Lettings compliance

Check-out inspections and deposit returns

How letting agents run check-out inspections, compare them with check-in, propose fair deductions and return deposits within the 10-day deadline.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. The check-out sets the tone for the whole tenancy
  2. A check-out timeline that works
  3. Comparing check-in and check-out
  4. Writing the proposal
  5. When the tenant disagrees
  6. Speed matters for the landlord too
  7. Shared houses and partial departures
  8. Agreeing the approach with the landlord first
  9. Returning the deposit
  10. Common check-out failings
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Once landlord and tenant agree the amount, the deposit must be returned within 10 days[1].
  • If they disagree, the disputed sum stays protected in the scheme until the issue is settled[1].
  • Run the check-out against the check-in report line by line, on the day the tenant leaves, before contractors go in.
  • Send an itemised proposal with photos quickly; slow, vague proposals are what turn into complaints.

The check-out sets the tone for the whole tenancy

Most tenants remember two moments from a tenancy: moving in and getting their deposit back. A slow, unclear check-out undoes years of good management, and a fair, quick one is the best reference an agency can earn. The process is short, but each step has a deadline or a trap.

The legal anchor is simple. The deposit must be returned within 10 days of the landlord and tenant agreeing how much the tenant gets back[1]. If they cannot agree, the deposit stays protected in the scheme until the issue is settled[1]. Everything else is about reaching a fair agreement quickly, with evidence to back it.

A check-out timeline that works

  1. Four weeks before the end

    Write to the tenant confirming the end date, the check-out appointment and what is expected: cleaning to the check-in standard, keys returned, personal items removed, meter readings taken. Attach the check-in report as a reminder.

  2. On the day the tenant leaves

    Carry out the check-out with the check-in report open, ideally with the tenant present. Photograph each room from the same positions used at check-in.

  3. Within two working days

    Finish the check-out report, with side-by-side photos for every item that has changed, and send it to the landlord with your recommendation.

  4. Within five working days

    Send the tenant an itemised proposal, including any agreed deductions, with photos and quotes, and a clear date for their response.

  5. On agreement

    Prepare the repayment straight away so the deposit is returned well inside the 10-day limit.

  6. If there is no agreement

    Release the undisputed balance where the scheme allows and move the disputed amount into the scheme's dispute process.

Comparing check-in and check-out

The comparison should be mechanical. Go room by room in the check-in order, and for each item ask whether the condition or cleanliness has changed beyond what normal use explains.

Recording the comparison
ItemCheck-inCheck-outChangeProposed action
Lounge carpetGood, light flattening, professionally cleanedGood, light flattening, two red stains by sofaStains beyond normal useSpecialist clean, quote attached
Kitchen ovenProfessionally cleanedHeavy grease on racks and doorCleanliness worseOven clean, invoice attached
Bedroom 1 wallsExcellent, decorated before tenancyLight scuffs near bedNormal wear after two yearsNo deduction
GardenLawn cut, beds weeded, summerLawn long, beds overgrown, summerGarden care clause not metGardener visit, quote attached
KeysTwo front door keys, one back doorOne front door key, one back doorOne key missingCost of a key, receipt attached

Each row records what changed and why it matters. A row with no change gets no deduction, and saying so in the report shows the tenant you looked at the evidence fairly. For the maths on older items, see fair wear and tear: realistic deposit deductions.

Writing the proposal

Tenants respond to proposals that are clear, specific and fair. Use the same structure every time.

Example proposal: Thank you for returning the keys on 30 April. The check-out report and photos are attached, with the check-in photos alongside. We propose returning £1,310 of your £1,500 deposit. The deductions are: oven clean £90, invoice attached, because the oven was professionally cleaned at check-in and needed cleaning again; and specialist carpet stain removal £100, quote attached, for the two stains shown in photos L-3 and L-4. We have not charged for scuffs on the bedroom walls, which we consider normal wear. Please reply by 10 May to accept or tell us which items you disagree with.

Never add admin or check-out fees to the proposal. Under the Tenant Fees Act only permitted payments can be taken from tenants[2], and agency time for handling the check-out is not one of them.

When the tenant disagrees

Some tenants will challenge, and some challenges are fair. Read the reply properly, check the evidence again, and change the proposal if the tenant has a point. Where you still disagree, point them to the scheme's dispute service. The tenant should already know the route, because the prescribed information at the start of the tenancy explains what to do if there is a dispute over the amount to be returned[3].

  • Agree and return the undisputed part as soon as the scheme process allows.
  • Prepare the evidence bundle while the details are fresh: check-in, check-out, photos, invoices, correspondence.
  • Keep the landlord informed in writing of each step and your view of the likely outcome.
  • Record the final outcome and the lessons for future check-ins.

Unresolved deposit problems also feed complaints about the agency. The Property Ombudsman's average award in lettings cases was £497 in 2025[4], a cost often larger than the deduction that started the argument.

Average Property Ombudsman awards by case type, 2025
Average Property Ombudsman awards by case type, 2025Comparison. Lettings cases: £497; Sales cases: £616.£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£616Sales casesSales cases: £616Average Property Ombudsman awards by case type, 2025Comparison. Lettings cases: £497; Sales cases: £616.£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497£616Sales casesSales cases: £616

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lettings cases£497
Sales cases£616

Speed matters for the landlord too

A quick check-out is good for the landlord as well as the tenant. Contractors cannot start until the condition is recorded, and marketing photos wait for the clean and repairs. Propertymark agents reported an average void period of almost four weeks in August 2026[5]. Every day the check-out report sits unfinished adds to that void.

Example: an agency sets a rule that check-out reports are completed on the day and contractor work is booked within 24 hours. A two-bedroom flat vacated on a Friday is reported the same afternoon, cleaned on Monday, repaired on Tuesday and photographed for the new listing on Wednesday. The tenant's deposit proposal goes out on Tuesday with the cleaning invoice attached, is accepted on Thursday and repaid the following Monday.

Shared houses and partial departures

Joint tenancies in shared houses rarely end neatly. One sharer leaves while others stay, or the group leaves over several weeks. The deposit usually belongs to the tenancy as a whole, so plan the check-out around the tenancy rather than the individual.

  • When one sharer leaves mid-tenancy, inspect their room and the shared areas, and record the condition, but agree in writing how their share of the deposit is handled.
  • Do not deduct from a departing sharer for shared-area issues that the remaining tenants will continue to affect.
  • At the final check-out, compare against the check-in report and any interim reports, so each period is judged on its own evidence.
  • Ask the tenants to agree among themselves how any deductions are split, and record their agreement before paying out.

Agreeing the approach with the landlord first

The check-out goes faster when the landlord knows in advance how deductions will be judged. Share your approach at instruction and again when notice is given: like-for-like comparison with the check-in, allowance for age and wear, evidence for every cost, and the 10-day return once agreed. Ask the landlord to confirm in writing who decides the final proposal and how quickly they will respond to your recommendation. A landlord who replies in a week can turn a fast check-out into a slow return, so agree a response time and remind them of the deadline when you send the report.

Returning the deposit

How the return works depends on the scheme model. Under a custodial scheme, both parties confirm the split and the scheme pays out. Under an insured scheme, the agent or landlord pays the tenant from the client account and closes the protection. In both cases, the 10-day limit runs from agreement[1], so do not wait for a monthly payment run.

  • Check the tenant's bank details directly with the tenant, not from an email that could be spoofed.
  • Pay joint tenants in the proportions they agreed, or as one payment if they asked for that.
  • Close the deposit protection once repaid and keep the confirmation.
  • Send the landlord a statement showing the deductions and the costs paid.

Common check-out failings

  • Check-outs done days after the tenant left, with contractors already in.
  • Photos from different angles or in different light from the check-in.
  • Proposals sent weeks later, by which time the tenant has moved on and is harder to reach.
  • Lump-sum deductions with no breakdown.
  • Claims for wear that the tenancy length makes normal.
  • Repayments delayed past 10 days because of a monthly accounts cycle.

For what makes the starting report strong, read inventories and check-in reports that stand up. If the check-out finds damp or mould, our guide on handling damp and mould reports explains how to diagnose the cause before blaming the tenant.

Frequently asked questions

Does the tenant have to attend the check-out?

No, but it helps. A tenant who attends can see the findings and often agrees on the spot. If they cannot attend, send the report and photos promptly so they have a fair chance to respond.

Can we hold the deposit until the new tenant moves in?

No. The deposit relates to the outgoing tenancy. Once the amount is agreed, it must be returned within 10 days, regardless of the next let.

What if the tenant leaves without returning keys?

Record the missing keys in the check-out report. The reasonable cost of replacing keys or security devices can be claimed where the tenancy agreement provides for it, with a receipt.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Information you must give to your tenants (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo