Property management

Change of sharer: replacing a tenant in a shared let

A letting agent's process for a change of sharer: landlord consent, referencing, right to rent, deposit transfer, the £50 fee cap and the paperwork.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why sharer changes go wrong
  2. Step one: take the request properly
  3. Step two: get the landlord's decision
  4. The two routes compared
  5. Step three: reference and check the incoming sharer
  6. Step four: settle the deposit
  7. Step five: fee, documents and handover
  8. When the landlord says no, or the newcomer fails
  9. Mistakes to check for before you sign
  10. Example: a swap in a three-bed let
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Agents can charge up to £50 for a tenant-requested change to a tenancy agreement unless higher costs are shown to be reasonable[1].
  • Every incoming sharer aged 18 or over needs a right to rent check before they move in[2].
  • If a new deposit is taken, it must be protected within 30 days of receipt[3].
  • Decide early whether the change is a fresh tenancy or a documented variation, and use the same checklist every time.

Why sharer changes go wrong

A change of sharer looks like admin: one name off, one name on. In practice it touches referencing, immigration checks, deposit protection, the tenancy document and the landlord's consent, and each of those has its own rules. Most disputes later come from one of three gaps: nobody checked the newcomer properly, the outgoing sharer's deposit share was handled informally between flatmates, or the paperwork still names someone who left months ago.

The fix is a fixed sequence, run the same way for every request. The sections below give that sequence, the fee you can charge for it and the evidence to keep.

Step one: take the request properly

Most requests start with a call or message from the sharer who wants to leave. Capture the details in one go so the file starts complete: who is leaving, the date they want to go, whether a replacement has been found, the replacement's contact details and whether the remaining sharers agree.

Ava can take that first call when the office is busy, log the details with a transcript and summary, and pass it to the lettings team, so a sharer who rings at 7pm does not have to repeat themselves the next day.

  • Confirm in writing that nothing changes until the landlord consents and the checks are complete.
  • Tell the outgoing sharer that they remain responsible under the current agreement until the change is signed.
  • Send the incoming applicant your application form, the referencing consent and the list of right to rent documents.

Step two: get the landlord's decision

The landlord decides whether to accept the replacement and on what terms. Put three questions to them in writing: will they accept a named replacement subject to referencing, do they want any change to the rent or terms at the same time, and do they want a new tenancy for the whole household or a variation of the existing one. The answer to the third question drives the paperwork, so take advice on the document your tenancy type needs rather than improvising.

The two routes compared

Choosing between a new tenancy and a variation
PointNew tenancy for the householdDocumented variation
What is signedA fresh agreement naming all current occupiersA deed or variation recording the change, signed by all parties
Written termsIssue a written statement of terms for the new tenancyUpdate the existing record and keep the variation with it
DepositOften returned and re-taken, or transferred with all parties' agreementStays in place, with the scheme told of the change
Best whenSeveral people are changing or terms are being updatedOne like-for-like swap with no other change
RiskMore admin, but a clean startEasy to leave gaps if the scheme and file are not updated

Since the Renters' Rights Act, landlords in England have been required to give a written statement of terms, with a deadline of 31 May 2026[4]. Whichever route you take, make sure the household's written statement of terms reflects who actually lives there.

Step three: reference and check the incoming sharer

Treat the newcomer like any new applicant. Run the same referencing standard you use for a new let: identity, income or guarantor, previous landlord and affordability for their share of the rent. Do not lower the bar because the existing sharers vouch for a friend.

Right to rent applies to the incoming sharer. In England, landlords or their agents must check the right to rent of all tenants aged 18 and over, even those not named on the tenancy agreement[2]. If the person has time-limited permission to stay, the check must be done in the 28 days before their tenancy starts[5]. Diarise a follow-up check where permission expires.

Step four: settle the deposit

This is where informal arrangements cause the most harm. Flatmates often agree that the newcomer will pay the leaver their share of the deposit directly. That leaves the protected deposit naming someone who has left, and no record of who paid what.

Deposit deadlines in England and Wales
Deposit deadlines in England and WalesComparison. Protect a deposit after receiving it: 30 days; Return it after the amount is agreed: 10 days.30 daysProtect a deposit after receiving itProtect a deposit after receiving it: 30 days10 daysReturn it after the amount is agreedReturn it after the amount is agreed: 10 daysDeposit deadlines in England and WalesComparison. Protect a deposit after receiving it: 30 days; Return it after the amount is agreed: 10 days.30 daysProtect a deposit after receiving itProtect a deposit after receiving it: 30 days10 daysReturn it after the amount is agreedReturn it after the amount is agreed: 10 days

Source: GOV.UK, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Protect a deposit after receiving it30 days
Return it after the amount is agreed10 days

If you take a new or replacement deposit, it must be protected in a government-backed scheme within 30 days of receipt[3], and there are three schemes in England and Wales[6]. If the deposit is returned at the change, it must be repaid within 10 days of landlord and tenants agreeing how much is returned[7]. Any deposit you take for the new arrangement still has to respect the cap of 5 weeks' rent where annual rent is below £50,000[8].

Whatever the household agrees between themselves, record it. A signed note from the leaver confirming they have been repaid their share by the newcomer, and the scheme updated, prevents the most common end-of-tenancy dispute.

Step five: fee, documents and handover

You can charge up to £50 for a tenant-requested change to the tenancy agreement, unless you can show that higher costs are reasonable[1]. Publish the fee on your fee list and quote it when the request arrives, not after the work is done.

  1. Prepare documents

    Draft the new tenancy or the variation, the written statement of terms and the deposit paperwork for the scheme.

  2. Sign in one sitting

    Collect signatures from the landlord, remaining sharers, outgoing sharer and incoming sharer. Missing one signature is the usual cause of delay.

  3. Inventory note

    Record the condition of the leaver's room and any shared items, with dated photos, and agree any deductions from their share.

  4. Keys and access

    Collect the leaver's keys, fobs and parking permits and issue them to the newcomer on the same day.

  5. Update systems

    Change rent splits, contact details, utility notifications if you handle them, and the landlord statement.

When the landlord says no, or the newcomer fails

Not every request ends in a swap. The landlord may refuse a named replacement, or the newcomer may fail referencing. Tell the household quickly and in writing, give the reason as far as you can without disclosing the applicant's personal data to the others, and set out the options. Usually those are: find another replacement, the remaining sharers take on the leaver's share, or the household ends the tenancy in the normal way.

Do not let the leaver walk away informally while the agreement still names them. Explain plainly that a move-out date and a legal change are different things, and confirm what each person remains responsible for until the paperwork is signed. If the remaining sharers want to cover the rent shortfall for a few weeks while they look, record that arrangement too.

Mistakes to check for before you sign

  • The incoming sharer moved in before the right to rent check was completed.
  • The deposit scheme still names the outgoing sharer after the change.
  • The rent split in your accounts system was not updated, so arrears appear against the wrong person.
  • The change fee was charged before the fee was quoted, or charged above the cap without evidence of reasonable costs.
  • Keys and fobs were handed over between flatmates without being logged.
  • The landlord's consent was given by phone and never confirmed in writing.

Run this list as a final check on the file before signatures. It takes two minutes and catches the gaps that otherwise surface at check-out, months later, when the people involved have moved on and nobody remembers who agreed what.

Example: a swap in a three-bed let

Example: three friends rent a three-bed house in Sheffield at £1,350 a month. One is moving abroad and has found a replacement. The agent logs the request, gets the landlord's consent in writing, references the newcomer and completes a right to rent check. The household chooses a variation. The newcomer pays £50 change fee, the leaver confirms in writing that the newcomer has repaid their deposit share, and the agent updates the deposit scheme records on the day of signing. The inventory note shows a scuffed wall in the leaver's room, agreed at £40 and deducted from what the newcomer paid across. Total time on file: about two weeks.

For the newcomer's first week, send the same tenant welcome pack you would send any new tenant. It reduces avoidable calls about bins, meters and repairs.

Frequently asked questions

How much can a letting agent charge for a change of sharer?

Up to £50 for a tenant-requested change to the tenancy agreement, unless the agent can show higher costs are reasonable[1].

Does the replacement sharer need a right to rent check?

Yes. In England all tenants aged 18 and over must be checked before the tenancy, even those not named on the agreement[2].

Can flatmates just repay each other's deposit share?

They can agree it, but record it in writing and update the deposit scheme so the protected deposit matches who lives there.

Is a new tenancy or a variation better?

A variation suits a single like-for-like swap. A new tenancy is cleaner when several people or terms change. Take advice on the document your tenancy type needs.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Checking your tenant's right to rent: Who you have to check (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Enforcement measures for landlords: Renters' Rights Act 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). Checking your tenant's right to rent: Who you have to check (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo