Renters rights

Renters' Rights Act compliance audit for agencies

A file-by-file Renters' Rights Act audit for letting agencies: templates, adverts, offers, money, notices and records, with sampling, scoring and fixes.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. How to run the audit
  2. Who should run it
  3. 1. Templates and tenancy documents
  4. 2. Adverts and listings
  5. 3. Offers and referencing
  6. 4. Money
  7. 5. Notices and possession
  8. 6. Records and communications
  9. Why audits pay for themselves
  10. Root causes behind red findings
  11. Example: a first audit at a two-branch agency
  12. Keeping the audit alive
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Audit six areas: templates, adverts, offers and referencing, money, notices and records.
  • Templates that still claim a fixed term risk a penalty of up to 7,000 pounds[1].
  • Relisting a property during the 12-month restricted period can cost up to 40,000 pounds[1].
  • Every advert, including on portals and social media, must show or link to your fees[2].
  • Lettings disputes resolved by The Property Ombudsman rose 65% in 2025[3]; audits catch the causes before complaints do.

How to run the audit

A compliance audit is only useful if it looks at what the agency actually does, not what its policies say. Pull real files, real adverts and real messages, compare them with the rules and record what you find. Run a full audit once, six months after the 1 May 2026 changes, and a lighter sample audit every quarter after that.

  1. Pick the sample

    For each branch, choose ten tenancies started since 1 May 2026, ten older tenancies, every live advert and every notice served in the last six months.

  2. Use one checklist

    Score every item against the same list below, so branches can be compared.

  3. Rate each finding

    Red: a breach that could bring a penalty or claim. Amber: a gap that could become one. Green: compliant with evidence on file.

  4. Fix reds within a week

    Assign an owner and a date for every red, and confirm the fix with evidence.

  5. Report and re-check

    Report results to the directors and re-check the same items at the next quarterly sample.

Who should run it

The person who wrote a process is the worst person to audit it, because they see what they meant rather than what happened. In a small agency, swap branches: the manager of one branch audits the other. In a single-office business, ask a trusted peer agency or an external compliance reviewer to run the first full audit, then train an internal lead for the quarterly samples.

Give the auditor read-only access to the CRM, the portal accounts, the social media pages and the shared inboxes. An audit that relies on staff to hand over files will only ever see the good ones.

1. Templates and tenancy documents

  • No tenancy template, letter or email refers to a fixed term, a renewal or a break clause. Claiming to let on a fixed-term tenancy can bring a penalty of up to 7,000 pounds[1].
  • Every tenancy that existed before 1 May 2026 has evidence that the government information sheet was given by 31 May 2026.
  • Every verbal tenancy has a written statement of terms, which landlords had to provide by 31 May 2026[1].
  • Terms of business for landlords reflect periodic tenancies, the possession grounds and the agency's refusal to act on unlawful instructions.
  • Notice templates are on the current prescribed forms, with a version date.

2. Adverts and listings

  • Every advert states an asking rent. Landlords and agents must publish one and cannot accept offers above it[4].
  • No advert or criteria excludes families with children or benefit claimants, directly or by wording such as 'professionals only'[4].
  • Your fee list is on your website, and every advert on Rightmove, Zoopla, Facebook or elsewhere lists the fees or links to them[2].
  • No property is advertised during a 12-month restricted period after a selling or moving-in ground. Remarketing includes posting an online advert or telling someone a property is or may be available[1].
  • The CRM is ready to record landlord and property registration numbers, which agents will need to confirm and show on adverts in future[5].

Search your own portal listings, social media posts and window cards on the same day. Old posts on social media are where restricted-period breaches hide.

3. Offers and referencing

  • Offer logs show no offer accepted above the asking rent.
  • Referencing decisions are recorded against a written affordability policy applied to every applicant.
  • Declined applications include the specific reason, using policy wording.
  • Holding deposits are no more than one week's rent, with the 15-day period or an agreed extension recorded[2].
  • Where a holding deposit was kept, the reason was given in writing within 7 days[2].
  • Right to rent checks are on file for every adult occupier, dated before the tenancy started.

4. Money

  • No more than one month's rent was taken in advance, and nothing before the tenancy agreement was signed[2].
  • Deposits are within the cap and protected within the deadline, with the certificate and prescribed information on file.
  • Every charge to a tenant is a permitted payment and matches the published fee list.
  • Client money protection certificate is displayed in the office and on the website.

Money findings are usually the easiest to evidence and the hardest to explain away, because bank records show exactly what was taken and when. Reconcile a sample of move-in payments against the tenancy start date and the signed agreement.

5. Notices and possession

  • Every notice served since 1 May 2026 cites a valid ground with the correct notice period and has proof of service.
  • Every selling or moving-in ground has a signed landlord declaration and evidence of genuine intention on file.
  • Every address with a selling or moving-in notice has a marketing block in the CRM with an end date 12 months later.
  • Section 13 rent increase notices give at least two months' notice and no tenancy has more than one increase in a year.
  • Tenant notices received by any channel, including texts or WhatsApp, were recognised and confirmed in writing[1].

6. Records and communications

  • Pet requests are logged with the date received, the date sent to the landlord and the decision within the initial 28-day window.
  • Repair reports have a date, triage decision and closure evidence.
  • Complaints have an acknowledgement, a final response and the redress route.
  • No staff member communicates with tenants from a personal phone or account.
  • Training records show each person's modules, scores and refresher dates.

Why audits pay for themselves

Complaints are rising. Lettings disputes resolved by The Property Ombudsman rose 65% to 3,119 in 2025, and the average award in lettings cases was 497 pounds[3]. Sales awards averaged more.

Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025
Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Comparison. Lettings cases: £497; Sales cases: £616.£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£616Sales casesSales cases: £616Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Comparison. Lettings cases: £497; Sales cases: £616.£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£616Sales casesSales cases: £616

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lettings cases£497
Sales cases£616

Awards are only part of the cost. Each dispute absorbs staff time, damages the landlord relationship and can sit alongside a council penalty for the same failure. An audit that finds one restricted-period advert or one fixed-term template before a council officer does has already justified itself.

Root causes behind red findings

Most red findings trace back to a handful of causes. Fixing the cause stops the same finding returning next quarter.

  • Old templates still saved on desktops or in email signatures, outside the controlled template library.
  • Adverts posted from personal or legacy social media accounts that nobody monitors.
  • No CRM block when a selling or moving-in notice is served, so the restriction depends on memory.
  • Landlord instructions accepted by phone without a written record or escalation.
  • Part-time and weekend staff who missed the training sessions.
  • Shared inboxes without an owner, so tenant requests and notices sit unread.

For each red finding, record the root cause alongside the fix. After two or three quarters, the pattern will show where the business needs a system change rather than another reminder.

Example: a first audit at a two-branch agency

Example (fictional): a compliance lead audits 40 tenancy files, 65 live adverts and 18 notices across two branches.

Example audit findings and actions
AreaFindingRatingFix
TemplatesWelcome letter still says 'your 12-month fixed term'RedRewritten and reissued within 3 days
AdvertsFour Facebook posts with no fee linkRedLinks added; posting checklist updated
AdvertsOne property relisted 7 months after a selling noticeRedAdvert removed; landlord and solicitor informed
OffersTwo files with no recorded reason for declining an applicantAmberDecision template made mandatory
RecordsThree pet requests logged lateAmberShared inbox and 28-day diary created
MoneyAll rent in advance within one monthGreenNone

In the example, the relisted property is the most serious finding because it may already be a breach. The agency removes the advert, records what happened and takes advice on whether any further action is needed.

Keeping the audit alive

Turn the checklist into a monthly ten-minute self-check for each branch manager, with the quarterly sample audit run by someone from another branch or an external reviewer. Update the checklist whenever guidance changes and date every version.

Related reading: the staff training plan, questions tenants ask, the How to Rent guide, private residential tenancies in Scotland and rent controls in Scotland for agencies working across borders.

Frequently asked questions

What should a Renters' Rights Act audit cover?

Templates and tenancy documents, adverts and listings, offers and referencing, money taken from tenants, notices and possession, and records and communications.

How often should a letting agency audit compliance?

A full audit once after the changes, then a quarterly sample and a short monthly self-check by branch managers.

What is the most serious finding to look for?

Any property advertised during a 12-month restricted period, any template claiming a fixed term and any offer accepted above the asking rent.

Do adverts on social media need fee information?

Yes. Adverts on third-party sites, including Facebook, must list the agent's fees or link to them.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Enforcement measures for landlords: Renters' Rights Act 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Register your rental property service: guidance for letting agents and property managers (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo