Key takeaways
- Each Propertymark branch placed around 10.8 homes on the market in August 2026; small gains in instruction rate move the whole pipeline[1].
- Measure the funnel: valuations booked, held, proposals sent, instructions won, and the reasons for losses.
- Win on evidence, not on the highest figure; 86% of agents reported homes selling below asking in August 2026[2].
- Send the proposal the same day and follow up on a set schedule.
- Earn reviews honestly: concealed incentivised reviews are banned under CMA guidance[3].
Start with the funnel, not the pitch
Most advice on winning instructions focuses on the valuation appointment itself. The appointment matters, but instructions are won or lost across a longer chain: how quickly the enquiry was answered, how well the valuer prepared, how fast the proposal arrived and how the follow-up was handled. Measuring each step shows where the losses really happen.
Enquiries to valuations booked
Of every seller who contacted you, how many booked a valuation? Low numbers point to slow responses or weak booking calls.
Booked to held
How many appointments actually happened? Cancellations here suggest booking sellers who were not ready, or weak confirmation routines.
Held to proposal sent
Did every seller receive a written proposal, and how quickly? Delays here are common and costly.
Proposal to instruction
How many chose you? Record why the others did not: price advised, fee, another agent's relationship, or timing.
The market makes each step count. RICS contributors reported that the number of market appraisals remained below the level of twelve months earlier, although a net balance of +6% of surveyors saw more new sales instructions in September 2026[4]. When appraisals are scarce, a few percentage points at each stage add up to meaningfully more stock.
Win the competition you actually face
Most competitors are small, local firms like yours. Of the 31,430 real estate agency enterprises in the UK in 2026, 28,330, about 90%, were micro businesses with 0 to 9 employees[5]. Sellers are rarely choosing between a local agent and a faceless giant; they are choosing between two or three local teams who look similar on paper. Service, evidence and follow-through are what separate you.
- 0 to 9 employees 28,330 90%
- 10 or more employees 3,100 10%
Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 0 to 9 employees | 28,330 |
| 10 or more employees | 3,100 |
Trust is a low bar to clear and an easy one to trip over. Only 37% of people said they trust estate agents in the Ipsos poll cited by the government[6]. Sellers notice agents who do what they say they will, on time.
Before the visit: preparation that sellers notice
Sellers can tell when a valuer has done their homework. Ten minutes of preparation produces specific comments that build credibility: the house two doors down that sold last spring, the competing listing that has been reduced twice, the buyers on your list looking for exactly this type of home.
- Recent sold prices for comparable homes nearby, with dates and any differences in condition or size.
- Current competing listings, how long they have been on the market and any reductions.
- Matching buyers on your register, described without personal details.
- The property's own history: previous sales and any past listings.
- A short note on what the seller said when booking: reason for moving, timescale, other agents.
For a step-by-step routine, see our guide to market appraisal preparation.
At the appointment: listen, then advise
Let the seller show you round and talk. Ask about their plans, their worries and what went well or badly last time they sold. Most sellers have already looked up online estimates and asked friends; they want to know whether you understand their home and their situation.
When you talk about price, show your evidence. Give a range with reasons, explain how you would launch, and say what you would do if viewings did not produce offers. Be honest about the market: in August 2026, 86% of Propertymark member agents reported homes selling below asking and only 9% at asking[2]. A seller who hears that from you, with evidence, is better prepared than one who hears an unrealistic figure from a competitor.
Do not buy the instruction
Overvaluing to win the instruction is the oldest trap in agency. It wins the board and loses the sale: viewings without offers, a reduction conversation a month later, and a seller who blames the agent. If another agent quotes a higher figure, ask the seller which evidence it was based on, and walk through your comparables again. Some sellers will still choose the higher number. Track those cases; many come back to the market, or to you, later. For more, see our article on the real cost of overvaluing.
The proposal: same day, short and specific
A proposal that arrives three days later tells the seller how quickly you will respond to buyers. Send it the same day, while the conversation is fresh. Keep it short and personal.
- A recap of what the seller told you they want: timing, priorities, concerns.
- Your recommended asking price, with the comparables behind it.
- The launch plan: photography, floor plan, portal and social channels, and the first two weeks of viewings.
- How you will keep them updated, and how often.
- Your terms and fee, clearly stated, with the contract length and notice period.
- One clear next step, such as booking the photographer.
Follow up on a schedule
Many instructions are lost because the agent stops calling, not because the seller said no. Agree with the seller when you will next speak, and stick to it. A simple sequence works for most branches: a call the day after the proposal to answer questions; a short message with a relevant new sale or buyer after three days; a call after a week to ask whether they have decided; then a monthly market update for sellers who are not ready yet. Stop when the seller asks you to, and record their preference.
Lettings instructions follow the same logic
Landlords choose agents on similar grounds: evidence, responsiveness and confidence that the agent will keep them compliant. Prepare comparable lets rather than sales, know which certificates the landlord will need, and explain clearly what the agency will handle and what stays with the landlord. Landlords who self-manage often worry about losing control, so describe how and when you will report to them.
- Bring recent lets of comparable homes and how long each took to let.
- Check the property's EPC rating before the visit and be ready to discuss what it means.
- Explain how rent will be set and advertised, and how applicants will be qualified.
- Send the proposal the same day, with the service levels set out plainly.
Reviews and reputation
Sellers check reviews before they book. Ask every happy client for an honest review, and reply to negative ones calmly. Do not offer incentives in exchange for reviews without making that clear: under CMA guidance, a review written in exchange for money or other benefits without disclosure is a banned concealed incentivised review[3]. Do not filter out negative reviews or post reviews from staff or friends.
Example: fixing the slowest step
Example: a fictional branch held 40 valuations in a quarter and won 14 instructions. Breaking the funnel down showed that proposals took an average of three days to arrive, and that sellers who received them within a day instructed the branch far more often. The manager blocked thirty minutes at the end of every valuer's day for proposals and introduced the follow-up sequence above.
Example, continued: the next quarter, with a similar number of valuations, the branch won 19 instructions. Nothing about the valuations themselves changed. The figures are illustrative, but the pattern is common: the easiest gains are usually in the steps after the appointment.
Use new lead sources wisely
Online valuation tools are sending more sellers to agents. Rightmove reported that its AI-enabled Online Agent Valuation supported a c.50% increase in unique valuation leads to estate agents in the first half of 2026[7]. Many of those sellers are early in their thinking. Respond quickly, ask readiness questions, and offer the right appointment: a full valuation for those ready now, a shorter conversation and regular updates for those who are only curious. Measure the funnel for each source separately, so you know where your instructions really come from.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good valuation to instruction rate?
It varies by area and competition, so track your own and improve it step by step. Measure bookings, appointments held, proposals sent and instructions won, and record why you lost the others.
How quickly should I send a valuation proposal?
The same day where possible. Sellers often decide within a few days, and speed signals how responsive you will be once the home is on the market.
Should I match a competitor's higher valuation to win the instruction?
Not without evidence. Overvaluing often leads to a stale listing and a price reduction later. Explain your comparables and let the seller weigh them.
Can I give clients a gift for leaving a review?
If you offer any incentive, the review must clearly disclose it. CMA guidance bans concealed incentivised reviews, and reviews should never be conditional on being positive.
References
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report: August 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) (2026). UK Residential Market Survey, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 68310, 68320), 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑