Key takeaways
- Fee pushback is usually about trust or value, not the number, so find out which before you answer.
- Decide your walk-away fee before the valuation, never in the room.
- Trade, do not give: if the fee moves, something else moves too, such as the service tier or the success element.
- Show the seller that your negotiation on the sale price is worth more than a small fee discount; most homes are selling below asking[1].
- Practise the lines as a team, so nobody discounts by reflex.
Why sellers push back
Most sellers ask for a lower fee. Some are testing you, some have a lower quote in hand, and some simply feel uneasy about paying a large sum to a profession they do not fully trust. Only 37% of people said they trust estate agents in the Ipsos index cited by the government[2]. When trust is low, every fee looks too high.
- Trust estate agents 37%
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Trust estate agents | 37% |
That means the fee conversation is rarely just about the fee. If you answer a trust problem with a discount, the seller is no more confident in you and now thinks your first figure was padded. Answer the real concern first.
It also helps to remember when the question is asked. A seller who raises the fee at the very end of the visit, after agreeing with your figure and plan, is usually close to instructing you and wants reassurance. A seller who opens with the fee before you have looked round is shopping on price, and needs to see the service before any number will make sense.
Before the valuation: know your walk-away
- Your standard fee for this type of home, including VAT, and the service it buys.
- The lowest fee you will accept, worked out from your cost per completed sale.
- The trades you are willing to offer, in order of preference.
- Whether you want this instruction enough to accept the floor, given the price evidence and the seller's motivation.
Write these down before you go. Negotiators who decide their floor in the room almost always end up below it.
Principles for the conversation
- Never raise the possibility of a discount yourself. Wait to be asked, and then ask a question back.
- Find out what is behind the request: another quote, a budget problem or doubt about value.
- Restate what the fee includes before discussing any change to it.
- If the fee moves, something else moves too. A discount with nothing in return teaches the seller to keep asking.
- Put any agreed change in writing the same day, in a revised proposal or terms.
Objection-handling lines
| Objection | What is often behind it | A line to use |
|---|---|---|
| 'The other agent is cheaper' | Comparing a number, not a service | 'Can I see what they include? Let's compare like for like.' |
| 'It's a lot of money' | Budget pressure on the move | 'It is. It's only paid if you exchange, and here's what you get for it.' |
| 'You don't do much for it' | Doubt about the agent's effort | 'Let me walk you through what happens between now and completion.' |
| 'Online agents charge far less' | Wondering if a local agent is worth it | 'They can be right for some sellers. Here's where we make a difference.' |
| 'Knock it down and you've got it' | Testing to see if you will fold | 'I'd rather keep the fee and earn it. What would make you confident?' |
Trade-offs instead of a discount
- Move down a service tier at a lower fee, so the seller chooses what to give up.
- Offer a lower base fee with a success element above an agreed sale figure.
- Shorten the minimum term or remove any withdrawal charge, reducing the seller's risk instead of your income.
- Offer a fixed fee where the seller's main worry is the size of a percentage on a high price.
- Agree a lower fee in exchange for a sole agency rather than multi-agency instruction.
Each trade keeps the value of the instruction in balance. The seller gets something they want, and you keep a fee you can defend.
The price argument
The fee is a small part of the money at stake. In August 2026, 86% of Propertymark member agents reported homes selling for less than asking and only 9% at asking[1]. How well an agent negotiates the sale price, and how well it holds a buyer through to exchange, can easily outweigh a small difference in fee.
Example: on a 400,000 pound sale, a fee discount of 0.25% saves the seller 1,000 pounds before VAT. A negotiator who secures 1% more on the price adds 4,000 pounds to the seller's proceeds. Present the comparison carefully: you cannot promise a higher price, but you can show how you negotiate and what your recent sales achieved against asking.
Service the seller can see
The government notes that consumers often face months without updates once a sale progresses[3], and poor or delayed communication was the first issue listed in Property Ombudsman lettings disputes in 2025[4]. Sellers have heard that agents disappear after the board goes up. If your fee includes weekly updates, a named progressor and active chasing of the chain, say so specifically. A promise of contact the seller can hold you to is more persuasive than a general claim about service.
When to say no
- The discounted fee would fall below your cost per completion.
- The seller insists on a figure the evidence does not support as well as a lower fee.
- The seller wants multi-agency and the lowest fee on the street.
- Agreeing would mean breaking your own fee policy for one seller while others pay the standard fee.
Walking away politely can be the right result. Some sellers return when the cheaper option has not worked.
When the question comes before the valuation
Many sellers ring the branch and ask 'what's your fee?' before booking a visit. A bare number on the phone invites comparison on price alone, but refusing to answer sounds evasive. Give the honest answer in context: 'For a home like yours our fee is usually in this range including VAT, depending on the service you choose. The best way to see what's included is a valuation, and there's no obligation.' Then book the appointment. Whoever answers the phone should know the range and the wording, so the branch gives the same answer every time.
Fee conversations with landlords
Landlords negotiate lettings fees just as hard, often by comparing a percentage of rent without looking at what each service level includes. The same principles apply. Ask what the landlord most wants to avoid: void weeks, late rent, compliance mistakes or calls about repairs. Then show how the fee covers that risk. A landlord who sees the fee as the cost of not having to deal with a 2am leak or a missed safety certificate is much less likely to push for a discount than one shown a price list.
Signs the branch is discounting too often
- The average fee achieved is well below the standard fee in your proposals.
- Discounts cluster with one or two negotiators.
- Sellers mention that a friend got a lower fee from you.
- Instructions won at a discount withdraw or fail more often than others.
- Nobody can say what was traded for each discount.
If two or more of these sound familiar, review the walk-away figures and the trades as a team, and agree that any discount below the standard needs a manager's approval.
Holding the fee: a script
Script, with example figures: 'I understand, and I'd ask the same in your position. Our fee is 1.5% plus VAT, which is 1.8% including VAT, and it's only due if you exchange. It covers accompanied viewings, weekly updates and a named person chasing your sale every week until completion. I'd rather not cut it, because that's what pays for the chasing. What I can do is take off the withdrawal charge and shorten the minimum term to eight weeks, so if we're not delivering, you can leave.'
The figures in the script are an example. The structure is what matters: acknowledge, restate the fee including VAT, link it to specific service, explain why it matters, then offer a trade that reduces the seller's risk.
A team drill
Prepare
Write the five most common objections your branch hears on cards.
Pair up
One negotiator plays the seller, one the agent. Swap after each card.
Score
A third person notes whether the agent asked a question before answering and whether any change came with a trade.
Review
Share the best lines and add them to the branch's valuation pack.
Record what was agreed
Whatever the outcome, write it down. Note the standard fee you quoted, any change, the trade that came with it and the reason. Send the seller revised terms that state the fee including VAT[5]. Over a few months, the records show who discounts most, which objections come up and which lines work. That turns fee negotiation from a personal habit into a branch skill.
Frequently asked questions
Should I offer a discount to win an instruction?
Not by reflex. Find out what is behind the request, restate the value, and if the fee moves, ask for something in return.
How do I respond when a seller says another agent is cheaper?
Ask what the other fee includes and compare like for like: service, terms and results, not just the number.
What can I offer instead of a lower fee?
A different service tier, a success-based element, a shorter minimum term or no withdrawal charge.
When should I walk away?
When the fee would fall below your cost per completed sale, or the seller wants both an unsupported figure and a lower fee.
References
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Property Ombudsman (2026). Code of Practice for Residential Estate Agents (TPOE27-9, March 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑