Lettings compliance

Deposit disputes: evidence that wins adjudication

What deposit scheme adjudicators look for, the evidence each type of claim needs, and how letting agents should present deductions so they hold up.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why most disputes are lost on paper
  2. The four tests behind every deduction
  3. The evidence each claim type needs
  4. Build the bundle in this order
  5. Write each claim as a short statement
  6. Where deductions fall apart
  7. Timing and the tenant conversation
  8. When the landlord wants more than the evidence supports
  9. When the tenant has a point
  10. A monthly self-check for lettings managers
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • The Property Ombudsman decided 61% of its 2025 cases in the consumer's favour, a reminder that weak paperwork rarely wins[1].
  • A disputed deposit stays protected in the scheme until the issue is settled, so the evidence bundle decides the outcome[2].
  • Every deduction needs four things: a tenancy obligation, start condition, end condition and a proportionate cost.
  • Present each item separately, with matching photos and invoices, and remove anything you cannot prove.

Why most disputes are lost on paper

A deposit dispute is not a negotiation that the loudest party wins. It is a file review. The adjudicator from the deposit scheme looks at what each side uploads and decides whether each deduction is justified. The person who did the check-out never gets to explain what they meant. If it is not in the file, it did not happen.

Agents handle most of these files. In 2024, 70% of deposits registered with England's protection schemes were registered by agents on behalf of landlords[3], which means agencies set the evidence standard for most of the market. Treat every deduction as something you have to prove. The deposit is the tenant's money, held as security, until a deduction is agreed or awarded.

The wider complaints picture points the same way. The Property Ombudsman, which handles complaints about agents rather than deposit adjudication, decided 61% of its cases in 2025 in the consumer's favour[1]. Its lettings disputes rose 65% to 3,119 in the same year[1]. Tenants are more willing to challenge, and they win when agencies cannot show their working.

Property Ombudsman decisions in 2025
Property Ombudsman decisions in 2025Stacked bar chart. Decided in the consumer's favour: 61%; Other outcomes: 39%.Decided in the consumer's favour: 61% (61%)Other outcomes: 39% (39%)Property Ombudsman decisions in 2025Stacked bar chart. Decided in the consumer's favour: 61%; Other outcomes: 39%.Decided in the consumer's favour: 61% (61%)Other outcomes: 39% (39%)
  • Decided in the consumer's favour 61%
  • Other outcomes 39%

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Decided in the consumer's favour61%
Other outcomes39%

The four tests behind every deduction

Run each proposed deduction through four questions before it goes anywhere near the landlord or the scheme. If one answer is weak, the deduction is weak.

  1. Was there an obligation?

    Point to the clause in the tenancy agreement that the tenant breached, such as returning the property clean to the standard at check-in, or not making holes in walls without consent.

  2. What was the condition at the start?

    Show the check-in report entry and photo for that exact item, dated and acknowledged by the tenant or sent to them with time to comment.

  3. What was the condition at the end?

    Show the check-out entry and a matching photo from the same angle. A close-up of a stain without a wider shot of the room proves little.

  4. Is the amount fair?

    Show a quote or invoice, and adjust for the age of the item and fair wear and tear. Landlords are not entitled to new for old.

The evidence each claim type needs

Evidence checklist by claim type
ClaimCore evidenceCommon weakness
CleaningCheck-in and check-out photos of the same areas; cleaner's invoice with hoursCheck-in says clean with no photos
DamageMatching before and after photos; repair quote or invoice; item ageNo allowance for age or wear
RedecorationDate of last decoration; photos of marks; proportion of wall affectedCharging a full room for a few marks
GardenCheck-in garden photos by season; tenancy clause on garden careComparing a summer check-in with a winter check-out
Missing itemsInventory listing the item; check-out noting its absence; replacement costItem never listed at check-in
Rent arrearsRent ledger; tenancy agreement rent clause; demand lettersArrears mixed with disputed charges
Utilities or council taxBills showing the period; clause making the tenant liableEstimated bills, no final readings

Cleaning and redecoration claims fail most often because the start position was never photographed properly. If your check-in reports say clean throughout with no supporting images, fix the template before you fix the claims; our guide to inventories and check-in reports that stand up covers the standard.

Build the bundle in this order

Adjudicators read hundreds of files. Make yours easy to follow and they will find what matters.

  1. A one-page summary listing each deduction, the amount and the evidence reference.
  2. The signed tenancy agreement, with the relevant clauses highlighted or listed by number.
  3. The check-in report and the tenant's acknowledgement or comments.
  4. The check-out report, with photos cross-referenced to the check-in.
  5. Quotes, invoices or receipts for each cost claimed.
  6. Correspondence where the tenant was told about the proposed deductions and given a chance to respond.
  7. For arrears, the rent ledger.

Label every photo with the room and item, and use the same labels across check-in and check-out. A file called IMG_4471 helps nobody.

Write each claim as a short statement

Keep the claim statement factual and item by item. Avoid adjectives such as filthy or disgusting; they signal emotion, not evidence.

Example: Item 3, living room carpet. Clause 12 requires the tenant to return the property in the same condition, allowing for fair wear and tear. Check-in report page 4, photo 4.2: carpet clean, no marks, fitted two years before the tenancy. Check-out report page 4, photo 4.2b: red wine stain approximately 30 cm across by the sofa. Professional cleaning quote attached for £85, which the specialist says should remove the stain. No replacement claimed.

That statement passes all four tests, asks for cleaning rather than replacement, and makes it easy for the adjudicator to agree. Compare it with a claim for a new carpet because of a stain; the adjudicator would likely reduce it to a cleaning cost anyway, and your credibility on the other items would fall with it.

Where deductions fall apart

  • Claims for items that were already worn, with no allowance for age.
  • Before and after photos taken from different angles or in different light.
  • Check-out reports done weeks after the tenant left, when contractors had already been in.
  • Cleaning charges where the check-in standard was never recorded.
  • Admin fees for handling the dispute; these are not a permitted payment under the Tenant Fees Act[4].
  • Deductions bundled into one lump sum with no breakdown.
  • Correspondence that shows the landlord deciding the figure before the check-out.

Timing and the tenant conversation

Most disputes are avoidable. Send the tenant a clear, itemised proposal with photos as soon as the check-out report is ready, and invite a response within a short, fair period. When both sides agree, the deposit must be returned within 10 days of agreement[2], so prepare the repayment while you wait. If they disagree, the disputed amount stays protected in the scheme until the issue is settled[2], and the undisputed part can be released.

The tenant should already know how this works, because the prescribed information at the start of the tenancy explains what to do if there is a dispute over the amount to be returned[5]. Refer back to it in your proposal. Tenants who feel informed are far less likely to escalate than tenants who feel ambushed.

When the landlord wants more than the evidence supports

The hardest disputes are often with your own client. A landlord who sees a worn kitchen at the end of a five-year tenancy may expect the deposit to pay for a refit. Your job is to explain, early and in writing, what the evidence will support and what an adjudicator is likely to award. Agents who push weak claims to keep a landlord happy end up with the landlord unhappy anyway, plus a tenant complaint.

  • Share the four tests with landlords at instruction, so the standard is no surprise.
  • Give a written view on each proposed deduction before it goes to the tenant.
  • Where a landlord insists on a claim you think is weak, record your advice and their instruction.
  • Offer the landlord the option of settling at a fair figure rather than risking a lower award.

Example: a landlord wants £1,200 to repaint a three-bedroom house after a four-year tenancy. The check-out shows scuffs in the hall and picture hook holes in two bedrooms. The agency advises that the decoration was already four years old, proposes £180 for filling and touching up the affected walls, and the tenant agrees within a week. The deposit is released inside the 10-day window and nobody goes to adjudication.

When the tenant has a point

Some disputes should not be fought. If the check-in report is thin, the check-out was late, or the item was old, the evidence will not carry the claim and the honest course is to say so. Concede early, release the undisputed balance, and fix the process for the next tenancy. A quick concession on a weak item also makes your stronger items more credible if the rest does go to adjudication.

A monthly self-check for lettings managers

Pick three recent check-outs each month and score them against the four tests. Where any item fails, ask why. Usually the cause is upstream: a thin check-in report, a late check-out, or a landlord pushing for a figure. Fixing those habits wins more disputes than any argument written at the end. For the deduction maths itself, see fair wear and tear: realistic deposit deductions and check-out inspections and deposit returns.

Frequently asked questions

Can the landlord deduct the cost of our time dealing with the dispute?

No. Agency or landlord time spent managing a dispute is not a permitted charge and should not appear in a deduction claim. Claim only actual losses such as cleaning, repairs or unpaid rent.

Are video walk-throughs better than photos?

They help, especially for showing the overall condition of a room, but adjudicators still need clear stills of specific items. Use both: a time-stamped video for context and labelled photos for each item you may claim against.

What if the tenant never signed the check-in report?

The report can still carry weight if you can show it was sent to the tenant promptly with a fair chance to comment. Keep the email and any reply. A report the tenant never saw is much weaker.

References

  1. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Private Landlord Survey 2024: main report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Information you must give to your tenants (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo