Renters rights

Rent increase challenges at the First-tier Tribunal

How tenants challenge a Form 4A rent increase at the tribunal, how open market rent is decided, when the new rent starts and the evidence agents need.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What the tribunal does
  2. How a challenge runs
  3. Validity checks before anything else
  4. Evidence that wins, and evidence that does not
  5. Reading the market before proposing
  6. Example: a challenge in Salford
  7. After the decision
  8. Reducing challenges in the first place
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • A tenant must apply to the tribunal before the start date of the new rent in the notice; the application costs £47 for notices dated from 1 May 2026[1].
  • The tribunal decides the open market rent, cannot set it above the landlord's proposal and does not backdate increases[2].
  • Landlords have 28 days to respond on Form MR2, and many cases are decided on the documents alone[1].
  • Market evidence is mixed: in August 2026, 59% of Propertymark letting agents said rents were static and 33% said they had risen[3].

What the tribunal does

When a landlord serves Form 4A proposing a new rent, the tenant can ask the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) to decide the rent instead. The tribunal's role under the Housing Act 1988 is to decide the open market rent: what the property would let for on the open market on the same terms[1]. The Renters' Rights Act changed the balance of risk. The tribunal can no longer set a rent above the landlord's proposal, so tenants never pay more than the landlord asked for, and the increase is not backdated[2].

That makes the tribunal a low-risk option for tenants and a reputational and financial risk for landlords. A tenant who applies loses nothing if the tribunal agrees with the landlord, and gains if it does not. Agencies should expect more applications than under the old system and prepare every proposal as though it will be tested.

£47

application fee for a tenant challenging a notice dated on or after 1 May 2026[1]

How a challenge runs

  1. Tenant applies before the start date

    The tenant applies online or on paper using Form MR1, and must do so before the start date of the new rent in the notice, even if still gathering evidence[1].

  2. Fee or exemption

    The application costs £47, with no fee for notices dated before 1 May 2026 or for social rented homes; help with fees may be available[1].

  3. Landlord responds

    The landlord can respond on Form MR2 within 28 days, copying the tenant and the tribunal; the tenant can reply on Form MR3[1].

  4. Papers, inspection or hearing

    The tribunal decides whether an inspection or hearing is needed. Decisions are often made on the documents alone[1].

  5. Decision

    The tribunal sets the open market rent, which can be the same as or lower than the landlord's proposal[1][2].

  6. New rent starts

    The tribunal usually makes the new rent payable from the proposed start date if that date is after the decision; if the date has passed, from the next payment date after the decision[1].

Tenants can also ask the tribunal to postpone the payment date on grounds of hardship, providing full details of their finances in the application[1]. The government's guide to the Act says the deferral can be up to a further two months[2].

Validity checks before anything else

A tenant's application can attack the notice itself as well as the figure. Before defending the rent, check that the notice was valid, because a defective notice means starting again and losing months. The landlord's guidance sets out the core rules: rent can rise only once a year, not in the first year of the tenancy, and the completed form must be given at least two months before the new rent is due to start[4].

  • Was the current Form 4A used, with its wording unchanged?
  • Did at least a year pass since the tenancy began and since any previous increase, including one under an old review clause?
  • Was the start date at least two months after the date the tenant received the notice?
  • Was the notice served on every tenant named on the agreement, and is there a record of how and when?
  • Does the proposed rent match the figure in any covering letter or email sent with the notice?

If any answer is no, tell the landlord at once and take advice on whether to withdraw and serve a fresh notice. Defending a flawed notice on its merits wastes the landlord's time and the tribunal's.

Evidence that wins, and evidence that does not

Because most cases are decided on paper, the landlord's written response is usually the whole case. A tribunal looking at open market rent wants comparable evidence: similar homes, let recently, nearby, with differences explained. A landlord's mortgage costs, insurance or plans for the property are not evidence of market rent.

A landlord's evidence pack for a rent determination
IncludeWhy it helps
Three to six achieved rents for similar homes let in the past six monthsShows what tenants are actually paying, not asking prices
Address, size, bedrooms, furnishing and condition for each comparableLets the tribunal adjust for differences
Photos and a short description of the subject propertyParticularly important if no inspection is held
Notes on features that justify a difference, such as parking or a gardenExplains why the figure sits where it does in the range
Any improvements the landlord made since the last rent was setSupports a higher figure if they add rental value
Area context such as official rent inflationUseful background, but not a substitute for comparables

Official data gives context. Private rents rose 3.8% across the UK and 4.0% in England in the 12 months to September 2026, but the rise ranged from 5.7% in the North West to 3.5% in London and the South East[5]. A proposal of 10% in an area where rents are rising at 3.5% will need very strong local comparables.

Annual private rent inflation, 12 months to September 2026
Annual private rent inflation, 12 months to September 2026Bar chart. North West: 5.7%; England: 4%; UK: 3.8%; London: 3.5%; South East: 3.5%.North WestNorth West: 5.7%5.7%EnglandEngland: 4%4%UKUK: 3.8%3.8%LondonLondon: 3.5%3.5%South EastSouth East: 3.5%3.5%Annual private rent inflation, 12 months to September 2026Bar chart. North West: 5.7%; England: 4%; UK: 3.8%; London: 3.5%; South East: 3.5%.North WestNorth West: 5.7%5.7%EnglandEngland: 4%4%UKUK: 3.8%3.8%LondonLondon: 3.5%3.5%South EastSouth East: 3.5%3.5%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
North West5.7%
England4%
UK3.8%
London3.5%
South East3.5%

Reading the market before proposing

Agents sit on the best evidence for local rents: their own lettings. Surveys suggest the market was flattening in places during 2026. In August, 59% of Propertymark letting agents said rents were static, 33% said they had risen and 6% said they had fallen[3]. Yet in September a net balance of +23% of RICS surveyors reported rising tenant demand[6]. Mixed signals like these are exactly when a tribunal will look closely at what similar homes have let for in the last few months.

  • Pull the agency's achieved rents for the same postcode district and property type before agreeing any figure.
  • Discard comparables older than six months unless there are no others, and say so.
  • Adjust for condition honestly: a tired kitchen or bathroom reduces market rent.
  • If the evidence supports only a small increase, recommend the small increase; a tribunal decision below the proposal costs the landlord the difference and the agency its credibility.

Example: a challenge in Salford

Example: a landlord proposes increasing the rent on a two-bedroom terrace in Salford from £950 to £1,075 a month, a 13% rise, on Form 4A with a start date of 1 December. The tenant applies to the tribunal in November, before the start date. The agency's response includes four comparables: two at £1,000, one at £1,025 and one at £1,100, the last with a new kitchen and a driveway. The subject property has an older kitchen and on-street parking. The tribunal decides on the papers and sets the rent at £1,010. Because the decision comes after 1 December, the new rent starts from the next payment date after the decision. The landlord would have done better proposing £1,010 at the start and avoiding the delay.

After the decision

Tribunal decisions are useful data. Each one tells the agency how an independent body valued a specific home against specific comparables, and over time those decisions show whether the agency's recommendations are well calibrated. Share each outcome with the landlord in a short note: the figure set, the start date, what the tribunal appeared to give weight to and what that means for the next review. Then update the rent schedule, the standing order instruction and the landlord statement from the correct date, and diary the next review twelve months after the new rent took effect.

Reducing challenges in the first place

  1. Tell the tenant before the notice is served and offer to share the comparables.
  2. Keep proposals within the range the evidence supports, and nearer the middle than the top.
  3. Fix outstanding repairs before proposing an increase; a tenant waiting for a repair is far more likely to challenge.
  4. Note any hardship the tenant mentions and give the landlord the option of a smaller increase or a later start date.
  5. Respond to every tribunal application within the 28-day window with a complete, well-organised pack.
  6. After each decision, update the agency's internal rent evidence so the next proposal benefits.

Script for a tenant who says they intend to challenge: 'That is your right, and the details of how to apply are on the notice. If it helps, I can send you the comparable lets we used so you can see how the figure was reached. If anything about the property affects its value, such as a repair that is outstanding, let me know now so we can take it into account.'

For the landlord's side of the process, see section 13 rent increases. When a property is relet rather than reviewed, the rules in the rental bidding ban apply instead.

Frequently asked questions

Can the tribunal increase the rent above what the landlord proposed?

No. Under the reforms, the tribunal cannot set a rent higher than the landlord's proposal. It can set the same rent or a lower one.

When must a tenant apply to challenge a rent increase?

Before the start date of the new rent given in the Form 4A notice. The application can be made online or on Form MR1.

Is there a fee to challenge a rent increase?

The application costs £47 for notices dated on or after 1 May 2026. There is no fee for notices dated before that date or for social rented homes, and help with fees may be available.

When does the new rent start after a tribunal decision?

Usually from the proposed start date if the decision comes before it. If that date has passed, the new rent usually starts from the next payment date after the decision. The tribunal can defer it in cases of hardship.

References

  1. HM Courts & Tribunals Service (GOV.UK) (2026). Apply for an open market rent determination (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Renting out your property: rent increases (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Private rent and house prices, UK: October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo