Renters rights

Rent repayment orders: when tenants can claim

Which offences let tenants claim back up to two years' rent, who pays after the Renters' Rights Act, and the checks that keep a letting agency out of it.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a rent repayment order is
  2. The offences that open the door
  3. Time limits and who can apply
  4. Who pays, and where agents fit
  5. How an application usually unfolds
  6. Example: an unlicensed HMO in a selective licensing area
  7. Agency controls that reduce RRO risk
  8. Talking to a landlord who has received a claim
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • The maximum rent repayment order doubled from 12 to 24 months' rent under the Renters' Rights Act[1].
  • Tenants now have 2 years from the offence to apply to the First-tier Tribunal[2].
  • New qualifying offences include misusing a possession ground and remarketing during the restricted period[3].
  • Orders can now reach superior landlords and company directors, which matters for rent-to-rent and company structures[1].
  • Most agency exposure comes from licensing gaps and careless possession or marketing advice, so audit those first.

What a rent repayment order is

A rent repayment order (RRO) is a First-tier Tribunal order requiring a landlord to repay rent because the landlord committed one of a defined list of housing offences. It sits in Part 2 of the Housing and Planning Act 2016. Either the tenant or the local housing authority can apply to the tribunal[2], and the landlord does not need to have been prosecuted first.

For years RROs were a niche risk that mainly hit landlords of unlicensed houses in multiple occupation. The Renters' Rights Act changed the scale. The maximum a landlord can be ordered to repay doubled from 12 to 24 months of rent, and orders were extended to superior landlords and company directors[1]. The government's roadmap adds that repeat offenders will be required to pay the maximum amount[4].

Maximum rent repayment order
Maximum rent repayment orderComparison. Before the Renters' Rights Act: 12 months; After the Renters' Rights Act: 24 months.12 monthsBefore the Renters' Rights ActBefore the Renters' Rights Act: 12 months24 monthsAfter the Renters' Rights ActAfter the Renters' Rights Act: 24 monthsMaximum rent repayment orderComparison. Before the Renters' Rights Act: 12 months; After the Renters' Rights Act: 24 months.12 monthsBefore the Renters' Rights ActBefore the Renters' Rights Act: 12 months24 monthsAfter the Renters' Rights ActAfter the Renters' Rights Act: 24 months

Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Before the Renters' Rights Act12 months
After the Renters' Rights Act24 months

Because the claim rests on an offence, the tribunal has to be sure the offence happened. That makes your records, not your recollection, the deciding evidence. An agency that can show when a licence application went in, what the landlord was told and what was advertised is in a far stronger position than one relying on staff memory.

The offences that open the door

Only the offences in the table in section 40 of the 2016 Act can found an order. The current list, as amended from 1 May 2026, is set out below with the agency trigger that most often sits behind each one[3].

Section 40 offences that can found a rent repayment order, with agency controls
Offence (statute)Typical agency triggerPrevention check
Violence for securing entry (Criminal Law Act 1977 s6)Contractor or landlord forcing entry after a disputeWritten access notices; no entry without consent or a court order
Eviction or harassment (Protection from Eviction Act 1977 s1)Changing locks, cutting utilities, repeated pressure to leaveEscalate every 'get them out' instruction to a manager
Misusing a possession ground (Housing Act 1988 s16J(1))Serving a selling or moving-in ground with no genuine intentionSigned landlord declaration and evidence before any notice
Letting or marketing in the restricted period (s16J(2))Relisting a home within 12 months of a ground 1 or 1A noticeCRM block on the address with an end date
Continuing tenancy reform breaches (s16J(3))Repeating a breach already penalisedRemediation log reviewed monthly
Improvement notice or prohibition order (Housing Act 2004 s30, s32)Repair works not done by the council's deadlineDiary every notice deadline with an owner
Unlicensed HMO or licensable house (Housing Act 2004 s72, s95)Missing mandatory, additional or selective licenceLicence check at instruction and at every scheme change
Breach of banning order (Housing and Planning Act 2016 s21)Acting for a banned landlord or agentCheck the rogue landlord database at onboarding

The three rows inserted by the Renters' Rights Act are the ones that put day-to-day agency advice in scope[3]. A possession ground served on weak instructions, or an advert posted too early, is no longer only a civil penalty risk for the landlord. It can also become a claim for up to two years of rent.

Time limits and who can apply

A tenant can apply where the offence relates to housing let to them at the time and was committed in the 2 years ending with the day the application is made[2]. Before the reforms the window was shorter, so older complaints that tenants were told were out of time may now be live. For the two new possession and marketing offences, the requirement that the home was let to the applicant at the time does not apply in the same way[2].

Councils can also apply, including where rent was paid through housing benefit or Universal Credit, and they must have regard to government guidance when they do. A council that finds an unlicensed HMO during an inspection may also point the tenants towards RROs, so one licensing failure can produce several claims at once.

24 months

maximum rent a landlord can be ordered to repay, up from 12 months[1]

Who pays, and where agents fit

An order is made against the landlord. Since the reforms that includes superior landlords in rent-to-rent chains and, in defined cases, company directors[1]. The agent is not normally the respondent. That does not make agents safe. Agents acting for landlords can be liable for breaching the Renters' Rights Act enforcement measures in their own right[5], and a landlord facing an order will look hard at what the agency advised, whether licensing was in its terms of business and whether staff marketed a property they should not have.

  • Fully managed lets: the landlord will expect you to have tracked licensing and council notices. Make the allocation of that duty explicit in your terms.
  • Let-only instructions: record in writing that licensing, repairs and notices stay with the landlord after move-in.
  • Rent-to-rent operators: check whether your client is the immediate landlord or a superior landlord, because both can now face orders.
  • Corporate landlords: a director-level contact should sign off any possession ground, since directors are now in the frame.

How an application usually unfolds

  1. Trigger

    A council inspection, a failed possession claim or advice from a tenancy support charity identifies a possible offence.

  2. Application

    The tenant applies to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) with tenancy evidence and rent records for the period claimed.

  3. Directions

    The tribunal sets deadlines for bundles. Agencies are usually asked by the landlord for statements, adverts, notices and correspondence within days.

  4. Hearing

    The tribunal decides whether the offence was committed and, if so, how much of the rent for the relevant period to order back, considering conduct and financial circumstances.

  5. Payment and fallout

    The landlord pays. Councils may also pursue a civil penalty for the same facts, and the landlord may raise a complaint or claim against the agency.

Keep a ready-made evidence pack per property: licence status with dates, every notice served, every advert with its live dates and the landlord's written instructions. If the pack takes a day to assemble, it is not ready.

Example: an unlicensed HMO in a selective licensing area

Example (fictional): a five-bedroom house is let room by room at 700 pounds a month per room. The council extended additional licensing to the street eight months ago and the landlord never applied. Each of the five tenants applies for an order covering the period since licensing became mandatory.

  1. In the example, rent for the offence period is 5,600 pounds per tenant (eight months at 700 pounds), or 28,000 pounds across the house.
  2. The tribunal can award up to the full rent for the period of the offence, within the 24-month ceiling, and adjusts for the landlord's conduct.
  3. The council can separately consider a civil penalty for the licensing offence.
  4. The landlord asks the agency why the scheme change was not flagged, because the management agreement listed licensing monitoring as a managed service.

The control that would have prevented this costs very little: a quarterly check of each council's licensing pages for every managed address, logged with the date checked and the result.

Agency controls that reduce RRO risk

  1. Licensing register: record the scheme, licence number, expiry and conditions for every managed property, with a named owner.
  2. Possession ground sign-off: require a signed landlord declaration and supporting evidence before staff serve any ground based on selling or moving in.
  3. Restricted-period lock: when a ground 1 or 1A notice is served, set a marketing block on the address for 12 months. Under the Act, remarketing includes posting an online advert or telling someone the property may be available[5].
  4. Council notice diary: log every improvement notice and prohibition order with the compliance date and the contractor booked.
  5. Onboarding checks: confirm the landlord is not subject to a banning order before signing terms.
  6. Annual file review: sample five managed files per negotiator against this list and record the result.

Train front-line staff on the phrases that signal risk. When a tenant says 'the council came round' or 'my landlord wants us out so he can sell', the call should be logged and passed to whoever owns compliance the same day. Related reading: civil penalties under the Act and how agent liability works.

Talking to a landlord who has received a claim

Landlords often call the agency first. Staff should not give a view on whether the claim will succeed. A short script keeps the call useful without straying into legal advice.

  • 'Thank you for telling us straight away. We will send you everything we hold on the property today: notices, adverts, licence records and messages.'
  • 'The tribunal sets strict deadlines, so please check the directions letter for the date your evidence is due.'
  • 'We cannot advise on the merits. A housing solicitor can, and the sooner they see the papers the better.'
  • 'While this is open, please do not contact the tenants about the claim. Any contact should go through your representative.'

Then record the call, preserve the file and tell your insurer if your professional indemnity policy requires notice of circumstances. For portfolio-wide context, see how the private rented sector database will work and the PRS Landlord Ombudsman, both of which will create new records tenants and councils can use.

Frequently asked questions

Can a tenant get a rent repayment order without a criminal conviction?

Yes. The tenant applies to the First-tier Tribunal, which decides for itself whether the offence was committed. A prior prosecution is not needed.

How long does a tenant have to apply?

The offence must have been committed in the 2 years ending with the day the application is made.

Can a rent repayment order be made against a letting agent?

Orders are made against landlords, now including superior landlords and some company directors. Agents carry separate exposure through civil penalties and through claims from landlords about the advice and service they gave.

Does a rent repayment order stop a council fining the landlord?

No. A council can consider a civil penalty or prosecution for the same offence, and the tribunal takes the landlord's conduct and any convictions into account when setting the amount.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Housing and Planning Act 2016, section 41 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Housing and Planning Act 2016, section 40 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Implementing the Renters' Rights Act 2025: our roadmap for reforming the private rented sector (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Enforcement measures for landlords: Renters' Rights Act 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo