Marketing

Responding to negative reviews

Triage negative reviews, reply in four calm steps without breaching confidentiality, and link replies to your complaints process. Templates included.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Who your reply is really for
  2. Triage before you type
  3. The four-part reply
  4. Templates you can adapt
  5. Confidentiality: what never goes in a public reply
  6. What not to do
  7. Who replies, and how fast
  8. Link replies to your complaints procedure
  9. Example: turning a one-star review into a fixed process
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Reply within two working days, in four steps: thank, acknowledge, explain your process without personal details, and move offline.
  • Never disclose transaction, tenancy or personal details in a public reply; the reviewer is not the only person involved.
  • Do not offer refunds or gifts in return for removing criticism; that can count as a concealed incentive[1].
  • Poor communication tops the list of issues in lettings disputes[2]; many bad reviews are the same complaint in public.
  • Treat every negative review as a possible formal complaint and offer your complaints procedure in the reply.

Who your reply is really for

A negative review stings, and the instinct is to defend the branch or correct the record point by point. Resist it. Your reply has two audiences, and the reviewer is the smaller one. The larger audience is every vendor, landlord and tenant who reads the review later while deciding whether to trust you. They will judge you less on what went wrong than on how you respond. A calm, fair, brief reply that takes responsibility where it is due often does more for your reputation than a page of five-star reviews.

Most bad reviews are a complaint that has gone public. The Property Ombudsman listed poor, unclear or delayed communication across all stages first among the top issues in lettings disputes in 2025[2]. That is the same theme you will see in many one-star reviews: nobody called back, nobody explained, nobody said what would happen next. The reply is your chance to show the communication the reviewer says was missing.

Triage before you type

Read the review twice, check the file and decide which kind it is. Each needs a different approach.

Six kinds of negative review and how to approach each
Type of reviewWhat the reviewer wantsYour aim
Genuine service failureAcknowledgement and a fixApologise specifically, say what you are changing, offer a call
Disagreement about factsTo be heard and proved rightExplain your process neutrally; take the detail offline
Unhappy with an outcome you did not controlSomeone to blameExplain your role and duties briefly; show empathy
Fee or deposit disputeMoney backPoint to the complaints procedure and redress; no public argument about amounts
Not a client, or appears fakeUnknownReply once politely saying you cannot find a record; report to the platform
Abusive or discriminatoryReactionReport to the platform; reply only if needed, briefly

The four-part reply

  1. Thank them and use their name

    A simple "Thank you for taking the time to tell us" sets a different tone from a defensive opener. Use the first name they used on the review.

  2. Acknowledge the specific problem

    Name what they are unhappy about in their terms: slow updates, a viewing that did not happen, a delay to the deposit. If you got it wrong, say so plainly.

  3. Explain your process, not their case

    One or two sentences on how things should work, or what you are changing, without any detail of their transaction, tenancy or circumstances.

  4. Move it offline with a named person

    Give a name and direct contact, and mention your complaints procedure. End there; do not ask them to change the review.

Keep replies short: four to six sentences. Long replies read as arguments. Reply within two working days, and sooner if the review is getting attention.

Templates you can adapt

Service failure: "Thank you, Daniel, and I am sorry. You should have had a call back the same day, and you did not. We have changed how messages are logged in the branch so this does not happen again. I would like to talk it through properly; please call me directly on the branch number and ask for Sarah, the branch manager."

Factual disagreement: "Thank you for your feedback, Helen. We take concerns about how offers are handled seriously, and our process is to pass every offer to the seller and confirm it in writing. I cannot discuss the details here, but I would welcome the chance to go through what happened with you. Please contact me on the branch number."

Deposit or fee dispute: "Thank you, Marcus. I understand you are unhappy with how the deposit return was handled. We want to resolve this, and our complaints procedure is on our website. If we cannot agree, you can refer the matter to our redress scheme. Please contact me directly so we can start."

No record found: "Thank you for your review. We cannot find a record of working with anyone of this name, and we would like to understand what happened. Please contact the branch directly so we can look into it."

Confidentiality: what never goes in a public reply

A review platform is public and permanent. Your reply must not reveal personal information about the reviewer or anyone else in the transaction, even if the reviewer has shared it. The seller, the buyer, the landlord and the tenant all have an interest in what you say.

  • No addresses, prices, offer amounts, rent arrears, deposit deductions or dates of completion.
  • No references to someone’s finances, health, family circumstances or immigration status.
  • No details of the other party’s behaviour, such as a seller who withdrew or a tenant who left damage.
  • No screenshots of messages or emails.
  • No suggestion that the reviewer is lying. Say that your records differ and invite a conversation.

If the review contains false and damaging claims, report it to the platform using its own process and keep a record of what you sent. Ask for legal advice before threatening action; a heavy-handed response often draws more attention to the review than the review itself.

What not to do

  • Do not offer a refund, discount or gift in return for removing or editing a review. The competition regulator gives exactly this as an example of a concealed incentivised review[1].
  • Do not edit, hide or withhold genuine negative reviews on platforms you control, such as your own website; the guidance warns against limiting access to them[1].
  • Do not treat a review as a complaint and refuse to publish it, or tell the customer they must choose between complaining and reviewing[1].
  • Do not reply while angry. Draft, wait an hour, and have a second person read it.
  • Do not copy the same reply onto every negative review. Readers notice.

Who replies, and how fast

Decide in advance who owns replies. In most agencies it should be the branch manager, with a director covering anything that mentions legal action, discrimination or the press. Negotiators who handled the case should not reply themselves; they are too close to it, and the reviewer may see it as the same person who let them down. Set a simple rule: every negative review gets a draft within one working day, a second read by someone else, and a published reply within two. Put review alerts on a shared inbox rather than one person’s phone, so holidays and sick days do not leave a one-star review unanswered for a fortnight.

Many negative reviews are the first sign of a formal complaint. Log each one in your complaints record, assign an owner and follow your written procedure. Residential estate agents across the country, and letting agents and property managers in England and Wales, must belong to a redress scheme[3], and an unresolved complaint can end up there.

The numbers show how often that happens. The Property Ombudsman resolved 7,681 disputes in 2025, 54% more than the year before[4], and 61% of the cases it decided went in the consumer’s favour[5]. Average awards were £616 in sales cases and £497 in lettings cases[6][7]. A good public reply that leads to a real conversation can stop a complaint before it gets that far.

Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Total lettings awards rose 52% to £778,849
Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Comparison. Sales cases: £616; Lettings cases: £497.£616Sales casesSales cases: £616£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497Average Property Ombudsman award, 2025Comparison. Sales cases: £616; Lettings cases: £497.£616Sales casesSales cases: £616£497Lettings casesLettings cases: £497

Source: The Property Ombudsman, 2025[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Sales cases£616
Lettings cases£497

Example: turning a one-star review into a fixed process

Example (fictional). A tenant posted a one-star review saying nobody responded for nine days to a report of a broken boiler. The branch manager replied the next morning with an apology, said the branch had changed how out-of-hours repair reports were logged, and gave her direct number. On the call she learned the report had gone to an inbox nobody checked on Fridays. She fixed the routing, told the landlord and the tenant what had changed, and logged the case in the complaints record. The tenant later added a line to the review saying the agency had sorted it out. Nobody asked them to.

The lesson is the order of events: reply publicly with care, fix the cause privately, and let the reviewer decide what to say next. For the other half of the job, building a steady flow of reviews, see our guide to getting more reviews.

Frequently asked questions

Should estate agents reply to every negative review?

Yes, in most cases, within two working days. Keep it short, thank the reviewer, acknowledge the problem, explain your process without personal details and offer a direct contact.

Can I ask a client to remove a bad review if I fix the problem?

You can fix the problem and leave the choice to them. Offering a refund or gift in return for changing the review is given by the competition regulator as an example of a concealed incentivised review[1].

What if a review is fake?

Reply once, politely, saying you cannot find a record and inviting contact. Then report it to the platform through its own process and keep a record.

Can a bad review become an ombudsman complaint?

Yes. Many reviews describe a complaint the client has not raised formally. Log it, follow your complaints procedure and tell the client about your redress scheme[3].

References

  1. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews guidance (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2018). Registering with a redress scheme as a property agent (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo