Key takeaways
- Agents must forward accurate details of every offer to the seller promptly and in writing, and must not misrepresent offers or a buyer's position[1].
- National Trading Standards enforces the Estate Agents Act 1979 and can issue prohibition and warning orders to people found unfit for estate agency work[2].
- Compare offers on position, finance, timing and conditions as well as price, and give the seller a written summary.
- Give every bidder the same information and the same deadline, and log every offer and decision with dates and times.
When multiple offers happen
Even in a cautious national market, some homes attract several buyers at once: a well-priced family home near a popular school, a flat in a street that rarely comes up, or any home launched just below a portal search band. Multiple offers are good news for the seller, but they put the agent under pressure. Buyers are anxious, sellers want the best result, and every decision will be questioned by someone.
Handled well, a competitive situation produces a strong sale and several buyers who, though disappointed, would use the agency again. Handled badly, it produces accusations of unfairness, complaints and sometimes a sale that falls through because the winning buyer overstretched.
The legal ground rules
Schedule 3 of the Estate Agents (Undesirable Practices) (No. 2) Order 1991 sets out two duties that matter most when offers compete. It treats as undesirable the failure to forward to the client, promptly and in writing, accurate details of any offer received, including conditional offers, unless the client has said in writing that they do not want offers of that kind. It also covers any misrepresentation, made knowingly or recklessly, about the existence or details of an offer, or about the existence or status of a prospective buyer, where status includes their financial standing and ability to exchange quickly[1].
Two National Trading Standards teams, for estate agency and for letting agency work, enforce the Estate Agents Act 1979 and the Tenant Fees Act 2019[2], and they can issue prohibition and formal warning orders to people found unfit to do estate agency work[2]. Inventing a rival offer to push a buyer up, or overstating a favoured buyer's position, is not a sharp tactic; it is the kind of conduct that can end a career.
A fair best and final process
Agree the process with the seller first
Confirm in writing that the seller wants to invite best and final offers, the deadline and what information buyers must provide.
Tell every bidder the same thing at the same time
Send one message to all interested parties with the deadline, the format and what will be considered. Do not give one buyer extra hints.
Ask for the full picture
Price, how it will be funded, proof of deposit, mortgage agreement in principle, any property to sell and its status, preferred timescale and any conditions.
Forward every offer
Send each offer to the seller in writing promptly, even late ones or ones the seller has said they are unlikely to accept, unless they have told you in writing not to.
Summarise and recommend
Give the seller a written comparison and your recommendation, then let them decide.
Tell every bidder the outcome
Call the successful buyer first, then the others on the same day, and thank them.
Comparing offers beyond price
The highest offer is not always the best one. A buyer who cannot proceed, or who will renegotiate after the survey, can cost the seller months. Help the seller weigh the factors with evidence.
| Factor | What to ask | Evidence to see |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Is this the buyer's best figure? | The written offer |
| Funding | Cash, mortgage or a mix? | Proof of deposit, agreement in principle |
| Chain | Do they have a home to sell? | Sale agreed, with the other agent's details |
| Timescale | When do they want to complete? | Their conveyancer's details |
| Conditions | Any survey, planning or fixtures conditions? | Conditions in writing |
| Commitment | How have they behaved so far? | Viewing history, responsiveness |
Be careful how you describe buyers to the seller. Report what each buyer told you and what you have verified, and say clearly which is which. Overstating a buyer's financial position is exactly the misrepresentation the Order prohibits.
Sealed bids or open negotiation
There are two common ways to settle competing offers in England and Wales. In open negotiation, the agent goes back to each buyer in turn and invites them to improve, within the seller's instructions. In a sealed bids process, every buyer submits one final written offer by a deadline and the seller chooses. Both are legitimate if the process is honest and every buyer is treated the same.
- Open negotiation suits two or three buyers who are close on price and want to talk
- Sealed bids suit four or more buyers, or a situation where buyers say they want a clear, final process
- Whichever you choose, explain it to every buyer at the start and do not switch half-way without telling them all
- Agree with the seller in writing whether you may tell buyers how many offers have been received, and stick to it
- Never tell one buyer the amount of another's offer unless the seller has instructed you to, and then tell everyone the same
Scripts for the difficult calls
Inviting best and final offers: 'The seller has received more than one offer and has asked everyone to submit their best and final offer by noon on Thursday. Please send it in writing with your position and proof of funding. The seller will consider price, position and timing, and we will let everyone know the outcome the same day.'
Telling an unsuccessful buyer: 'Thank you for your offer. The seller has decided to accept another offer this time. I know that is disappointing. If anything changes, you will be the first person I call, and I would like to keep you in mind for similar homes.' Then record the buyer's details and criteria; a well-handled loser is often next month's buyer.
Record every offer and decision
Trust is fragile in this part of the job. Only 37% of people said they trust estate agents in the Ipsos Veracity Index of November 2024, as cited by the government[3]. Sales disputes resolved by The Property Ombudsman rose 9% to 2,243 in 2025[4], and the average award in sales cases rose to £616[4]. A clear offer log is the best protection for both the agency and the seller.
- Trust estate agents 37%
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Trust estate agents | 37% |
- Date and time each offer was received, and from whom
- The amount, funding and conditions as stated by the buyer
- What you verified, and how
- When and how the offer was forwarded to the seller
- The seller's instructions and decision, with the date
- When each bidder was told the outcome
After the decision
Winning buyers in a competitive situation sometimes overstretch, and around one in three property transactions fail[3]. Move quickly: send the memorandum of sale the same day, ask both sides to instruct conveyancers, and agree a timetable. Ask the seller whether they want the property marketed as sale agreed or withdrawn, and keep the details of the strongest unsuccessful bidders in case the sale collapses. In Scotland, the closing date system works differently; see our guide to closing dates in Scotland.
Lettings: several applicants for one home
Competition for rental homes works differently. The Renters' Rights Act ends rental bidding: landlords and agents must publish an asking rent and cannot ask for or accept offers above it[5]. When several applicants want the same home, choose on fair, consistent criteria such as affordability checks, references and move-in date, record the reasons, and tell unsuccessful applicants promptly. Never invite applicants to outbid each other.
Example: four offers on a terrace
Example: a two-bedroom terrace receives four offers in its first week. The negotiator agrees a best and final process with the seller, sends all four buyers the same email with a Friday noon deadline and asks for proof of funding. One buyer offers the highest price but has an unsold flat; another offers slightly less, has a mortgage agreement in principle and no chain.
Example: the negotiator sends the seller a written comparison of all four offers, recommends the chain-free buyer and explains why. The seller agrees. All four buyers are called by 3pm the same day, and the offer log is saved to the file. The sale completes ten weeks later, and one of the unsuccessful buyers buys another home through the branch the following month.
Frequently asked questions
Do estate agents have to tell the seller about every offer?
Yes. They must forward accurate details of every offer, including conditional ones, promptly and in writing, unless the seller has said in writing that they do not want offers of that kind.
Is it legal for an agent to invent a rival offer?
No. Misrepresenting the existence or details of an offer, or a buyer's position, is an undesirable practice and can lead to enforcement action.
How do you choose between multiple offers?
Compare price alongside funding, chain, timescale and conditions, using evidence the buyers have provided, and choose the offer most likely to complete on acceptable terms.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1991). The Estate Agents (Undesirable Practices) (No. 2) Order 1991, Schedule 3 (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Trading Standards (2026). NTS Estate Agency and NTS Letting Agency Teams (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑