Valuations instructions

Estate agent fees: setting a fee you can defend

Percentage, fixed and tiered estate agent fee models compared, how to work out a minimum fee from your costs, and how to quote fees correctly with VAT.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. A fee you can defend
  2. The main fee models
  3. How to quote the fee
  4. The same percentage earns different fees
  5. Build your minimum fee from costs
  6. Example: one branch's floor
  7. Failed sales are a cost
  8. Portals are a fixed cost
  9. The real price of a small discount
  10. What sellers actually compare
  11. When the fee is paid
  12. Link the fee to service levels
  13. Set fees independently
  14. Review the fee every year
  15. Frequently asked questions
  16. References

Key takeaways

  • A defensible fee starts from your cost per completed sale, not from what the agent down the road charges.
  • Quote fees including VAT, with an example at the asking price for percentage fees[1]; the standard VAT rate is 20%[2].
  • The same percentage earns very different amounts across the country, because average prices differ so much[3].
  • Failed sales and portal spend both sit in your costs, so price them in.
  • Link the fee to clear service levels, so a seller can see what a higher fee buys.

A fee you can defend

A fee is defensible when you can explain, in a sentence, what it pays for and why it is the right level for this home. Sellers push back on fees that look arbitrary. They are far more likely to accept a fee that is clearly linked to a service they value and set at a level the agent can justify from its own costs.

Most agencies set fees by looking at competitors and adjusting. That tells you what the market will bear, but not whether the fee covers the work. Start from your own numbers, then compare with the market.

The main fee models

Common estate agency fee models
ModelHow it worksStrengthWeakness
Percentage of sale priceA set percentage, due on exchange or completionRises with the price; aligns agent with a higher saleHard for sellers of expensive homes to accept
Fixed feeA set amount regardless of priceEasy to understand and compareSame reward whatever the effort or result
Tiered percentageA lower rate on the first band, higher on the amount above a targetRewards achieving more than the targetHarder to explain; needs a clear example
Fixed plus success elementA smaller fixed fee and a percentage above a figureShares riskCan look complicated beside simpler offers

How to quote the fee

The Property Ombudsman's code requires fees to be shown including VAT alongside a statement that VAT is included[1]. A percentage fee must be quoted including VAT, with an example based on the asking price, and the terms must say the fee will be higher or lower if the sale price is[1]. A fixed fee must be stated as the actual amount including VAT[1]. Most services carry the standard VAT rate of 20%[2], so a fee of 1% plus VAT is 1.2% including VAT.

Quote it the same way everywhere: the proposal, the terms, the website and the conversation at the kitchen table. For example, a seller who hears '1%' at the valuation and reads '1.2% including VAT' in the terms will feel misled, even though both are correct.

The same percentage earns different fees

Average house prices in the 12 months to August 2026 were £294,000 in England, £216,000 in Wales and £198,000 in Scotland[3]. At the same percentage, a branch selling average homes in England earns roughly half as much again per sale as one in Scotland. Branch costs do not fall in the same proportion, which is why fee levels vary so widely by area.

Average house price by nation, 12 months to August 2026ONS house price statistics
Average house price by nation, 12 months to August 2026Column chart. England: £294,000; Wales: £216,000; Scotland: £198,000.£0£100,000£200,000£300,000England: £294,000£294,000EnglandWales: £216,000£216,000WalesScotland: £198,000£198,000ScotlandAverage house price by nation, 12 months to August 2026Column chart. England: £294,000; Wales: £216,000; Scotland: £198,000.£0£100,000£200,000£300,000England: £294,000£294,000EnglandWales: £216,000£216,000WalesScotland: £198,000£198,000Scotland

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
England£294,000
Wales£216,000
Scotland£198,000

Build your minimum fee from costs

  1. Total the branch's monthly costs

    Salaries and employer costs, rent, portal and marketing, software, insurance, compliance and a share of head office costs.

  2. Count completions, not sales agreed

    Use the average monthly completions over the last year. Agreed sales that fall through earn nothing.

  3. Work out cost per completion

    Divide monthly costs by monthly completions. This is the amount each completed sale must earn just to break even.

  4. Add a target margin

    Decide the profit you need per completion to invest, cover bad months and reward the team.

  5. Turn it into a fee

    Divide the target per completion by your average sale price to get the minimum percentage, or use it directly as a fixed fee floor.

Example: one branch's floor

Example: a branch has monthly costs of 48,000 pounds and completes an average of 12 sales a month, so each completion costs 4,000 pounds to deliver. With a target margin of 1,500 pounds per completion, the branch needs 5,500 pounds per sale before VAT. At an average sale price of 300,000 pounds, that is about 1.8% plus VAT. If the manager wants to compete at a lower rate, the arithmetic shows what must change: more completions, lower costs or a lower margin.

Example: the same branch now compares its floor with local competitors. If most charge less, it has to show a service difference that justifies the gap, or find ways to raise completions per negotiator.

Failed sales are a cost

The government estimates that around one in three property transactions fail[4]. A sale that falls through after months of work earns no fee on a standard agreement, yet the viewings, negotiation and chasing have all been paid for. Your cost per completion already includes those failures if you divide by completions rather than sales agreed. Many branches forget this and set fees on agreed sales, which overstates their income.

For context, Propertymark member branches agreed an average of 9.5 sales each in August 2026[5]. Your own ratio of completions to agreed sales is one of the most important numbers in setting a fee.

Portals are a fixed cost

Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in the first half of 2026, up 8% on a year earlier[6]. Add other portals, your website and social advertising, and marketing becomes one of the largest lines after salaries. It does not fall when the market slows, so a branch with fewer completions carries a higher marketing cost per sale.

The real price of a small discount

Discounts look small as percentages and large as pounds. At the UK average house price of £273,000 in the year to August 2026[3], every 0.1% off the fee is £273 before VAT. A negotiator who routinely drops 0.25% to win instructions gives away several hundred pounds per sale, and across a year of completions that can be more than the margin the branch planned to make.

Before agreeing any reduction, know what it does to your cost-per-completion sum. If the discounted fee no longer covers the cost of delivering the sale, the instruction is a loss even when it completes.

What sellers actually compare

Sellers rarely compare fees in isolation. They weigh the fee against the agent's figure, the agreement terms, the confidence they feel in the negotiator and what friends have said. A seller who trusts that one agent will get the sale over the line will usually pay more for that certainty. Your job is to make the comparison easy: one clear fee including VAT, the service it buys and the terms that apply, set out the same way in every proposal.

  • Is the fee shown including VAT, with an example at their asking price?
  • What happens to the fee if the sale falls through?
  • How long is the minimum term, and what does it cost to leave?
  • What does the seller get that a cheaper agent does not offer?

When the fee is paid

The redress code says that, except for previously agreed additional costs, commission becomes due on exchange of contracts[1]. In practice, many agents send the invoice to the seller's solicitor ahead of exchange so it can be settled from the sale proceeds at completion. State in the terms exactly when the fee is due and how it will be collected, so the seller is not surprised by a demand at the busiest moment of their move.

  • Core service: valuation, photography, floor plan, portal listing, accompanied viewings on request and sales progression.
  • Enhanced service: all viewings accompanied, video tour, premium portal placement, weekly written reports and a named progressor.
  • Specialist service: for listed, rural or high-value homes, with extended marketing, specialist photography and longer viewing slots.

Show the tiers side by side with the fee for each. Sellers who can see what the extra pays for often choose the middle tier; sellers who see a single fee with no context tend to argue about it.

Set fees independently

The redress code says agents must take decisions on how they advertise fees, charges and offers independently of competitors[1]. Agreeing fee levels with other agents, even informally at a local networking event, can breach competition law. Watch the market, but set your fee from your own costs and service.

Review the fee every year

  • Recalculate cost per completion with the latest costs and completion numbers.
  • Check what share of sellers negotiated the fee down, and by how much.
  • Compare fees achieved by negotiator, to spot who discounts most.
  • Review whether each service tier is still delivered as described.

Frequently asked questions

What is a typical estate agent fee?

Fees vary widely by area, home and service level. The best way to set yours is to work out your cost per completed sale and add a margin, then compare with local agents.

Should estate agent fees include VAT?

Yes. The redress code requires fees to be quoted including VAT, with a statement that VAT is included.

Is a fixed fee better than a percentage?

Neither is better in all cases. Fixed fees are easy to compare; percentages rise with the price. Choose the model that matches your service and costs.

How can I justify a higher fee than competitors?

Link it to specific service levels the seller can see, and show your results, such as completion rates and time to sale.

References

  1. The Property Ombudsman (2026). Code of Practice for Residential Estate Agents (TPOE27-9, March 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). VAT rates (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Private rent and house prices, UK: October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo