Property management

Contractor management: building a reliable panel

How letting agents vet contractors: insurance, Gas Safe and electrical competence checks, onboarding paperwork, job instructions and performance reviews.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why the panel is a compliance tool
  2. What the code expects
  3. Vetting checklist
  4. Gas and electrical competence
  5. Sizing the panel
  6. Onboarding a new contractor
  7. Instructions that get the job done right
  8. Contractors in tenants' homes
  9. Protecting against payment fraud
  10. When landlords use their own contractors
  11. Performance reviews
  12. Removing a contractor
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • The Property Ombudsman's England code expects agents to take reasonable steps to check contractors hold indemnity and public liability insurance and suitable qualifications[1].
  • Gas work and checks must be done by an approved person, and electrical inspections by a qualified person[2][3].
  • Verify bank detail changes by phone: phishing was the most common cyber attack on UK businesses in 2025/26[4].
  • Review every panel member at least yearly on response, quality, paperwork and complaints, and drop those who do not improve.

Why the panel is a compliance tool

A contractor panel is often treated as a list of phone numbers. In practice it is one of the main ways an agency meets its legal and ombudsman obligations. Every gas check, electrical inspection and damp repair you arrange is only as good as the person who carries it out, and if a council serves a notice, your contractors decide whether you meet its deadline.

The stakes have risen. Under the updated HHSRS guidance, the maximum civil penalty for failing to comply with an improvement notice is £40,000, up from £30,000 for offences committed before 1 May 2026[5]. A panel that cannot deliver on time is a direct risk to landlords and to your agency.

Maximum civil penalty for failing to comply with an HHSRS improvement notice
Maximum civil penalty for failing to comply with an HHSRS improvement noticeComparison. Offences before 1 May 2026: £30,000; Offences from 1 May 2026: £40,000.£30,000Offences before 1 May 2026Offences before 1 May 2026: £30,000£40,000Offences from 1 May 2026Offences from 1 May 2026: £40,000Maximum civil penalty for failing to comply with an HHSRS improvement noticeComparison. Offences before 1 May 2026: £30,000; Offences from 1 May 2026: £40,000.£30,000Offences before 1 May 2026Offences before 1 May 2026: £30,000£40,000Offences from 1 May 2026Offences from 1 May 2026: £40,000

Source: GOV.UK, 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Offences before 1 May 2026£30,000
Offences from 1 May 2026£40,000

What the code expects

The Property Ombudsman's England code says agents must be prudent in selecting, appointing and using contractors who work for landlords. It expects reasonable steps to ensure contractors hold relevant professional indemnity and public liability insurance and possess suitable qualifications or applicable professional or trade membership where required[1]. It also expects instructions that indicate urgency and scope, and quotes and invoices with a detailed breakdown of the work and cost[1]. Build your vetting and job process directly from those expectations.

Vetting checklist

Contractor vetting checklist for a lettings panel
CheckWhat to collectHow often
Identity and businessCompany or sole trader details, address, VAT number if registeredAt onboarding
Public liability insuranceCertificate showing cover and expiryAt onboarding and each renewal
Professional indemnity, where relevantCertificate for design, survey or advice workAt onboarding and each renewal
Gas competenceGas Safe Register details, checked against the engineer's ID card for the work types they will doAt onboarding and annually
Electrical competenceQualifications and competent person scheme membership, such as NICEIC or NAPITAt onboarding and annually
Specialist workEvidence for asbestos, damp, fire alarm or other specialist workAt onboarding
ReferencesTwo recent references from agents or landlordsAt onboarding
Bank detailsConfirmed by a call to a known number, never by email aloneAt onboarding and any change

Put every expiry date into your compliance tracker, not the contractor's file. An insurance certificate that lapsed six months ago is as useless as none.

Gas and electrical competence

Gas safety law is specific about who may do the work. Under regulation 36 of the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998, landlords' safety checks and work must be carried out by an approved person or an employee of an approved body[2]. In practice that means an engineer on the Gas Safe Register who is qualified for the specific appliance types in your properties. Check the engineer's ID card for the categories they cover, not just that they are registered.

For electrics, landlords in England must have installations checked at least every 5 years by a properly qualified person[3]. The government guidance links to a register of competent person schemes to help find one but does not make membership mandatory[6]. Membership is still the simplest evidence of competence for a panel, so ask for it and check it, and where it is missing ask for qualifications and insurance that cover inspection and testing.

Sizing the panel

A panel that is too small fails in winter; one that is too large means no contractor gets enough work to prioritise you. Start from the trades you need and the coverage each one gives.

  • At least two contractors for each emergency trade: gas and heating, plumbing, electrical, locksmith and drainage.
  • One or two for each routine trade: general maintenance, decorating, roofing and gutters, glazing, pest control and cleaning.
  • Specialists on call rather than on the rota: damp surveyors, asbestos surveyors, fire alarm engineers and arborists.
  • Clear geographic coverage, so a contractor is not crossing the county for an urgent job.
  • Named out-of-hours cover for each emergency trade, with a phone number tested every quarter.

Spread work deliberately. Contractors who receive steady volume from your branch are more likely to answer at 7am on a Sunday.

Onboarding a new contractor

  1. Collect the documents

    Insurance, competence evidence, references and business details, checked by a second person.

  2. Agree the terms

    Rates or quoting rules, payment terms, response commitments by priority band, out-of-hours availability and photo requirements.

  3. Brief them on your standards

    How to contact tenants, what to do if access fails, the need to stop and call if they find asbestos or a hazard, and how to report completion.

  4. Set up payment securely

    Confirm bank details by phone to a number from your own records, and record who confirmed and when.

  5. Start with a trial

    Give the first few jobs to a supervisor to check before adding them to the full rota.

Instructions that get the job done right

Most poor outcomes trace back to poor instructions. Every works order should state the property, access arrangements, tenant contact, a clear description of the fault with photos, the priority and target date, any approval limit, safety information such as presumed asbestos in older buildings, and what evidence you need on completion. The code expects instructions to indicate urgency and, within reason, the scope or scale of the works[1].

  • Ask for before and after photos on every job.
  • Require a call before any extra work above the approved amount.
  • Ask for invoices that show what was done, where and at what cost[1].
  • Agree a rule for what happens when access fails, so missed visits are not billed without evidence.

Contractors in tenants' homes

Contractors are the face of your agency in a tenant's home, often more than your own staff. Set expectations for conduct as clearly as for workmanship: arrive in the agreed window or call ahead, carry identification, explain what they are doing, protect floors and furniture, leave the property clean and secure, and never discuss the landlord's business or other tenants. Ask tenants for brief feedback after larger jobs, and treat a complaint about conduct as seriously as one about quality. A contractor who does good work but upsets tenants still generates complaints that land with you.

Protecting against payment fraud

Contractor payments are a favourite target for fraud. A fake email from a familiar contractor asking you to update their bank details can divert thousands of pounds of landlords' money. Phishing was the most common cyber attack on UK businesses in 2025/26, experienced by 38% of businesses[4].

Never change a contractor's bank details on the strength of an email or message. Call them on the number already in your records, confirm the change, record who confirmed it, and have a second person approve the change before the next payment run.

When landlords use their own contractors

Some landlords insist on a relative, a friend or their own handyman. That is their right on many jobs, but it creates risk for the agent if the work is poor, unsafe or uninsured. Set the rules in the terms of business: landlord-appointed contractors must provide the same insurance and competence evidence as panel members before you will give them keys or tenant details, safety-critical work must be done by appropriately registered or qualified people, and the landlord takes responsibility for the contractor's work and conduct.

Record every landlord-appointed contractor on the property file with their documents, and do not instruct them yourself unless they meet your standards. If a tenant complains about their work, deal with the complaint promptly and pass it to the landlord in writing, but be clear that the contractor was the landlord's choice.

Performance reviews

Review each contractor at least once a year, and the busiest ones every quarter. Use the same scorecard for everyone.

Example contractor scorecard with fictional targets
MeasureSourceTarget (Example)
Response within the agreed band timeJob records90% of jobs
First-time fixJob records80% of jobs
Completion photos and invoices with breakdownJob recordsEvery job
Tenant complaints about the contractorComplaints logNone upheld
Insurance and competence documents in dateCompliance trackerAlways

Example (fictional): a heating engineer on the panel scores well on quality but misses response targets in winter because he works alone. The property manager agrees a second engineer for emergency cover from November to February, keeps the first for routine and servicing work, and the winter response figure recovers the following year. Share scorecards with contractors; most improve when they can see the numbers.

Removing a contractor

Have a clear rule for removal: any safety failure, any upheld complaint about conduct in a tenant's home, lapsed insurance or competence, or two consecutive reviews below target. Tell the contractor in writing, settle outstanding invoices properly, and update the panel list the same day so nobody books them by habit. Keep the reasons on file in case of a dispute.

Frequently asked questions

What checks should a letting agent do on contractors?

Insurance, competence for the work they do, references and verified bank details. The ombudsman code expects reasonable steps to check indemnity and public liability insurance and suitable qualifications[1].

Who can do a landlord gas safety check?

An approved person under the gas safety regulations[2], which in practice means a Gas Safe registered engineer qualified for the appliances concerned.

Does an electrician need to be in a competent person scheme?

The government guidance asks for a qualified person and links to competent person registers but does not make membership mandatory[6]. It remains the simplest evidence of competence.

References

  1. The Property Ombudsman (2026). Code of Practice for Residential Letting Agents (England), effective 1 May 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1998). The Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998, regulation 36 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Electrical safety standards in the private and social rented sectors: guidance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (GOV.UK) (2026). Cyber security breaches survey 2025/2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). Landlord and agent guide to the Housing Health and Safety Rating System (HHSRS) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2025). Electrical safety standards in the private and social rented sectors: guidance (full guide) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo