Key takeaways
- Measure the rate by cohort: instructions won from appraisals attended in a given month, counted after a fixed decision window.
- No UK body publishes a reliable national benchmark, so build your own from 12 months of branch data, split by lead source.
- Portal valuation tools are sending more leads, with Rightmove reporting a c.50% rise in unique valuation leads[1], so lead quality now varies more than it used to.
- Compare valuers only on similar lead mixes and check their asking-price accuracy alongside conversion, or you will reward overvaluing.
- Most leakage happens after the appointment: slow proposals and no structured follow-up.
What the rate tells you, and why it matters now
Your valuation-to-instruction rate is the share of market appraisals that turn into a signed instruction. It is the clearest single measure of how well a branch wins stock, and stock is what every later fee depends on. A branch that books plenty of appraisals but converts few of them has a valuer, pricing or follow-up problem, not a marketing problem.
The market makes this number harder to ignore. RICS contributors report that the number of market appraisals is still below the level of twelve months earlier[2], even though a small net balance of surveyors, +6%, reported more new sales instructions in September 2026[3]. Each Propertymark member branch placed around 10.8 homes on the market in August 2026[4]. With appraisal volumes this tight, a few points of conversion is the difference between a full board and a thin one.
At the same time, more leads are arriving through portal tools. Rightmove says its online agent valuation tool supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to agents in the first half of 2026[1]. Some of those owners are ready to sell; many are simply curious. If you count every online valuation request as an appraisal, your rate will fall even when your valuers are doing nothing differently.
Source: Rightmove plc, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| H1 2025 | 100 |
| H1 2026 | 150 |
The formula, done properly
Most agency software can produce a ratio, but the default report often divides this month's instructions by this month's appraisals. That mixes different groups of sellers and swings wildly from month to month. Use a cohort method instead.
Define what counts as an appraisal
Count only valuations where a valuer attended the property, in person or by a structured video walk-through. Log online estimates and desktop requests as leads, not appraisals.
Group by appraisal date
Put every attended appraisal into the month it took place. That month is its cohort.
Set a decision window
Count an instruction against the cohort if it is signed within 60 days of the appraisal. Sellers who instruct later are still worth tracking, but report them separately as late wins.
Record the outcome for every appraisal
Use four outcomes only: instructed with us, instructed with a rival, not yet decided, and not proceeding. Unknown is not an outcome; chase it.
Calculate and split
Instructed with us divided by attended appraisals in the cohort gives the rate. Split it by valuer, by lead source and by sales versus lettings.
Example: a branch attends 42 appraisals in September. By the end of November, 17 have instructed with the branch, 9 went to a rival, 6 are undecided and 10 are not proceeding. The September cohort rate is 17 out of 42, about 40%. The rate against decided sellers only (17 out of 26) shows how the branch performs when the owner actually chooses an agent.
Benchmarks: build your own instead of borrowing one
You will see headline conversion figures quoted at conferences and in supplier marketing, but none come from a published, consistent national survey, and definitions differ. A figure that counts online requests as appraisals cannot be compared with one that counts only attended visits. The reliable benchmark is your own history.
Pull 12 months of attended appraisals and outcomes. Work out the median rate for the branch and the range covered by the middle half of months. That range is your normal band. A month outside it is worth investigating; a month inside it is noise. Repeat the exercise for each lead source, because the gaps between sources are usually larger than the gaps between valuers.
| Lead source | What usually drives conversion | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| Previous client or referral | Existing trust and a warm introduction | Whether the valuer reached them quickly and referenced the relationship |
| Portal online valuation request | Speed of first contact and how ready the owner is to move | How many were booked as attended appraisals, and how fast |
| Board or local marketing | Visible local stock and recent sales nearby | Whether the proposal showed comparable sold evidence |
| Lettings landlord switching agent | Service failings with the current agent | Whether the proposal addressed the specific complaint |
| Probate or executor enquiry | Patience and clear explanation of process | Whether follow-up allowed for the legal timetable |
Comparing valuers fairly
Ranking valuers on raw conversion encourages the wrong behaviour. The quickest way to win an instruction is to suggest a higher asking price than a rival, and the market currently punishes that: in August 2026, 86% of Propertymark member agents reported properties selling for less than the asking price[5]. A valuer who wins on price and then needs two reductions has not helped the branch.
- Compare valuers only within the same lead source mix, or weight their results by source.
- Set a minimum sample, such as 20 attended appraisals in the period, before discussing anyone's rate.
- Show each valuer's conversion next to their asking price achieved and their share of listings reduced within eight weeks.
- Look at the reasons for losses that went to rivals: fee, price, marketing or relationship. Each needs a different fix.
- Review lettings valuations separately, because a landlord comparing management services decides differently from a seller.
Pair this report with asking price achieved and the instruction-to-sale rate. Together the three numbers show whether a valuer wins good instructions, not just many.
Where appraisals leak, stage by stage
- Request to booked appointment: leads left unanswered overnight or at weekends often book with whoever replies first.
- Booked to attended: no-shows and cancellations rise when there is no reminder the day before.
- Attended to proposal sent: a written proposal that arrives three days later loses momentum. Aim for the same or next working day.
- Proposal to decision: without a planned follow-up call, undecided sellers drift towards the agent who keeps in touch.
- Decision to signed terms: delays in AML checks or terms of business can lose a seller who has already said yes.
Measure the drop-off at each stage for one quarter. Most branches find the largest loss between proposal and decision, which is also the cheapest stage to fix. Where the first gap is the problem, Ava can answer valuation calls out of hours and book the appointment into your calendar, while the valuer handles the valuation itself.
A follow-up call that does not pressure the seller
The follow-up call is where many valuers either push too hard or say nothing useful. A short, structured call works better and is easy to coach.
Script: 'Hello, it's Sam from the branch. I'm calling about the valuation on Tuesday. Did the proposal arrive and was anything unclear? You mentioned you were speaking to two other agents. When you compare us, the things worth checking are the evidence behind each asking price, how often each agent will update you, and the notice period in the terms. Would it help if I sent the three sold comparables again with the floor areas?'
Log the outcome of the call with a date for the next contact. If the seller has chosen a rival, ask once, politely, what made the difference, and record the answer under fee, price, marketing or relationship.
What to put in the monthly report
Owners need one page, not a spreadsheet dump. Keep the report the same every month so changes stand out, and show the cohort that has just closed its decision window rather than the current month, which will always look weak because many sellers have not decided yet.
- Attended appraisals for the closed cohort, sales and lettings separately.
- Instructed with us, instructed with a rival, not proceeding and still undecided, as counts and as shares.
- The branch rate against its normal band, with a short note if it falls outside.
- Each valuer's rate, sample size and asking price achieved on the same row.
- The top three loss reasons recorded from follow-up calls, with the action agreed for each.
- Late wins from older cohorts, so effort on long follow-up is visible.
Agree one action per month and name an owner for it. A report that produces no decision is a habit, not a management tool.
Reading the rate through the seasons
Sellers with flexible timing tend to come to market in the autumn, when there are typically more active buyers than in the slower summer season[6]. Appraisals booked in September and October often include more serious sellers, so conversion can rise without any change in your process. Compare each cohort with the same month last year rather than the month before.
Review the rate monthly in the estate agency KPI pack, act on the stage with the largest drop, and recheck the same stage after one full cohort has passed its decision window.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good valuation-to-instruction rate for an estate agent?
There is no reliable published national benchmark because agents define appraisals differently. Use the median of your own last 12 monthly cohorts, split by lead source, as your baseline and investigate months outside your normal range.
Should online valuation requests count as appraisals?
No. Log them as leads and count an appraisal only when a valuer has attended or done a structured video valuation. Otherwise a rise in online requests will make your conversion look worse with no change in performance.
How long should I wait before counting an appraisal as lost?
A 60-day decision window suits most sales appraisals. Track later wins separately so they are not lost from the record, and chase every appraisal still marked undecided.
Why might a valuer with a high conversion rate be a problem?
High conversion bought with optimistic asking prices often leads to reductions and slow sales. Review conversion alongside asking price achieved and the share of listings reduced.
References
Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Rightmove (2026). House Price Index, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑