Valuations instructions

Winning back withdrawn and expired listings

How to approach sellers whose home did not sell: timing, a letter that never criticises the last agent, diagnosing what went wrong and a fresh-start plan.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why homes come off the market unsold
  2. Who you are approaching
  3. Rules before you approach
  4. When to make contact
  5. The first letter
  6. Diagnose what went wrong
  7. Resetting the figure
  8. The fresh-start plan
  9. Check the dual-fee risk
  10. Example: a semi back on the market
  11. When the seller is not ready
  12. When the seller is angry
  13. Do not criticise the last agent
  14. Track the results
  15. Frequently asked questions
  16. References

Key takeaways

  • Many homes leave the market unsold: in London in October 2026, only 42% of listings found a buyer[1].
  • Wait until the seller is free of their last agreement, and check the dual-fee risk before they commit to you[2].
  • Never criticise the previous agent; diagnose the listing instead, with the seller.
  • Most failed listings come down to price, presentation or access, and the seller usually knows which.
  • Offer a fresh-start plan with a short minimum term, so the seller's risk is low.

Why homes come off the market unsold

Homes leave the market without a sale for many reasons. Some sellers change their plans. Some are priced above what buyers will pay and give up after reductions. Some are poorly presented, hard to view or marketed to the wrong buyers. In London in October 2026, 38% of listings had been reduced and only 42% of homes found a buyer, after an average of 78 days[1].

London homes on the market that found a buyer, October 2026Rightmove House Price Index
London homes on the market that found a buyer, October 2026Donut chart. Found a buyer: 42%.Found a buyer: 42%42%
  • Found a buyer 42%

Source: Rightmove, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Found a buyer42%

Each of those sellers still has a home, and many still want to move. The agent who approaches them well, at the right time, can win an instruction that is easier to sell second time round, because the seller's expectations have already been tested.

Who you are approaching

  • Withdrawn listings: the seller took the home off the market, often frustrated, sometimes with plans unchanged.
  • Expired listings: the agreement ran out without a sale, and the seller has not yet chosen what to do.
  • Relisted homes: back on with a new agent, so not your target unless that agreement also ends.
  • Sales that fell through: the home is back on the market with the same agent; leave it alone.

Rules before you approach

The Property Ombudsman's code says agents must not use unfair methods to seek business, and must not harass anyone or repeatedly try to gain instructions in a way likely to cause offence[2]. If you phone, screen the number against the Telephone Preference Service and respect anyone who has said not to call[3]. Marketing emails and texts need consent, which you will not have for a seller you have never dealt with[4]. A letter is usually the safest first contact.

Do not try to persuade a seller to break an agreement that is still running. Wait until it has ended, or until they tell you it has.

When to make contact

  1. Spot it

    Note homes that disappear from the portals without a sold board, and expiry dates you hear about from sellers or buyers.

  2. Wait

    Give the seller a few weeks. Approaching the day after a withdrawal looks opportunistic.

  3. Write

    Send one personal letter, addressed to the owner, with a reason to talk: local evidence, a matched buyer or a plain offer of a second opinion.

  4. Follow up once

    If there is no reply after a fortnight, one short follow-up letter, then stop.

The first letter

Script: 'I noticed your home is no longer on the market, and wanted to write in case you are still thinking about moving. Every sale is different, and there are many reasons a home does not sell first time. If it would help, I'd be happy to give a second opinion on the figure and the marketing, with no obligation. We have sold four homes on your road in the last year and have buyers registered for homes like yours. If now is not the time, please ignore this letter and I won't write again.'

Replace the street detail with your own real figures; never claim sales or buyers you do not have. The letter avoids three things: it does not mention the previous agent, it does not suggest the home was overpriced and it does not promise a result. It offers help and an easy way to say no.

Diagnose what went wrong

Common symptoms of a failed listing and the questions to ask
SymptomLikely causeQuestion to ask the seller
Few viewingsFigure too high for the band, or weak photosHow many viewing requests did you get in the first month?
Viewings but no offersFigure too high against competing homesWhat did buyers say after viewing?
Offers rejectedSeller's expectation above the marketWhat offers came in, and how far from asking were they?
Sale agreed then fell throughBuyer not checked, or chain problemsWhat went wrong, and when?
Few viewing slotsAccess difficult or seller-led viewingsWho showed buyers round, and when?

Ask, listen and take notes. Sellers usually know what went wrong, even if they blame the agent for it. Your job is to help them see the cause without making them feel foolish.

Resetting the figure

Price is the most common cause, and the hardest to raise. In August 2026, 86% of Propertymark member agents reported homes selling below asking and only 9% at asking[5]. A seller whose home did not sell at the old figure will need evidence before accepting a new one. Bring recent completed sales and the homes currently competing, and let the seller compare.

Avoid simply quoting lower than the last agent. If the old figure was too high, say what the evidence supports and why, and let the seller draw the conclusion. Many will have reached it already.

The fresh-start plan

  • New photographs and a new description, so the listing does not look like the old one.
  • A launch to registered buyers before the portals, with a count of matched buyers.
  • Accompanied viewings with feedback within a day.
  • A short minimum term, so the seller's risk is low.
  • Agreed review dates at two and five weeks.
  • A clear answer to what went wrong last time, built into the plan.

Check the dual-fee risk

Before the seller signs, the code requires you to ask whether they have instructed another agent and to point out the risk of paying more than one fee[2]. A fee may be owed to the previous agent if a buyer it introduced exchanges within six months of the end of its instruction, or within two years with no other agent involved[2]. Ask the seller for the previous agent's list of introduced buyers, and do not chase those buyers yourself without discussing the position.

Example: a semi back on the market

Example: a three-bedroom semi was withdrawn in July after four months and two reductions. In September, a negotiator sends a single letter offering a second opinion. The seller calls back. Together they work out that viewings were rare because the seller conducted them only on weekday evenings, and that the last reduction still left the home above two similar ones nearby. The negotiator proposes accompanied weekend viewings, new photographs and a figure in line with the evidence. The home agrees a sale in five weeks.

When the seller is not ready

Some sellers reply to say they have decided to stay, or to wait until next year. Treat that as a result, not a failure. Thank them, ask whether you may write again at a time they choose, and record their answer. If they say yes, put a date in the diary and send something useful when it comes round: recent sales on the street, or a short note on how the market has moved. If they say no, remove them from every list. A seller who felt respected when they said no is far more likely to call you when their plans change.

When the seller is angry

A seller whose home failed to sell may be angry, with the market, the last agent or agents in general. Let them talk. Do not defend the profession or the previous agent, and do not agree with every complaint either. Acknowledge the frustration, ask what they would want done differently, and write their answers down. Those answers are your brief. A seller who has been listened to properly often instructs the agent who listened, even before hearing the figure.

Do not criticise the last agent

It is tempting to agree when a seller complains about their previous agent. Resist it. The seller may later feel foolish for choosing them, the criticism may be unfair, and it invites a complaint if you say something inaccurate. Talk about what you will do, not what the other agent failed to do. If the seller presses, say: 'I can't speak for how they worked. Here's how we'd approach it.'

Track the results

  • Letters sent to withdrawn and expired listings, by month.
  • Responses, valuations booked and instructions won.
  • Days to sale agreed for won-back homes against your average.
  • Any complaints or requests to stop, which show whether the tone is right.

Frequently asked questions

When should I contact a seller whose listing expired?

After their agreement has ended and a few weeks have passed. Write once, follow up once, then stop.

Is it legal to approach sellers of withdrawn homes?

Yes, if you use fair methods, do not harass, respect TPS and objections for calls, and have consent for marketing emails or texts.

Should I tell the seller their last agent overpriced the home?

No. Show the current evidence and let the seller draw conclusions. Criticising the previous agent rarely helps and can backfire.

Could the seller owe two fees if they instruct me?

Possibly, if a buyer introduced by the previous agent goes on to buy. Explain the risk and check the previous agent's list before they sign.

References

  1. Rightmove (2026). House Price Index, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Property Ombudsman (2026). Code of Practice for Residential Estate Agents (TPOE27-9, March 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2019). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 21 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo