Phone enquiries

Following up instant online valuation leads

How to follow up instant online valuation leads: a call and message cadence for low-intent sellers, scripts and when to stop.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why these leads need their own process
  2. Sort leads on the first call
  3. A 90-day cadence for planning and curious leads
  4. Scripts that respect low intent
  5. When the online figure is higher than yours
  6. Turning a baseline appraisal into an instruction
  7. Who does what in the team
  8. Calling and messaging within the rules
  9. What to record on each lead
  10. Example: a curious lead that came back
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Rightmove said its AI-enabled online valuation tool supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to agents in H1 2026[1].
  • Most instant valuation leads are curious, not ready; sort them by timescale on the first call.
  • Use a 90-day cadence that mixes calls with useful local information, then move quiet leads to a quarterly check-in.
  • Stay within PECR: no calls to numbers on the TPS without consent, and honour any request to stop[2].

Why these leads need their own process

Instant online valuation tools have made it easy for homeowners to ask "what's my house worth?" at midnight without speaking to anyone. Rightmove reported that its AI-enabled Online Agent Valuation supported a c.50% total increase in unique valuation leads to estate agents in the first half of 2026[1]. More leads, though, does not mean more sellers. Many people are checking their equity, comparing with a neighbour's sale or thinking about remortgaging.

Instructions are still scarce. Propertymark member branches each placed around 10.8 homes on the market in August 2026[3], against an average of 69 new buyers registered[4]. RICS contributors reported that the volume of market appraisals remained below the level of a year earlier[5]. A branch that turns even a small share of online valuation leads into appraisals gains a real edge.

Average activity per Propertymark branch, August 2026
Average activity per Propertymark branch, August 2026Column chart. New buyers registered: 69; Homes placed on the market: 10.8.020406080New buyers registered: 6969New buyers registeredHomes placed on the market: 10.810.8Homes placed on the marketAverage activity per Propertymark branch, August 2026Column chart. New buyers registered: 69; Homes placed on the market: 10.8.020406080New buyers registered: 6969New buyersregisteredHomes placed on the market: 10.810.8Homes placed onthe market

Source: Propertymark, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
New buyers registered69
Homes placed on the market10.8

Sort leads on the first call

Call within the hour if you can. The aim of the first call is not to book an appraisal at any cost; it is to find out where the person really is. Four questions do most of the work.

  1. "What made you look at the value today?"
  2. "Are you thinking of moving, or was it more about knowing where you stand?"
  3. "If you did move, roughly when would that be?"
  4. "Would a proper valuation from someone who knows the street be useful now, or later on?"
Sorting instant valuation leads
SegmentTypical answerNext step
Ready: moving within three months"We've seen somewhere" or "we need to move for work"Book an appraisal this week
Planning: three to twelve months"Probably next spring"Offer an appraisal now as a baseline, or agree a date to talk
Curious: no plans"Just interested" or remortgagingSend the local sales report; check in quarterly
Not the owner or invalidTenant, neighbour, wrong numberClose the lead politely

A 90-day cadence for planning and curious leads

  1. Day 0

    Call. If no answer, leave a short voicemail and send a text naming the property and your name.

  2. Day 1

    Email a short note: how instant estimates work, what they miss (condition, extensions, the street) and two recent local sales.

  3. Day 3

    Second call at a different time of day.

  4. Day 10

    Send something useful: a summary of homes sold nearby in the last three months.

  5. Day 30

    Check-in call: "Has anything changed since you looked?"

  6. Day 60

    Market update email for their postcode area.

  7. Day 90

    Final call. If still quiet, move to a quarterly update with their permission, or close the lead.

Adjust the cadence for the season. Sellers with flexible timing tend to come to market in the autumn, when there are typically more active buyers[6], so curious summer leads are worth a call in early September.

Scripts that respect low intent

Opening: "Hi, it's Sam from the branch. You looked up the value of 22 Ash Grove last night. I'm not calling to push you into selling. Online figures can be out by a fair bit, so I wanted to see whether a quick view from someone who knows Ash Grove would be useful."

When they say "just curious": "That's fine, lots of people check. Would it help if I sent you what's sold on your road and nearby every few months? No calls unless you ask."

Booking a baseline: "Even if you're not moving until next year, a valuation now gives you a baseline. It takes about 40 minutes and there's no obligation."

Never quote a figure on the phone to win the appointment. In August 2026, 86% of Propertymark agents reported homes selling below asking price[7]. A high number now becomes a price reduction conversation later.

When the online figure is higher than yours

Sometimes the owner's first question at the appraisal is why your figure is lower than the website said. Prepare for it. Instant estimates are built from past sales and broad area trends; they cannot see a tired kitchen, an awkward layout or the extension next door that took the light. Bring three comparable sales, explain what each one shows, and say plainly where you think the online figure went wrong.

"The online estimate looked at sales across the postcode. The two closest matches to your house sold in the summer, and both had the loft converted. Without that, buyers have been paying a little less. I'd rather tell you that now than after six weeks on the market."

Owners respect an agent who explains the evidence. They rarely respect one who simply matches the highest number they have seen.

Turning a baseline appraisal into an instruction

Owners who accept a "baseline" valuation months ahead of a move are among the best leads you will ever get, but only if you stay in touch properly. Send a written summary within a day of the visit, with the figure range, the evidence and two or three things that would make the home easier to sell. Diarise a call for the month before they said they might move. In between, send the local sales summary they agreed to receive, and mention any sale on their road personally. When the time comes, you are the agent who already knows the house, has explained the price honestly and has been useful for months. That is a much stronger position than arriving cold against two rivals who quote a higher number.

Who does what in the team

  • Valuers or senior negotiators make the first call, because the conversation is about the owner's home and plans.
  • An administrator or lead coordinator runs the cadence, sends the local sales summaries and books calls into diaries.
  • The branch manager reviews the lead list weekly and reassigns anything that has gone quiet without a decision.

Calling and messaging within the rules

A follow-up call about a valuation the person requested is a response to their enquiry. Later calls that promote your services are direct marketing, and PECR prohibits unsolicited marketing calls to numbers on the Telephone Preference Service register, or to anyone who has told you not to call[2]. A TPS registration less than 28 days old is not a breach[8], but the simplest rule is to check consent at the first call.

  • Ask on the first call whether they are happy to hear from you again, and by which channel.
  • Record the answer with the date.
  • Stop at once if anyone asks you to.
  • Send email updates only with consent or within a valid soft opt-in.
  • Present a callable number when you phone; hidden numbers are not allowed for marketing calls.

What to record on each lead

  • Source tool and date of the online estimate.
  • Segment and expected timescale.
  • Motivation in the owner's words.
  • Consent for follow-up and preferred channel.
  • Next action and date.
  • Outcome: appraisal booked, instructed, lost to another agent, closed.

Review the outcomes quarterly. If most appraisals from online leads come from the "planning" segment, put more effort into the 30 and 60-day touches. If almost none convert, look at how quickly the first call happens.

Example: a curious lead that came back

Example (fictional): a homeowner checks an instant estimate in July and says on the call that they are "just curious". The negotiator asks permission to send a quarterly sales summary and logs "curious; possible move next year; email only". In September the summary shows two similar homes sold nearby. The owner replies asking for a valuation. The appraisal is booked within the week, and the vendor instructs because the agent had been useful without being pushy.

Online valuation leads overlap with other enquiries. Some will be buyers too, so ask whether they have seen anything they like and check whether any are waiting on properties under offer. For website forms that feed these leads, see enquiry forms that capture the right details. And when calls arrive out of hours, an answering service such as Ava can take the details and book the appraisal into your calendar, leaving the figure to your valuer.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly should we call an online valuation lead?

Within the hour if possible, while the person still remembers looking. Leave a voicemail and follow with a text if there is no answer.

Should we give a price on the phone?

No. Explain that an accurate figure needs a visit, and book one. Quoting a high figure to win the appointment creates price reductions later.

Can we keep calling a lead that is not ready?

Ask for permission on the first call. Marketing calls to TPS-registered numbers without consent are prohibited under PECR[2].

When should we stop following up?

After about 90 days without engagement, move the lead to a consented quarterly update or close it.

References

  1. Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2019). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 21 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Rightmove (2026). House Price Index, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2019). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 21 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo