Key takeaways
- An overpriced instruction rarely sells at the inflated figure: most agents report homes selling below asking[1].
- Stale stock clogs the branch: the average member branch had far more homes for sale than sales agreed each month[1].
- The cost lands on negotiator time, portal spend and the agency's reputation, not just the seller's patience.
- Complaints follow broken expectations, and most ombudsman decisions went the consumer's way in 2025[2].
- Track valuation against sale price by valuer to see the habit in your own numbers.
Why agents overvalue
Nobody sets out to mislead a seller. Overvaluing usually starts with a competitive appraisal. The seller has seen two other agents, one figure was higher than yours, and you suspect the instruction goes to whoever says the biggest number. You nudge your figure up to stay in the race, telling yourself the market can decide.
The Property Ombudsman's code is clear that any figure you advise must be given in good faith, reflect market conditions and be supported by comparable evidence, and that you must never deliberately misrepresent the market value[3]. Beyond the rule, there is a commercial case against the habit, and it is stronger than most branch managers think.
The stock arithmetic
In August 2026, the average Propertymark member branch had 51 homes available for sale and agreed 9.5 sales in the month[1]. That is more than five months of stock at the current pace. Overpriced listings make the ratio worse, because they sit at the back of the queue while correctly priced homes sell around them.
Source: Propertymark, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Homes available for sale | 51 |
| Sales agreed in the month | 9.5 |
The same survey found 86% of member agents reporting homes selling below asking and only 9% at asking[1]. In London in October 2026, 38% of listings had been reduced and only 42% of homes found a buyer, taking an average of 78 days to do so[4]. A figure that is already optimistic in that market becomes a reduction waiting to happen.
What happens to an overpriced listing
Weeks one and two
The listing attracts clicks from buyers who search in its band, but viewings convert poorly because buyers compare it with cheaper homes they have already seen.
Weeks three to six
Viewings fall away. The seller asks what is wrong. Feedback mentions price politely, as 'not quite right for us'.
First reduction
A cut arrives, usually too small, because the seller is anchored to the original figure. Buyers who watched the listing wait for a second one.
Relaunch or withdrawal
The home is relaunched with a new photo set, or withdrawn and given to another agent who prices it correctly and gets the sale.
The costs, item by item
| Cost | Who bears it | How it shows up |
|---|---|---|
| Negotiator time | Agency | Extra viewings, feedback calls and price conversations for a home that does not sell |
| Portal and marketing spend | Agency | Months of advertising on a listing that earns no fee |
| Lost fee | Agency | The seller withdraws and another agent sells at the right price |
| Lower final price | Seller | After reductions, buyers negotiate from the cut figure and early demand has passed |
| Delay | Seller | Missed onward purchase, chain collapse, extra mortgage or bridging cost |
| Reputation | Agency | A local seller who tells neighbours you overpromised |
Portal spend alone is significant. Rightmove's average revenue per agency advertiser was £1,636 a month in the first half of 2026[5]. Every listing that sits for months takes a share of that spend without bringing a fee.
The complaint risk
Broken expectations turn into complaints. The Property Ombudsman decided 61% of its 2025 cases in the consumer's favour, resolved 2,243 sales disputes, 9% more than in 2024, and made an average award of £616 in sales cases[2]. A seller who was promised a figure the market never paid is a likely complainant, especially if the agreement had a long tie-in.
Trust is also low to start with. Only 37% of people said they trust estate agents, according to the Ipsos index cited by the government[6]. Every inflated figure reinforces that view, and sellers talk to their neighbours.
Example: one inflated instruction
Example: a branch wins a three-bedroom house at a figure its own comparables do not support. It spends four months marketing the home, books sixteen viewings and makes two reductions. The seller then withdraws and instructs a competitor, which agrees a sale in three weeks at roughly the figure the first branch's comparables pointed to. The first branch has spent negotiator time, a share of its portal budget and the seller's goodwill, and earned nothing.
Example: the competitor that sold it did not have better buyers. It had a correctly priced launch and the benefit of the first agent's reductions, which had already reset the seller's expectations.
The hidden effect on your applicant list
Overpriced stock does damage beyond the listing itself. Applicants who view two or three of your homes and find each one overpriced for what it offers stop trusting your particulars. They begin to treat every figure from your branch as a starting point for a much lower offer, which makes it harder to achieve good prices on the homes you priced correctly.
Your applicant list is also finite. If your negotiators spend their calls pushing buyers towards homes that will not sell at their current figure, they have less time to match buyers to the homes that will. The branch's sales agreed figure drops even while instruction numbers look healthy, which is why instruction counts alone are a poor measure of a valuer's performance.
What sellers say they want
Sellers do want a good price, but most also want certainty: a sale that agrees, progresses and completes on a date they can plan around. When you ask a seller at the appraisal what matters most, the answer is often a date, a school term or an onward purchase rather than a figure. Building your recommendation around that goal gives you a way to compete without the biggest number, and makes the seller's own priorities the measure of a good figure.
A pricing policy for the branch
Write the standard
Agree in writing that every recommended figure must be backed by at least three adjusted comparables, kept on file.
Review high figures
Any figure above the top of the evidence needs a second opinion from the manager before it goes to the seller.
Record the reason
Where the seller insists on a higher launch figure, record your recommendation, the seller's choice and the review date.
Review monthly
Look at instructions that have had no offers in four weeks and decide the next step with the negotiator.
Reward sales, not listings
Base valuer targets on sales agreed and completed, so no one is paid for building stale stock.
How to win instructions without inflating
- Lead with evidence. Bring the comparables, adjusted in writing, and let the seller test them.
- Name the higher figure openly. Say you know another agent may have suggested more, and ask what evidence they gave.
- Offer a review plan instead of a higher number: an agreed date to look at viewings and feedback together.
- Show your sale-price record against the original asking price, if you track it, and how quickly your sales agree.
- Be willing to lose some instructions. The ones you lose at an inflated figure are often back on the market within months.
Measure it in your own branch
Most agencies already hold the data to see whether overvaluing is costing them. Pull every instruction from the last year and record three numbers: the figure at instruction, the agreed sale price and the days from launch to sale agreed. Group them by valuer.
- A valuer whose instructions regularly need reductions is pricing to win, not to sell.
- A valuer with high instruction numbers but low sales agreed is building stale stock.
- A valuer whose homes sell close to the launch figure is your benchmark. Ask them to review the others' figures for a month.
Share the numbers in your weekly sales meeting. Once the team can see that inflated instructions cost them time and commission, the pressure to say the biggest number at the kitchen table eases.
Talking to a seller who wants the higher figure
Some sellers will still ask you to market at the higher figure. You can agree to their figure only if you put your own recommendation and the reasons in writing, set an early review date and agree in advance what change follows if interest is weak. That protects the seller from drift and protects you if the seller later says nobody warned them. For the reduction conversation itself, see price reduction advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is overvaluing a property against the rules?
The Property Ombudsman's code says any figure must be given in good faith, supported by comparable evidence, and that you must never deliberately misrepresent market value. Overvaluing to win an instruction breaks that standard.
Why do overpriced homes often sell for less in the end?
Buyers watch for reductions and compare a stale listing with fresher homes. By the time the price is right, the early demand has gone.
How can I tell if my branch overvalues?
Compare the figure at instruction with the sale price agreed and the days to sale, grouped by valuer. Regular reductions show a pricing habit.
What should I do if a seller insists on a higher asking price?
Record your recommendation and evidence in writing, agree an early review date and the change that follows if interest is weak.
References
Propertymark (2026). Housing Insight Report, August 2026 (PDF) (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Property Ombudsman (2026). Code of Practice for Residential Estate Agents (TPOE27-9, March 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Rightmove (2026). House Price Index, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Rightmove plc (2026). Rightmove plc unaudited results for the six months ended 30 June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑