Staffing

Restrictive covenants when agency staff join competitors

Non-compete, non-solicitation and non-dealing clauses for estate agency staff: what courts enforce, reform plans, garden leave and protecting client data.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why this matters in estate agency
  2. The types of covenant
  3. What the courts look for
  4. The reform debate
  5. Drafting covenants that protect client relationships
  6. Lettings and property management staff
  7. Garden leave
  8. Client data and the criminal law
  9. When someone resigns to join a competitor
  10. Hiring from a competitor: the other side
  11. Example: a valuer leaving for a rival
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Under current law a non-compete clause is a restraint of trade and is unenforceable unless the employer can show it is reasonable to protect a legitimate business interest[1].
  • Around 5 million employees in Great Britain are estimated to work under a contract with a non-compete clause, typically lasting around six months[1]. The government has consulted on capping or banning them, so check the position before drafting.
  • For most agencies, a well-drafted non-solicitation and non-dealing clause, a confidentiality clause and garden leave protect client relationships better than a broad non-compete.
  • Client data belongs to the agency as controller. Knowingly or recklessly taking or keeping personal data without the controller's consent is a criminal offence[2].

Why this matters in estate agency

Estate agency is a relationship business in a crowded market. Around 90% of the UK's 31,430 real estate agencies are micro businesses with fewer than ten employees[3], and there may be several competitors on the same high street. With around 167,000 employees across Great Britain's real estate agencies in 2024[4], people move between local firms all the time. When a valuer or senior negotiator leaves, the risk is not only losing a good person but losing the vendors, landlords and applicants they know personally.

UK real estate agencies by size, 2026Enterprises in SIC 68310, by number of employees
UK real estate agencies by size, 2026Bar chart. Micro (0 to 9 employees): 28,330 businesses; Small (10 to 49): 2,910 businesses; Medium (50 to 249): 165 businesses; Large (250 or more): 25 businesses.Micro (0 to 9 employees)Micro (0 to 9 employees): 28,330 businesses28,330 businessesSmall (10 to 49)Small (10 to 49): 2,910 businesses2,910 businessesMedium (50 to 249)Medium (50 to 249): 165 businesses165 businessesLarge (250 or more)Large (250 or more): 25 businesses25 businessesUK real estate agencies by size, 2026Bar chart. Micro (0 to 9 employees): 28,330 businesses; Small (10 to 49): 2,910 businesses; Medium (50 to 249): 165 businesses; Large (250 or more): 25 businesses.Micro (0 to 9 employees)Micro (0 to 9 employees): 28,330 businesses28,330 businessesSmall (10 to 49)Small (10 to 49): 2,910 businesses2,910 businessesMedium (50 to 249)Medium (50 to 249): 165 businesses165 businessesLarge (250 or more)Large (250 or more): 25 businesses25 businesses

Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Micro (0 to 9 employees)28,330 businesses
Small (10 to 49)2,910 businesses
Medium (50 to 249)165 businesses
Large (250 or more)25 businesses

Restrictive covenants are the contract terms that try to limit that damage. They are often copied from templates, rarely reviewed and frequently unenforceable as written. Getting them right is cheaper than litigating them later, and most disputes are settled by the strength of the clause rather than in court.

The types of covenant

Restrictive covenants used in agency employment contracts
CovenantWhat it restrictsTypical use in agenciesEnforceability risk
Non-competeWorking for a competitor, or setting up one, in a defined area for a periodValuers, branch managers, directorsHighest: must be narrow, short and justified
Non-solicitation of clientsApproaching clients the employee dealt with to win their businessNegotiators, valuers, property managersModerate: needs a defined client group and period
Non-dealingAccepting business from those clients, even if the client approaches firstSenior staff with strong client relationshipsModerate to high: must be limited to clients the employee knew
Non-poaching of staffRecruiting former colleaguesManagers and directorsModerate: should cover senior or key staff only
ConfidentialityUsing or disclosing confidential informationEveryoneLow: lasts after employment, but must identify what is confidential
Garden leaveKeeping the employee away from work and clients during noticeSenior staffLow if the contract allows it and pay continues

What the courts look for

The law starts from the position that people should be free to work. The government's working paper on non-compete reform summarises the current position: a non-compete is treated as a restraint of trade and is unenforceable unless the employer can demonstrate it is reasonable, with a court deciding if it is challenged[1]. In practice, courts ask a series of questions.

  1. Is there a legitimate interest?

    The employer must be protecting something real, such as client connections, confidential information like a pipeline of instructions, or the stability of its workforce. Preventing competition for its own sake is not enough.

  2. Is the clause no wider than necessary?

    Duration, geography and the activities restricted must match the risk. A one-mile radius around a branch for six months may be defensible for a valuer; a 20-mile radius for two years for a trainee negotiator is unlikely to be.

  3. Is it right for this employee?

    A junior negotiator with no client relationships rarely justifies a non-compete; a branch manager who knows every landlord on the books may.

  4. Was it reasonable when agreed?

    Courts look at the position when the contract was signed or the clause was last agreed, so promotions are a good moment to update covenants.

  5. Can a narrower version be read?

    Courts may strike out an offending part, but they will not rewrite a clause to make it reasonable. Draft each restriction as a separate, stand-alone clause.

The reform debate

Non-competes are under review. In November 2025 the Department for Business and Trade published a working paper on options for reform, inviting responses by 18 February 2026[1]. It cites previous analysis that around 5 million employees in Great Britain work under a non-compete, typically lasting around six months, and sets out options including a statutory cap on duration, limits that vary by employer size, a ban below a salary threshold and a full ban[1].

The paper also asks whether any changes should extend to other covenants, such as non-dealing clauses. Until legislation is passed, the current common law test applies. Agencies drafting or updating contracts now should assume that long non-competes are the most vulnerable and that client-focused restrictions are the safer foundation.

Drafting covenants that protect client relationships

For most agencies the real asset is the client relationship, and the clauses below protect it without the risk of a broad non-compete.

  • Define the client group narrowly: vendors, landlords and applicants the employee dealt with, or had confidential information about, in the 12 months before leaving.
  • Keep durations proportionate: shorter for negotiators, longer only for staff with deep relationships, such as a valuer or a lettings manager responsible for a portfolio.
  • Include non-dealing as well as non-solicitation for senior staff, because clients often approach a departing negotiator rather than the other way round.
  • Set off any garden leave against the covenant period, so the total restriction is not excessive.
  • Tailor clauses by role. One template for everyone, from administrator to director, is the commonest reason clauses fail.
  • Review covenants on promotion, and give something in return for new restrictions, such as a pay rise or bonus, so there is clear consideration.
  • Take legal advice on wording. These clauses are technical, and small drafting errors can make them worthless.

Lettings and property management staff

Lettings creates a different risk. A property manager who leaves may know every landlord in a managed portfolio, their rent, their fee terms and their frustrations with the agency. That portfolio is recurring income, so losing even a handful of landlords to a former employee hurts for years.

For lettings managers and senior property managers, consider a non-dealing clause covering landlords they managed or had confidential information about in the final year, alongside a garden leave clause. Make sure management agreements with landlords are in the agency's name, that landlords know the agency rather than one individual and that more than one person in the team has a working relationship with each larger landlord. A portfolio that depends on one person is a covenant problem waiting to happen.

Garden leave

Garden leave allows the employer to keep an employee away from work and clients during their notice period while continuing to pay them. For a valuer leaving to join a rival, three months of garden leave can be more effective than any covenant: the employee cannot contact clients, the agency has time to introduce a new valuer to each vendor and the information the employee holds becomes less current.

It needs an express contract clause, and pay and benefits must continue. Use the time well: reassign the pipeline in the first week, call every vendor and landlord personally and make sure listings, portal profiles and email signatures no longer show the departing employee.

Client data and the criminal law

Covenants are contractual; data protection adds a statutory layer. The agency is the controller of the personal data in its CRM. Under section 170 of the Data Protection Act 2018, it is an offence for a person knowingly or recklessly to obtain or disclose personal data without the consent of the controller, or to retain it without consent after obtaining it[2]. A negotiator who exports applicant lists or forwards vendor details to a personal email before leaving may commit that offence, and selling such data is a separate offence.

Practical controls matter more than threats:

  • Limit exports from the CRM to managers, and log them.
  • Block forwarding of client emails to personal accounts.
  • Remove system access on the last working day, or at the start of garden leave.
  • Ask departing staff to confirm in writing that they hold no client data on personal devices.
  • Remind everyone, at induction and at exit, that client data belongs to the agency.

When someone resigns to join a competitor

  1. Read the contract

    Check notice, garden leave, covenants and confidentiality before the exit meeting, so you know what you can rely on.

  2. Decide on garden leave

    For client-facing senior staff, decide quickly whether they work their notice or go on garden leave.

  3. Protect the data

    Review recent CRM exports and email forwarding, then adjust access in line with your decision.

  4. Write to the employee

    Remind them of their obligations in a factual letter, without threats.

  5. Contact the clients

    Introduce the new contact to every vendor, landlord and key applicant in the departing employee's pipeline within days.

  6. Monitor and record

    Keep notes of any approaches to clients that come to light, with dates and evidence, in case advice or action is needed.

Most departures never reach a solicitor's letter. Agencies that move fast to look after clients usually keep them, whatever the covenant says.

Hiring from a competitor: the other side

The same rules apply in reverse. When recruiting an experienced negotiator from a rival, ask to see their covenants before making an offer, and avoid encouraging them to breach confidentiality or solicit clients. A new employee who brings their old employer's applicant list is a legal and reputational risk to your agency, not an asset. The recruitment guide covers how to build a pipeline of candidates without relying on poaching.

Example: a valuer leaving for a rival

Example: a fictional agency's senior valuer resigns to join a competitor two streets away. Her contract has a three-month notice period with a garden leave clause, a six-month non-dealing covenant covering vendors she met in the last year, and a confidentiality clause. The agency places her on garden leave immediately, removes her system access and introduces the branch manager to all 14 vendors in her pipeline that week. Two vendors ask about following her; the manager explains the agency's continued service and both stay. The covenant is never tested because the client relationships were secured first.

Frequently asked questions

Are non-compete clauses enforceable in the UK?

Sometimes. They are treated as a restraint of trade and are unenforceable unless the employer shows they are reasonable to protect a legitimate business interest. Short, narrow clauses for senior staff have the best chance.

Can a former negotiator contact our clients?

It depends on their contract. A well-drafted non-solicitation or non-dealing clause can prevent it for a limited period, and taking client data without consent can be a criminal offence regardless of the contract.

Is garden leave better than a non-compete?

Often, for agencies. It keeps the employee away from clients during notice while they are still paid, needs a contract clause and is less likely to be challenged than a long non-compete.

References

  1. Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2025). Working paper on options for reform of non-compete clauses in employment contracts (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Data Protection Act 2018, section 170: unlawful obtaining etc of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 68310, 68320), 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2024). Business Register and Employment Survey: open access (SIC 68310, 68320), 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo