Key takeaways
- Only 37% of people say they trust estate agents[1]; a steady stream of genuine reviews is one of the few ways to show you are different.
- Ask every client, not just the happy ones. Encouraging only satisfied customers to review can count as cherry-picking[2].
- Concealed incentivised reviews are banned[3]; prize draws for reviewers and discounts for five stars are out.
- Time each request to a natural high point: keys handed over, tenancy started, first rent statement sent.
- Write the process down so it runs every time, whoever is in the branch.
Why reviews matter more than ever for agents
Vendors and landlords choosing an agent rarely have much to go on. They see a board, a website, a portal listing and the star rating next to your name in search results. Reviews are the only part of that picture written by people like them. In a profession that only 37% of people say they trust, according to the Ipsos Veracity Index cited by the government[1], that independent voice carries real weight.
- Trust estate agents 37%
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Trust estate agents | 37% |
The rules have tightened at the same time. The unfair commercial practices provisions of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which cover fake reviews, came into force on 6 April 2025[4]. Businesses that publish consumer reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews[5]. In March 2026 the competition regulator opened investigations into five businesses over online reviews using its new powers[6]. Getting more reviews is still the right goal, but how you get them now matters as much as how many.
The right moment to ask
People review when the experience is fresh and the outcome is good. For agencies those moments are predictable, so build the request into the workflow at each one rather than relying on negotiators to remember.
| Client | Best moment | Second chance |
|---|---|---|
| Seller | The day after completion, once keys are released | Two weeks later, with a short thank-you |
| Buyer | The day after completion | Not usually needed; one request is enough |
| Landlord (let only) | Once the tenant has moved in and the first rent has been paid | At renewal or re-let |
| Landlord (managed) | After the first quarter of management | Once a year, with the annual statement |
| Tenant | Two weeks after move-in, when the home is set up | At the end of tenancy, once the deposit is resolved |
Ask every client at the same points, whatever you think they will say. That is fair, it is what the rules expect and it produces a more believable mix of ratings.
Scripts that work
Keep requests short and personal, and make the link one tap. Send from the negotiator who handled the move, not a no-reply address.
Text to a seller after completion: "Hi Priya, it was great to see the sale complete yesterday. If you have two minutes, would you leave an honest review of how we did? It helps other people choosing an agent. [link] Thanks, Tom"
Email to a tenant two weeks after move-in: "We hope you are settling in at Flat 4. We ask every tenant for honest feedback on how we handled the let, good or bad. You can leave a public review here [link], or reply to this email if there is something we should sort out first. Either way, we read every word."
Notice what the second script does. It offers a private route for problems alongside the public review link, not instead of it. That is helpful. What you must not do is send only the unhappy clients to a private form and only the happy ones to the public site.
What the rules ban
The competition regulator’s guidance is specific about the practices that can break the law. The ones most relevant to agencies are these.
- Concealed incentivised reviews: a review written in exchange for money or other benefits without making that clear is banned[3]. That includes prize draws for reviewers, vouchers and discounts on fees.
- Cherry-picking: encouraging just those who are satisfied to leave reviews, or highlighting only favourable reviews, can mislead[2].
- Suppressing negative reviews: the guidance says traders should not interfere with the ability of reviewers to leave negative reviews, for example by arbitrarily stopping and starting review invitations[2].
- Pressure to change a review: offering a refund or a gift to remove negative comments, so the review no longer reflects the real experience, is listed as an example of a concealed incentive[2].
- Fake reviews: writing reviews yourself, asking staff, friends or family to post them, or buying them.
This is not theoretical. When the regulator reviewed more than 100 business websites in 2025, it found 54 could be failing to comply with its guidance[7].
A compliant review process in five steps
Trigger the request from the CRM
Completion, move-in and management milestones should create the request automatically, for every client, with the negotiator’s name.
Use one public link per platform
Send clients straight to your review page on the platform you have chosen. Do not route them through a rating screen that decides where they go next.
Offer a private route as well, never instead
Say clearly that they can contact the branch with any problem. Deal with issues fast, but do not ask for a review to be withheld while you do.
Reply to every review
Thank people for positive reviews and respond calmly to negative ones. See our guide to responding to negative reviews.
Publish a short review policy
State on your website how you collect reviews, that you invite all clients and that you do not offer incentives. The regulator’s short guide asks businesses to state their approach to incentivised reviews[5].
Awkward situations and how to handle them
- A client asks what to write: say you would value their honest view of what went well and what could have been better. Do not suggest wording or star ratings.
- A happy client offers to review before the sale completes: thank them and ask them to wait until completion, so the review reflects the whole experience.
- A sale fell through: still send the request if the client used your service for months. Their view of how you handled it is useful to the next vendor.
- A buyer reviews you badly because they were outbid: reply calmly, explain you act for the seller and must pass on every offer, and invite them to call.
- A tenant reviews a landlord’s decision as if it were yours: acknowledge it, explain your role without disclosing details, and offer to talk.
- A staff member wants to post a review of the branch: no. Staff, family and friends should not review the business.
Keep a short note in the CRM whenever one of these happens. Over time the notes show which parts of your service generate the most friction and give new staff real examples of how to respond.
Choosing where reviews go
Most agencies need two places at most: Google, because that is what appears beside your branch in local search, and one independent review site that vendors and landlords in your area recognise. Spreading requests across four platforms means none builds momentum. If you display reviews on your own website, show them in full, include the critical ones, and make clear where they were collected and over what period. Showing a rating average that excludes negative reviews is exactly the kind of misleading review information the rules target.
Example: what a steady process changes
Example (fictional). A two-branch agency had 40 reviews collected over six years, most from a single push when it opened. It set up automatic requests at completion and move-in, sent from the negotiator, with a reminder after a week. Over twelve months it gained a little over 100 new reviews. The average rating dipped slightly, because the mix now included less enthusiastic clients, but vendors began mentioning the reviews on valuation visits, and the branch had a far clearer picture of where service fell short.
The dip is a feature, not a problem. A long run of perfect scores looks less credible than a strong average with the occasional honest criticism and a calm reply.
Making reviews part of service, not marketing
Reviews are most valuable as feedback. Read them at the weekly team meeting, track the themes that recur, such as slow updates during sales progression or unclear fees, and fix the cause. A review process that only feeds the marketing team misses half its value. One that feeds the branch manager improves the service that the next review will describe. Our guides to local SEO and area guides show how reviews support the rest of your local marketing.
Frequently asked questions
Can estate agents offer a prize draw for reviews?
No, not without making the incentive clear in every review, and in practice it is best avoided. Reviews written in exchange for money or other benefits without disclosure are banned as concealed incentivised reviews[3].
Can I ask only happy clients for reviews?
No. The competition regulator’s guidance says encouraging just those who are satisfied to leave reviews can be cherry-picking, which may mislead consumers[2]. Ask every client at the same points.
When is the best time to ask a seller for a review?
The day after completion, once keys have been released and the outcome is fresh, with one gentle reminder about two weeks later.
Do I need a review policy?
It is good practice to publish one explaining how you collect reviews and your approach to incentives. The regulator’s short guide for businesses asks you to state your approach to incentivised reviews[5].
References
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). Home buying and selling reform (consultation) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews guidance (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Reviews and social media endorsements: guidance for businesses and brands (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2026). Online consumer reviews (CMA case page) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Online consumer reviews (CMA case page) (opens in a new tab) ↑