

Present both options with numbers, not a sales pitch. Show the landlord the deposit, the realistic exposure for their rent level and what each option would cover. Record their choice and the date. If they decline both, record that too, because a landlord who later suffers heavy arrears will remember the advice differently from how it was given.

Related guides: referencing and affordability, rent arrears management, possession claim timelines and antisocial behaviour possession grounds.

Frequently asked questions

Is a guarantor better than rent guarantee insurance?

It depends on the guarantor's finances and the policy terms. A strong guarantor can be better for applicants who need support; insurance suits landlords wanting predictable cover and legal costs across a portfolio.

Can the cost of rent guarantee insurance be passed to the tenant?

No. It is not a permitted payment under the Tenant Fees Act.

Do old guarantee deeds still work for periodic tenancies?

They may not be clear. Deeds drafted around a fixed term should be reviewed by a solicitor, and new deeds should expressly cover periodic tenancies and rent increases.

What do insurers usually require?

Referencing to their criteria at the start, prompt notification of arrears and agreement before payment plans are accepted. Check the exact terms in each policy.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Mortgage and landlord possession statistics: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Private rent and house prices, UK: October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo