Metrics finance

The cost of a lost lead: modelling enquiry value

Turn your conversion rates and average fees into a value for each valuation, landlord, buyer and tenant enquiry, then measure how many your agency loses.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why put a number on an enquiry?
  2. The formula
  3. Worked examples
  4. Where enquiries are lost
  5. Measuring how many you lose
  6. A call-handling standard for the branch
  7. What portal changes mean for lead value
  8. Using the number to make decisions
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Value each enquiry type separately: a valuation request, a landlord enquiry, a buyer and a tenant are worth very different amounts.
  • Enquiry value equals the chance it converts at each stage multiplied by the fee, plus any recurring income it brings.
  • Buyers far outnumber new listings: Propertymark branches registered 69 new buyers but placed only 10.8 homes on the market each in August 2026[1][2].
  • Losses happen at contact: unanswered calls, slow replies and no follow-up. Poor or delayed communication tops lettings dispute issues[3].
  • Use the value to decide what cover, staffing or tools are worth paying for, not to guess.

Why put a number on an enquiry?

Every agency loses some enquiries: a call that rings out during a valuation, an email answered the next afternoon, a portal lead nobody followed up. Most owners know this happens but not what it costs, so decisions about lunchtime cover, weekend opening or a second negotiator are made on instinct. Putting a value on each type of enquiry turns those decisions into arithmetic.

The supply of enquiries is uneven. In August 2026, each Propertymark member branch registered an average of 69 new prospective buyers[1] but placed only around 10.8 homes on the market[2]. Letting branches averaged 121 new tenant registrations each[4]. Buyers and tenants are plentiful; sellers and landlords are scarce, and their enquiries are where most of the value sits.

New buyers vs new listings per Propertymark branch, August 2026Seller enquiries are the scarce resource
New buyers vs new listings per Propertymark branch, August 2026Comparison. New prospective buyers registered: 69 per branch; Homes placed on the market: 10.8 per branch.69 per branchNew prospective buyers registeredNew prospective buyers registered: 69 per branch10.8 per branchHomes placed on the marketHomes placed on the market: 10.8 per branchNew buyers vs new listings per Propertymark branch, August 2026Comparison. New prospective buyers registered: 69 per branch; Homes placed on the market: 10.8 per branch.69 per branchNew prospective buyers registeredNew prospective buyers registered: 69 per branch10.8 per branchHomes placed on the marketHomes placed on the market: 10.8 per branch

Source: Propertymark, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
New prospective buyers registered69 per branch
Homes placed on the market10.8 per branch

The formula

The value of an enquiry is what it would be expected to earn if handled well. Multiply the probability of each step by the fee at the end, and add any income that continues after the first transaction.

  1. Chance the enquiry books an appointment

    For a valuation request, the share that become attended appraisals. For a landlord, the share who book a lettings valuation.

  2. Chance the appointment becomes an instruction

    Your valuation-to-instruction rate, by lead source.

  3. Chance the instruction produces a fee

    For sales, your completion rate per instruction. For lettings, the share of instructions that let.

  4. Average fee

    Your actual average net fee per completion or per let, after discounts.

  5. Recurring value

    For managed lettings, add the expected management income over the average time a landlord stays with you, less the cost of serving them.

Measure each input from 12 months of your own data, by branch.
Enquiry typeMain value routeInputs to measure
Sales valuation requestInstruction and completion feeBooking rate, instruction rate, completion rate, average fee
Landlord enquiryLet fee plus management income over timeBooking rate, instruction rate, managed share, retention, annual management income
Buyer enquiryViewings and sale agreed on your stock; possible seller of their own homeShare who are also sellers, share who book a valuation
Tenant enquiryLet on your stock; occasional future buyer or landlordViewing to application rate

Worked examples

Example, sales valuation request: 70% book an appraisal, 40% of appraisals instruct, 65% of instructions complete, and the average net fee is £3,600. Value per request: 0.70 × 0.40 × 0.65 × £3,600 = about £655. A branch that misses five such calls a month is losing about £3,300 of expected fee income each month.

Example, landlord enquiry: 60% book a valuation, 50% instruct, 80% of instructions let, the let fee is £900 and 40% of new landlords take management worth £1,100 a year for an average of four years, with service costs of half that income. Value: 0.60 × 0.50 × 0.80 × (£900 + 0.40 × £2,200) = about £427 per enquiry, roughly half of it from the management that follows.

Buyer enquiries are lower value one by one, because about ten applicants compete for each available rental[5] and many buyers chase each sales listing. Their hidden value is that some are sellers too. Ask every buyer whether they have a home to sell, and count the valuations that result. That share, multiplied by the value of a valuation request, is the real value of a buyer enquiry to the branch.

Where enquiries are lost

  • Calls that ring out while the team is on viewings, at lunch or after closing time.
  • Portal and website leads answered hours later, after a competitor has already called.
  • Voicemails that are never returned or returned without the right information.
  • Valuation requests booked without a confirmation and reminder, leading to no-shows.
  • Landlord enquiries passed between sales and lettings teams with no owner.
  • Buyers never asked whether they have a property to sell.

Communication failures also cost goodwill with existing clients. Poor, unclear or delayed communication across all stages was listed first among the top issues in Property Ombudsman lettings disputes in 2025[3], and the government says that even once a sale progresses, consumers often face months without updates[6].

Measuring how many you lose

  1. Pull a month of call data from your phone system: calls received, answered, missed and abandoned, by hour of the day and day of the week.
  2. Check how many missed callers were called back, and how quickly.
  3. Sample 30 portal and website leads and time the first response.
  4. Ask every new instruction which other agents they contacted and who replied first.
  5. Classify missed enquiries by type where you can, using caller numbers matched to the CRM.

Multiply the missed enquiries of each type by its value. The result will be an estimate, but a far better one than guessing. It also shows when losses happen: most agencies find a cluster at lunchtime, in the early evening and on weekends, when staffing is thinnest. Estate agents typically work 35 to 40 hours a week and may work weekends on a rota[7], so cover is always stretched somewhere.

A call-handling standard for the branch

Once you know what each enquiry is worth, write down how the branch will handle them. A short standard, agreed with the team and checked monthly, recovers more lost enquiries than any single piece of technology, because it removes the ambiguity about who answers and when.

  • Every call answered or returned within a set time during opening hours, with a named person responsible for missed calls each day.
  • Portal and website leads acknowledged within a set time, with a real reply rather than an automatic one.
  • Valuation requests confirmed in writing the same day, with a reminder the day before the appointment.
  • Every buyer and tenant asked whether they have a property to sell or let, and the answer recorded.
  • Landlord enquiries passed to a named lettings contact, never left in a shared inbox.

Script for a missed-call return: 'Hello, it's Jordan from the branch, returning your call from earlier. I'm sorry we missed you; we were out on viewings. Were you calling about selling, letting or a property you've seen? ... Thank you. I can book a valuation for Thursday at 10 or Friday at 2, and I'll send a confirmation straight after this call.'

Check the standard against real data each month: missed call rate by hour, call-back times and lead response times. Share the results with the team in the same meeting where you review instructions, so the link between answering quickly and winning stock is visible.

What portal changes mean for lead value

Portals are changing how owners and movers make contact. Rightmove says its online agent valuation tool supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to agents in the first half of 2026[8], and early results from its conversational search showed close to double the propensity to send leads[9]. More leads arriving does not mean more value arriving: online valuation leads often convert at a lower rate than referrals or previous clients. Calculate the value of portal leads separately from other sources, and update it as the mix changes, so that a rise in volume does not hide a fall in value per lead.

Using the number to make decisions

With a value per enquiry and a count of missed enquiries, any proposal to reduce losses can be tested. Compare the cost of the change with the value it would recover, using cautious assumptions. Options include a lunchtime rota, a call-back rule with a time limit, an out-of-hours answering service, or Ava answering when the team cannot and booking valuations into the calendar with a summary for the negotiator.

Example: a branch misses 12 valuation calls and 8 landlord calls a month outside staffed hours. Using the values above, that is about 12 × £655 + 8 × £427, roughly £11,300 of expected income a month. If a cover option recovers even a third of those enquiries, it is worth up to about £3,800 a month before its own cost.

Review the values twice a year as conversion rates and fees change, and keep the method the same. The figures feed directly into market share planning, speed to lead targets and stock levels forecasts.

Frequently asked questions

How do I calculate the value of an estate agency lead?

Multiply the chance the enquiry books an appointment, the chance that becomes an instruction and the chance the instruction produces a fee by your average fee. For landlords, add expected management income over the time they stay, less service costs.

Which enquiries are worth most to an estate agent?

Seller valuation requests and landlord enquiries, because they are scarcer and lead to fees. Buyer and tenant enquiries are more numerous; their value comes partly from the share who also have a home to sell or let.

How do I find out how many leads we miss?

Use your phone system's missed and abandoned call data by hour, check call-back times, time responses to a sample of portal leads and ask new clients which agents they contacted first.

References

  1. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. National Careers Service (GOV.UK) (2026). Estate agent job profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo