Key takeaways
- No more than 2% of home movers in a poll cited by the government felt they had enough information before making an offer[1].
- Use a question log on every viewing: the question, who asked, who will answer and by when.
- Answer from documents and the seller in writing, never from memory or assumption.
- If the answer is material information, update the listing so every buyer sees it[2].
- 79% of consultation responses backed mandatory upfront property information, so expect more questions to be answered before viewings[3].
The question you dread at every viewing
Every negotiator knows the moment. The buyer is standing in the kitchen and asks whether the extension had building regulation approval, whether the loft could be converted, how old the boiler is, or whether the neighbours have ever complained about the tree. You do not know. The temptation is to give an answer that sounds helpful: 'I think so', 'most of these have been done', 'it should be fine'.
Those guesses cause real harm. A buyer who offers on the strength of a wrong answer may withdraw when their solicitor or surveyor finds the truth, taking weeks of work with them. Buyers already feel under-informed: a poll cited in the government's home buying and selling consultation found that no more than 2% of home movers believed they had received sufficient information before making an offer[1].
Why guessing is a compliance risk
National Trading Standards notes that agents are already obliged under the Consumer Protection Regulations not to omit material information from property listings, and its guidance divides that information into three parts: Part A, always material for all properties; Part B, information that should be established for all properties; and Part C, additional information that depends on whether the property is affected[2]. Misleading statements are covered by the same rules as misleading omissions, and the unfair commercial practices provisions of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 came into force on 6 April 2025[4].
Two National Trading Standards teams, for estate agency and letting agency work, enforce the Estate Agents Act 1979 and the Tenant Fees Act 2019[5]. The practical point for a negotiator is simple: 'I don't know, but I'll find out' is always safer than a confident guess.
Questions buyers ask that you should not answer from memory
| Question type | Examples | Where the answer comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Legal and title | Boundaries, rights of way, covenants, who owns the fence | Title register and plan, seller's property information form, solicitor |
| Permissions | Planning, building regulations, listed building consent | Seller's documents, council planning portal, building control records |
| Condition | Age of roof, boiler, wiring, damp history | Seller's records, service history, surveys the seller holds |
| Running costs | Service charge, ground rent, council tax, energy bills | Lease and management accounts, council tax band, EPC |
| Environment | Flood risk, subsidence, mining, noise | Seller disclosure, official flood and mining searches |
| Neighbours and area | Disputes, planned developments, schools | Seller disclosure, council planning applications, official school data |
| Connectivity | Broadband speed, mobile signal | Official coverage checkers and the seller's current provider |
Several of these overlap with what the material information guidance expects you to establish anyway. The more of it you gather at instruction, the fewer questions you will face at the door.
Run a question log for every viewing
A question log is a short record attached to the property file. It does not need special software; a shared sheet or a note field on the listing will do. What matters is that every unanswered question is written down, given an owner and closed with a written answer.
Capture the question exactly
Write down the buyer's words, not your interpretation. 'Has the side extension got building regs?' is more useful than 'asked about extension'.
Note who asked and when
Link the question to the applicant record and the viewing date, so you know who is waiting for an answer.
Assign the source
Decide whether the seller, a document or a third party will answer. Most questions go to the seller first.
Set a reply time
Promise a time you can meet, usually 24 to 48 hours. Put a reminder in the diary.
Answer in writing
Email the buyer the answer and the evidence, such as a copy of a certificate, and keep a copy on file.
Decide if it is material
If the answer would affect other buyers' decisions, add it to the listing and the property details.
What to say when you do not know
Buyers respect an honest gap more than a vague answer. Use a form of words that shows you take the question seriously and gives a clear next step.
Script: 'That's a good question and I don't want to guess. I'll check with the owner and the paperwork and email you by tomorrow evening. Is there anything else you'd like me to find out at the same time?'
That last question matters. It turns one query into a list, and it often surfaces the real concern behind the first question. A buyer who asks about the boiler may really be worried about running costs, and the EPC and recent bills may answer them better than the boiler's age.
Getting answers from the seller
Sellers do not always know the answers either, and some are nervous about saying the wrong thing. Make it easy for them to help.
- Send questions in writing, in batches, rather than ringing the seller after every viewing.
- Ask for documents rather than recollections where they exist: certificates, guarantees, planning letters, service records.
- Explain that the same information will be needed by the buyer's solicitor, so finding it now saves time later.
- If the seller does not know, say so to the buyer rather than filling the gap.
- If the seller asks you to withhold something material, explain that you cannot, and record the conversation.
When the answer changes the listing
Some answers are only of interest to the buyer who asked. Others change what every buyer should know. A planned development next door, a flood history, a short lease or an unapproved extension are examples of information that may be material. If an answer falls into that category, update the listing and the property details, tell buyers who have already viewed, and record the change and the date.
Expect this to become routine. The government's roadmap says it will publish non-statutory guidance on the quality of information in property listings in 2026[3], and 79% of responses to its consultation backed a mandatory requirement for comprehensive upfront property information[3].
The same discipline at rental viewings
Tenants ask different questions, but the risk of guessing is the same. Common ones are whether pets will be considered, whether the landlord will allow a home office or a fixed desk, how quickly repairs are dealt with, whether the furniture can be removed, which council tax band applies and what the broadband is like. Some of these are the landlord's decision rather than a fact you can look up.
- Log the question in the same way, with the applicant and the date.
- Put decisions such as pets or alterations to the landlord in writing, and pass the written reply back to the applicant.
- Do not promise a landlord's agreement on the doorstep, even when you think it is likely.
- Keep answers about fees and deposits consistent with your published fee list.
Lettings viewings are often booked back to back for one property, so a single unanswered question can be asked by six applicants in a morning. Answering it once, in writing, and adding it to the property's information sheet saves time for everyone.
Example: the extension question
Example: at a fictional semi, a buyer asked whether the rear extension had building regulation approval. The negotiator said she did not know, logged the question and emailed the seller that afternoon. The seller found a completion certificate for the extension but nothing for a later loft room used as a third bedroom.
Example, continued: the negotiator sent the buyer the extension certificate, told them the loft room had no approval on file, and updated the listing to describe the loft as a room without building regulation sign-off. Two other buyers who had viewed were told. The first buyer still offered, at a level that reflected the loft. Had she guessed 'yes' at the viewing, the sale would likely have collapsed at the enquiries stage. The details are illustrative.
Prepare the answers before the first viewing
The best question log is a short one. At instruction, ask the seller for the documents behind the questions buyers most often ask, and build a one-page property fact sheet: tenure, council tax band, service charge and ground rent where relevant, heating and boiler age, broadband and mobile coverage, parking, any known building works and their approvals. Give it to every negotiator who will hold viewings, and hand a copy to buyers. Over time, review your logs to see which questions keep coming up, and add those answers to the fact sheet template for every new instruction.
Frequently asked questions
What should I say if a buyer asks a question I can't answer at a viewing?
Say you do not want to guess, write the question down, and promise a written answer by a specific time after checking with the seller and the documents.
Is it illegal for an estate agent to guess an answer?
Giving a misleading statement or leaving out material information can breach consumer protection law. A guess that turns out to be wrong can be misleading, so it is safer to check before answering.
Do I have to tell other buyers what I find out?
If the answer is material information that would affect buyers' decisions, update the listing and tell buyers who have already viewed. Answers of purely personal interest can go to the buyer who asked.
What if the seller won't answer a buyer's question?
Tell the buyer the seller has not provided an answer, rather than filling the gap yourself. If the seller asks you to hide material information, explain that you cannot and record the conversation.
References
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Trading Standards (2023). Full material information guidance published (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Home buying and selling reform roadmap (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Reviews and social media endorsements: guidance for businesses and brands (opens in a new tab) ↑
National Trading Standards (2026). NTS Estate Agency and NTS Letting Agency Teams (opens in a new tab) ↑