Property management

Landlord insurance claims: the agent's role

A managing agent's role in a landlord insurance claim: notification, evidence, contractors, loss adjusters, tenant updates and where the role stops.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Where the agent fits in a claim
  2. The claims workflow
  3. Evidence that insurers ask for
  4. Common claim types and the agent's checklist
  5. Deposit, insurance or tenant: who pays
  6. Keeping the tenant on side
  7. Loss of rent and alternative accommodation
  8. When a claim is declined
  9. Money, fees and conflicts
  10. Example: a ceiling collapse in a managed flat
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Only 18% of landlords in England used agent management services in 2024, so managed landlords expect claims handling as part of the service[1].
  • The agent's value is evidence: dated photos, contractor reports, inspection records and a clear timeline from the first call.
  • Keep insurer payments in client money and account for them like rent; agents holding client money must belong to a protection scheme[2].
  • Agents handle claims as the landlord's representative; advising on or arranging cover is a separate, regulated activity.

Where the agent fits in a claim

In 2024, 43% of landlords in England used agent letting services but only 18% used agent management services[1]. Landlords who pay for management usually expect the agent to handle an insurance claim end to end: report it, gather evidence, organise contractors and keep the tenant informed. The policy, though, belongs to the landlord, and so do the decisions on whether to claim and what to accept.

Landlords in England using agent services, 2024
Landlords in England using agent services, 2024Bar chart. Agent letting services: 43%; Agent management services: 18%.Agent letting servicesAgent letting services: 43%43%Agent management servicesAgent management services: 18%18%Landlords in England using agent services, 2024Bar chart. Agent letting services: 43%; Agent management services: 18%.Agent letting servicesAgent letting services: 43%43%Agent management servicesAgent management services: 18%18%

Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Agent letting services43%
Agent management services18%

Set the boundaries in your terms of business. Say what claims handling is included, whether there is a separate fee for major claims, how much you can spend on emergency work without approval, and that the landlord remains the policyholder. Agents are also often the first to know about a problem, which makes their records the backbone of the claim.

The claims workflow

  1. Make safe

    Stop the damage getting worse: plumber, electrician, glazier or board-up. Keep every invoice and the contractor's notes on cause.

  2. Tell the landlord

    Same day, with what happened, what you have done, initial photos and whether you think a claim is likely.

  3. Notify the insurer

    With the landlord's authority, call the claims line or use the insurer's portal. Get a claim reference and note any instructions, such as not starting repairs before a loss adjuster visits.

  4. Gather evidence

    Photos and video of all damage, the latest inventory and inspection report, contractor reports, moisture readings and the tenant's account.

  5. Get quotes

    Two or three quotes for reinstatement, itemised, from contractors who will deal with the insurer or loss adjuster.

  6. Manage the adjuster visit

    Arrange access with the tenant, attend if you can and take your own notes of what was said.

  7. Track to settlement

    Chase weekly, update the landlord and tenant, and keep a log of every call and email.

  8. Account for the money

    Pay contractors from insurer funds only on the landlord's instruction and show every movement on the landlord's statement.

Evidence that insurers ask for

A standard evidence pack for a landlord buildings or contents claim.
EvidenceWhere it comes fromWhy it matters
Date and time the damage was foundTenant report, call logShows prompt notification
Photos and video of damageTenant, agent, contractorExtent of loss
Cause of loss reportPlumber, roofer, electricianWhether the cause is covered
Last inspection reportProperty fileCondition before the loss; maintenance record
Check-in inventoryProperty fileWhat was there and in what condition
Safety certificatesProperty fileGas and electrical compliance at the time
Itemised quotesContractorsBasis for settlement
Rent scheduleAccountsLoss of rent claim if the home is uninhabitable

Inspection reports carry more weight than most agents realise. Many policies exclude gradual damage, wear and tear or a failure to maintain. A dated report showing the roof, gutters or sealant were checked and in reasonable condition a few months earlier can be the difference between a paid claim and a declined one.

Common claim types and the agent's checklist

  • Escape of water: find and fix the cause, record the cause in writing, start drying promptly and keep moisture readings.
  • Storm damage: photos taken as soon as safe, weather details for the date, roofer's report on cause and condition.
  • Malicious damage by tenants: police crime reference where appropriate, check-in and check-out reports, and the deposit position.
  • Fire: fire service report, contact with the tenant's household, safety certificates and alarm records.
  • Theft or break-in during a void: police reference, evidence of how the home was secured and when it was last visited.
  • Accidental damage: the tenant's account in writing and any relevant photos.

After every claim, add one line to the property file: what happened, the cause, the outcome and what would prevent it next time. Over a portfolio, those lines show which properties need a maintenance plan before the next claim.

Deposit, insurance or tenant: who pays

When a tenant causes damage, the landlord can claim against the deposit, against the tenant directly or on the policy, depending on cover and the size of the loss. In 2024, 70% of tenancy deposits registered with government-backed schemes in England were registered by agents on behalf of landlords[3], so agents usually manage this choice too.

Set it out for the landlord simply: the amount of damage, the deposit available, the policy excess, the likely effect of a claim on future premiums and the chance of recovering from the tenant. A small loss below or near the excess is usually a deposit matter. A large loss may need both, and the insurer may then pursue the tenant itself.

Keeping the tenant on side

The tenant lives with the consequences of the claim: drying machines, contractors, adjuster visits and sometimes weeks without a usable room. Explain the process at the start and give dates as soon as you have them. Ask the tenant to check their own contents insurance for their belongings, because the landlord's policy does not usually cover them.

Claims are a frequent source of complaints when they drag. Poor, unclear or delayed communication was listed first among the top issues in lettings disputes at The Property Ombudsman in 2025[4]. A weekly written update to both landlord and tenant costs ten minutes and prevents most of them.

Loss of rent and alternative accommodation

If damage makes the home uninhabitable, two questions arise at once: where does the tenant live, and what happens to the rent? Many landlord policies include loss of rent or alternative accommodation cover, usually with limits and conditions. Read the schedule with the landlord before promising the tenant anything, and agree in writing how rent will be treated while the tenant cannot live in the property.

Keep a simple record of the dates the property was unusable, the rent due for those dates and any accommodation costs paid. Insurers settle loss of rent on evidence, and a clean schedule from the agent avoids weeks of back and forth.

When a claim is declined

Claims are declined for a handful of familiar reasons: gradual damage rather than a sudden event, lack of maintenance, the property being empty longer than the policy allows, or a cause the policy excludes. Ask the insurer for the reason in writing and check it against the policy wording and your evidence.

  1. Send the landlord the decline letter with your view of whether it can be challenged.
  2. If your inspection records contradict the reason, supply them to the insurer and ask for a review.
  3. If the landlord wants to complain, they can use the insurer's complaints process and then the Financial Ombudsman Service.
  4. Arrange the repairs anyway if they are needed for safety or the tenancy, with the landlord's approval.

Money, fees and conflicts

Insurer settlements paid to the agent are client money. Letting and property management agents in England that hold client money must belong to a client money protection scheme or face a fine of up to £30,000[2]. Pay contractors only on the landlord's instruction, issue a statement line for every receipt and payment, and never offset an agent's fee against a settlement without clear authority.

Be careful about insurance itself. Recommending, arranging or selling cover is a regulated activity. Unless your firm is authorised or acts as an appointed representative, keep to handling claims as the landlord's agent and refer questions about what the policy covers to the broker or insurer. Disclose any commission you receive from contractors used on claims.

Example: a ceiling collapse in a managed flat

Example (fictional): a bathroom seal in a Bournemouth flat fails and the kitchen ceiling below partly collapses. The agent books a plumber, gets a cause report the same day, sends the landlord photos and opens a claim with the insurer's portal on the landlord's authority. The loss adjuster visits on day six with the agent present. Two quotes are submitted, the claim is accepted less the excess, and the reinstatement is done in week five. The landlord's statement shows the settlement in, the contractor paid out and the excess deducted, each with its own line.

Frequently asked questions

Can a letting agent make an insurance claim for a landlord?

Yes, as the landlord's agent and with their authority. The landlord remains the policyholder and makes the decisions on whether to claim and what to accept.

Should we start repairs before the loss adjuster visits?

Make the property safe and stop further damage straight away. For anything beyond that, follow the insurer's instructions, as some ask you to wait for the adjuster.

Does landlord insurance cover the tenant's belongings?

Usually not. Tenants need their own contents insurance for their possessions.

Is it better to use the deposit or the insurance for tenant damage?

It depends on the size of the loss, the excess and the effect on future premiums. Small losses are usually dealt with through the deposit; large ones may need both.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Private Landlord Survey 2024: main report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2019). Protecting clients' money if you're a property agent (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Private Landlord Survey 2024: main report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo