Key takeaways
- Rent repayment orders now reach superior landlords and company directors, aimed squarely at criminal rent-to-rent[1].
- New possession grounds cover the end of a superior lease, so subletting structures need planning for the exit[1].
- Tenants can claim for offences committed in the 2 years before they apply[2].
- Operators doing lettings or management work need redress membership and, if they hold client money, client money protection[3].
- Owners should check the operator's licensing, redress and insurance before signing, not after a council visit.
What rent-to-rent means here
Rent-to-rent covers arrangements where an owner lets a property to an intermediary, often a company, which then sublets it to occupiers. Guaranteed rent schemes run by agents and serviced accommodation operators use the same structure. The owner receives a fixed rent; the intermediary keeps the difference between that rent and what the occupiers pay.
Done well, these arrangements give owners hands-off income. Done badly, they produce unlicensed houses in multiple occupation, overcrowding and owners who did not know what was happening in their own property. The Renters' Rights Act targets the second group. The government says it is extending rent repayment orders to superior landlords and company directors to tackle criminal rent-to-rent arrangements[1].
Who is the landlord of whom
| Arrangement | Owner's tenant | Occupier's landlord | Assured tenancy rules for occupiers? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent-to-rent company subletting rooms | The company | The company | Usually yes, where occupiers live there as their only or principal home |
| Agent guaranteed rent scheme | The agent or its company | The agent or its company | Usually yes |
| Genuine company let for an employee | The company | None: the employee occupies under the company's arrangement | No assured tenancy between owner and company |
| Serviced accommodation for short stays | The operator | Guests under short-stay licences | Often not, if genuinely holiday or short-stay use |
An assured tenancy needs an individual tenant occupying the home as their only or principal home, so a genuine let to a company is not itself an assured tenancy. But when that company sublets to individuals who live there, those sublets are normally assured tenancies with the company as landlord. Everything in the Act then applies to the company: periodic tenancies, grounds for possession, rent rules and penalties.
The new exposure for owners
Before the reforms, an owner who leased a house to a rent-to-rent operator could often stand back if the operator ran an unlicensed HMO. Now rent repayment orders can be made against superior landlords as well[1]. The qualifying offences include running an unlicensed HMO or licensable house, failing to comply with improvement notices, and harassment or illegal eviction[4]. The maximum order doubled from 12 to 24 months of rent[1], and tenants can apply for offences committed in the 2 years before their application[2].
For corporate structures, orders can also reach company directors[1]. Owners who lease to a newly formed company with no assets should no longer assume the company is the only party at risk.
When the head lease ends
The traditional weak point in rent-to-rent is the end of the head lease. If the owner takes the property back, the occupiers' tenancies with the operator do not simply disappear. The Act adds possession grounds 2ZA to 2ZD for situations where a superior lease ends[1]. Owners and operators should agree in writing, before any occupier moves in, how and when those grounds would be used, who serves notice and who bears the cost of any void or court action.
An exit plan agreed at the start is far cheaper than an argument at the end. Write it into the head lease and the management agreement.
Regulatory duties for operators
An operator that finds occupiers, collects rent or manages the property for others is doing lettings agency or property management work. To do that work in England, an agent must be registered with a relevant redress scheme[3]. Operators that hold clients' money must also join a client money protection scheme or face a fine of up to 30,000 pounds[5], and must display their certificate in offices and online, with fines of up to 5,000 pounds for failing to[5].
- Licensing: mandatory HMO licensing, plus any additional or selective scheme in the council area.
- Planning: whether HMO use needs permission locally, especially where an Article 4 direction applies.
- Safety: gas, electrical and fire safety, including HMO management regulations.
- Deposits: protection within the statutory deadline for each occupier's deposit.
- Database: once registration applies in the region, the operator as landlord of the occupiers will need to register.
An owner's checklist before signing
Identify the operator
Get the company number, directors and trading history. Check for banning orders and past enforcement where you can.
Ask for proof of memberships
Redress scheme, client money protection certificate if relevant, and professional indemnity insurance.
Check licensing and planning
Confirm whether the intended use needs an HMO, additional or selective licence and any planning permission, and who will apply.
Agree occupancy limits
Set maximum occupiers and room use in the head lease and prohibit changes without consent.
Secure inspection rights
Reserve the right to inspect with notice and to see tenancy records, safety certificates and licence conditions.
Plan the exit
Agree how the head lease ends, how occupiers are dealt with and who pays.
If your agency runs a guaranteed rent scheme
Some letting agents offer owners a guaranteed rent product, taking a lease of the property and letting it on. That makes the agency the landlord of the occupiers, with every duty that brings. Review the scheme against the Act rather than assuming the agency's existing compliance covers it.
- List every property held under a lease, separately from managed properties, with the lease end date.
- Confirm the agency entity that is landlord to the occupiers, and that it holds the right licences and registrations in its own name.
- Check that tenancy documents name the correct landlord and reflect periodic tenancies.
- Model the cost of the head lease ending: notice periods, possible voids and court action, and who carries them under the lease.
- Make sure owners understand, in writing, their own exposure as superior landlord if something goes wrong.
Guaranteed rent can still be attractive to owners who want certainty. It works best when the agency prices in the real risks of the new regime and is open with owners about them.
Warning signs of a problem operator
- Offers well above market rent with no explanation of how the numbers work.
- Reluctance to share company details, licence plans or insurance.
- Plans to add bedrooms by converting living rooms, without mentioning licensing or room size standards.
- No redress scheme membership, or vague answers about client money.
- A head lease drafted by the operator that restricts the owner's right to inspect.
Any one of these is a reason to pause. Several together are a reason to walk away and tell the owner why in writing.
Example: a house the owner had not visited
Example (fictional): an owner leases a four-bedroom house to a rent-to-rent company for three years. The company converts the lounge to a fifth bedroom and lets five rooms to individuals. Nobody applies for a mandatory HMO licence.
- In the example, after a council inspection, the five occupiers apply for rent repayment orders.
- Under the old rules the claim would have been against the company, which has few assets.
- Under the new rules the owner, as superior landlord, also faces the claim, and the company's directors are in the frame.
- The owner's letting agent, who introduced the company, is asked by the owner why no licensing check was made before the lease was signed.
In the example, a one-page checklist at the start would have flagged the licensing duty and the occupancy limit. Agents who introduce rent-to-rent operators to owners should treat that checklist as part of their own due diligence.
Company lets: what still works
Genuine company lets, where a business rents a home for an employee, remain a useful product. The tenancy between owner and company is not an assured tenancy, so the Act's tenancy rules do not apply to that contract in the same way. Make sure the paperwork reflects reality: the company is the tenant, the employee occupies by arrangement with the company and the company pays the rent.
Problems arise when a 'company let' label is used for what is really a let to individuals, for example where the employee pays the rent personally or the company is a shell created to avoid tenant protections. Courts look at substance, not labels. Read more in holiday lets, licences and excluded tenancies, rent repayment orders, renewal fees and agency income and utilities on a change of tenancy.
Frequently asked questions
Is rent-to-rent legal?
Yes, if the operator complies with licensing, safety, redress, client money and tenancy law. The Act targets criminal arrangements, not the structure itself.
Can the property owner be liable for a rent-to-rent operator's offences?
Rent repayment orders can now be made against superior landlords, so owners face real exposure if the operator commits a qualifying offence such as running an unlicensed HMO.
Are company lets covered by the Renters' Rights Act?
A genuine let to a company is not an assured tenancy, because an assured tenancy needs an individual tenant living there as their main home. Sublets by the company to individuals usually are.
What happens to occupiers if the head lease ends?
Their tenancies do not end automatically. The Act includes grounds for possession where a superior lease ends, and owners and operators should agree an exit plan in advance.
References
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Guide to the Renters' Rights Act (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Housing and Planning Act 2016, section 41 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Register your rental property service: guidance for letting agents and property managers (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). Housing and Planning Act 2016, section 40 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2019). Client money protection schemes for property agents (opens in a new tab) ↑