Lettings compliance

Tenancy deposit protection schemes compared

Custodial and insured deposit schemes compared for letting agents in England and Wales, with the 30-day deadline, cash-flow effects and dispute handling.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The choice in one paragraph
  2. Custodial and insured side by side
  3. The deadlines that do not change
  4. Cash flow: what insured really changes
  5. How to decide: five questions
  6. Switching schemes without creating risk
  7. What to tell landlords at instruction
  8. Dispute services and your evidence
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Three government-backed schemes operate in England and Wales: Deposit Protection Service, mydeposits and Tenancy Deposit Scheme[1].
  • A custodial scheme holds the money for free; an insured scheme lets the agent or landlord hold it and pay the scheme to insure it[1].
  • Whichever model you choose, protect within 30 days of receipt and return within 10 days of agreement[1].
  • Insured membership means holding client money, which brings client money protection duties with it[2].

The choice in one paragraph

Every letting agency in England and Wales that takes deposits has to pick a protection model. The three approved schemes are the Deposit Protection Service, mydeposits and the Tenancy Deposit Scheme[1]. In a custodial scheme the scheme holds the deposit for free. In an insured scheme the landlord or agent keeps the money and pays the scheme to insure it[1]. The legal deadlines are identical either way, so the decision is really about cash handling, admin load, dispute workflow and what your landlords expect from you.

Statutory deposit deadlines in England and Wales
Statutory deposit deadlines in England and WalesComparison. Protect after receiving the deposit: 30 days; Return after both sides agree the amount: 10 days.30 daysProtect after receiving the depositProtect after receiving the deposit: 30 days10 daysReturn after both sides agree the amountReturn after both sides agree the amount: 10 daysStatutory deposit deadlines in England and WalesComparison. Protect after receiving the deposit: 30 days; Return after both sides agree the amount: 10 days.30 daysProtect after receiving the depositProtect after receiving the deposit: 30 days10 daysReturn after both sides agree theamountReturn after both sides agree the amount: 10 days

Source: GOV.UK, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Protect after receiving the deposit30 days
Return after both sides agree the amount10 days

Agents carry most of the volume. In 2024, 70% of deposits registered with England's schemes were registered by agents on behalf of landlords[3]. The model an agency picks therefore shapes how most tenants experience deposit protection, from the first certificate email to the final repayment.

Custodial and insured side by side

Custodial and insured deposit protection compared
FactorCustodialInsured
Who holds the moneyThe schemeThe agent or landlord, in a client account
ChargesFree to useMembership and protection charges set by the scheme
Cash in your client accountLeaves within 30 daysStays with you for the tenancy
Client money protectionStill needed for rent and other client moneyEssential, because deposits are client money you hold
End of tenancyParties confirm the split; the scheme pays outYou pay out from your account once agreed
If there is a disputeMoney is already with the schemeYou must pass the disputed sum to the scheme
Admin loadUploads, certificates, repayment requestsReconciliation, audits and scheme holding rules
Typical fitSmaller agencies and let-only workManaged portfolios with strong accounting controls

The row that matters most is the dispute row. With an insured scheme, the deposit stays protected until the issue is settled, but the landlord or agent must pass it to the scheme, which then holds it until the dispute ends[1]. If your accounts team is slow to transfer the disputed amount, the dispute stalls, the tenant waits, and an irritation becomes a formal complaint.

The second difference is visibility. Under a custodial model the tenant can see that an independent body holds the money, which tends to reassure first-time renters and overseas tenants. Under an insured model, tenants rely on the scheme's insurance and your client account controls, which you may need to explain at sign-up.

The deadlines that do not change

Model choice never moves the statutory clock. The deposit must be in a scheme within 30 days of the agent or landlord receiving it, and at the end of the tenancy it must be returned within 10 days of both sides agreeing how much the tenant gets back[1]. Build both into your lettings software as system dates rather than reminders in one person's inbox.

  • Start the 30-day count from the date the first deposit payment cleared, not from the tenancy start date.
  • Treat the 10-day return as running from the moment both parties accept a figure in writing, including by email.
  • Record the scheme reference on the tenancy file on the day you protect.
  • Serve the prescribed information alongside the certificate; see serving prescribed information correctly.

Up to 3x

the deposit, which a court can order repaid where a deposit was not protected when it should have been[4]

Getting this wrong is expensive. A tenant can go to the county court, and the court may order the landlord to repay the deposit or pay it into a custodial scheme within 14 days, and also to pay up to three times the original deposit[4]. Landlords tend to look to the agent who held the money.

Cash flow: what insured really changes

Agencies sometimes choose insured protection because holding deposits looks like useful working capital. It is not your money. Deposits held under an insured model sit in a client account, and agents in England who hold client money must belong to a client money protection scheme or face a fine of up to £30,000[2]. The real benefits of insured are control over timing and fewer transfers at the end of each tenancy, not access to the cash.

Example: a managed portfolio of 400 homes with an average deposit of £1,600 means roughly £640,000 sitting in the client account under an insured model. Every pound has to reconcile to a named tenancy each month and survive an accountant's inspection. If month-end reconciliation is already a strain, a custodial model removes that balance from your books entirely and shortens the audit.

The deposit itself is capped, at five weeks' rent where annual rent is below £50,000 and six weeks' where it is £50,000 to £100,000[5], so the largest balances come from higher-rent stock. Check the cap before the money arrives, not after, because an over-cap deposit is a prohibited payment that must be refunded.

How to decide: five questions

  1. How strong is your client accounting?

    If you already reconcile daily and pass independent audits easily, insured is workable. If month-end is a scramble, choose custodial and remove the risk.

  2. What does your landlord mix want?

    Portfolio landlords on full management may prefer you to hold deposits so deductions are settled quickly. Let-only landlords often prefer a scheme that holds the money independently.

  3. How often do tenancies end in dispute?

    If disputes are common, look closely at how fast your team can transfer disputed funds under an insured model, and at each scheme's evidence upload process.

  4. Can your systems talk to the scheme?

    Bulk uploads and repayment requests from lettings software save hours across a portfolio. Ask each scheme which integrations your software supports before you sign up.

  5. Will you mix models?

    Some agencies use custodial for let-only and insured for managed lets. That is allowed, but every file must show which applies, and the prescribed information must match it.

Switching schemes without creating risk

Moving a portfolio between schemes or models is one of the riskiest admin projects a lettings team can run, because every moved deposit needs new protection and new prescribed information. Plan it in small batches and keep evidence for each step.

  1. Export every live deposit with its scheme reference, amount and tenant names.
  2. Protect each deposit with the new scheme before closing it in the old one, so there is never an unprotected gap.
  3. Serve updated certificates and prescribed information to every tenant and relevant payer.
  4. Collect receipts, then close the old protection and reconcile the client account.
  5. Spot-check a sample of moved files a month later.

Tell tenants why you are writing. An unexpected email about their deposit triggers calls and worry, and the Property Ombudsman lists poor, unclear or delayed communication first among the top issues in its lettings disputes[6]. Two plain sentences at the top of the message, saying what changed and that the money is safe, prevent most of those calls.

What to tell landlords at instruction

Landlords rarely ask which deposit model you use until something goes wrong, so put the answer in your terms of business and your instruction call. Explain who will protect the deposit, which scheme and model you use, who serves the prescribed information, and who decides on deductions at the end. If the landlord protects the deposit themselves on a let-only service, get that in writing, together with a promise to send you the certificate so you can confirm it happened.

  • Name the scheme and model in the terms of business.
  • State who serves the prescribed information and how it is evidenced.
  • Explain how deductions are proposed, agreed and paid out.
  • Say what happens to the deposit if the landlord moves from let-only to full management, or leaves the agency.

Example: a landlord moving from let-only to full management midway through a tenancy asks the agency to take over a deposit she protected herself. The agency protects it under its own membership, serves fresh information on both tenants, and only then asks the landlord to release her protection, so the money is never unprotected.

Dispute services and your evidence

Each scheme runs a free alternative dispute resolution service. Adjudicators decide on the written evidence both sides upload, so your check-in report, check-out report and dated photos carry the case. The protection model does not change the evidence standard; it only changes who holds the money while the adjudicator decides.

That is why the best scheme choice is often the one that fits your evidence workflow. Ask how each scheme accepts photos and video, how long uploads stay open, and how the landlord is kept informed. For the evidence itself, read deposit disputes: evidence that wins adjudication and our guide to the deposit cap and holding deposits.

Frequently asked questions

Can an agency use more than one deposit scheme?

Yes. Some agencies use one scheme for let-only landlords and another for managed properties. Each deposit must be protected in one scheme only, and the tenant's prescribed information must name the right one.

Is a custodial scheme really free?

Custodial protection is free for the landlord or agent to use, because the scheme holds the money itself. Insured schemes charge for membership and for insuring each deposit, and those charges vary by scheme, so compare them against the admin time a custodial model saves.

Do the same schemes cover Scotland?

No. The three schemes described here cover England and Wales. Scotland runs its own tenancy deposit regime with separately approved schemes and different rules, so check those before letting there.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: Overview (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2019). Protecting clients' money if you're a property agent (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Private Landlord Survey 2024: main report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). Deposit protection schemes and landlords: If you do not protect your tenants' deposit (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2026). Fees you can charge as part of a tenancy (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. The Property Ombudsman (2025). Annual Review 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo